Leslie Pankey, Broker, Five Star Realty
Leslie Pankey is a dedicated and licensed real estate broker based in Carbondale, Illinois, representing clients through Five Star Realty Professional, LLC. A longtime resident of the area since 1987, Leslie brings deep local expertise and a genuine passion for helping buyers and sellers achieve their real estate goals. Her approach is built on enthusiasm, sincerity, and a talent for identifying smart investments and hidden gems in the Southern Illinois market.
Leslie serves not only Carbondale but also the broader Southern Illinois region, including Makanda, Murphysboro, Carterville, Cobden, Herrin, Anna-Jonesboro, and Marion. Whether you are looking for a luxury home, a fixer-upper, commercial property, or rental opportunities, Leslie provides personalized guidance to ensure your real estate experience is smooth and successful. She is committed to customer satisfaction as her top priority, ensuring you feel confident and well-informed at every step.
Five Star Realty is known for making real estate a breeze, offering comprehensive services for both sales and rentals. The brokerage’s team, led by designated managing brokers, works to provide expert advice on affordability, credit, and market trends. With a strong focus on results and professional service, Leslie Pankey and her colleagues at Five Star Realty are here to guide you through your property adventure with care and expertise.
Opening hours
Photos of Leslie Pankey, Broker, Five Star Realty
Leslie Pankey, Broker, Five Star Realty: Reviews
Reviews are the opinions of their authors. We do not verify that the author was a customer.
Reviews on Google
4,9 out of 5 from 54 reviews
Fantastic experience: Leslie Pankey is the best realtor in Carbondale! We got her contact from someone who found their home through her a couple of years ago, and we were so glad we did. The first thing we liked about Leslie is her quick response time, her persistence, and her honesty. She got right on the phone with us to discuss our needs and available inventory. She consistently kept us up to date with new listings and was easily reached by text or phone. Being first time home buyers, we appreciated her constant support, thorough knowledge of the area, and the process of buying a home in Illinois. Leslie even found us a very competent and honest mortgage banker, and we are forever grateful for that help. Because of Leslie's clear guidance and dedication, we found a perfect home that met all of our criteria. The process from there was smooth and easy. As a final touch, she even bought us a Ring doorbell setup as a welcome home gift! She supported us from beginning to end, and also helped us to settle in to the area by providing local contacts and information about utilities, water, and other services. We love our new home and can't recommend Leslie enough. She's five-stars in every way!
Allison, I'm thrilled that the home buying experience was a positive one for you! Thank you for the kind words. The home buying process can be stressful - so glad you found our journey together to be a smooth one!
Fantastic experience: Absolutely the best at taking care of of both seller and buyer. You can't go wrong having Leslie Pankey as your representative. Thanks Leslie for a great experience.
Thank you, Cecil! Welcome back to Southern Illinois! And thank you for the kind words!
Fantastic experience: I live four hours away from Carbondale. My daughter will be going to SIU and I needed to find the perfect house for her to stay in for the next few years. I explain to Leslie what was important to me and she found the perfect house. As a matter fact, I trusted her so much I never saw the house in person. We only did a video walk-through, and I saw pictures. When I arrived, she did not disappoint me. the house is perfect. I totally recommend her for your real estate needs.
Talana, it was a pleasure working with you! I hope your daughter and her pups are happy in the house and wish her the best in the Aviation school!
Fantastic experience: Incredibly professional and very driven realtor. Went above and beyond to make sure the transaction went through smoothly, and kept me updated every step of the way.
Fantastic experience: I love 5 star loved the experience of renting with them pat is the greatest ever.
Fantastic experience: My husband and I loved working with Leslie! Leslie was so helpful in guiding us through the process as first-time homebuyers. She was highly responsive, honest with her opinions, and definitely had our best interests in mind. She's also very well connected and has great recommendations for who to work with in Carbondale, for everything from home inspections to painting services. I highly recommend choosing Leslie as your realtor.
Emily, thank you for the kind words! It was great working with you and James! Congratulations again on your first home! I’m going to look forward to seeing your home as you put your personal stamp in it!
Fantastic experience: Thank you, Leslie! It was so easy to work with you and together we found a great new home. You understood our requests and the challenges we experienced moving from out of State. You provided great information and offered suggestions so we could confidently navigate the purchase and closing. We felt that you went the extra mile and we are very grateful for your help. Best to you! Candace
Fantastic experience: Leslie is an excellent realtor. She took the time to listen to our specific requirements and look for the home that met our needs. We conducted the purchase from out of state so it could have been much more difficult for use if it had not been for Leslies help in all aspects of the purchase. Leslie followed up with the sale by providing contacts to get all the little thing done that are so important in moving in. Thanks Leslie, I wish you covered every area we've purchased in, all home sales should be this easy.
I'm so glad that you had a positive experience purchasing the home here. My goal is to make the process as easy and stressless as possible! Thank you for the great review!
Fantastic experience: Leslie was absolutely incredible through the entire process of selling our house. She was able to resolve potential issues before they became a problem with the sell of our house and was ALWAYS pleasant to work with. She's extremely knowledgeable and offered great advise!!
Y'all were a pleasure to work with! Wish you the best out east - enjoy that ocean!
Fantastic experience: We feel so lucky to have found Leslie as our realtor! My husband and I moved across the country for a new work opportunity and knew NOTHING about the area, the local housing market, or, frankly, what we were doing when it came to finding a home. We had a three-day window to find a house, and Leslie made it happen. She took time to understand what we were looking for and efficiently scheduled our limited time. Now that we have been settled for about six months, we are very happy. We love our neighborhood and our house, and we couldn't have done this on our own. Leslie helped us through every step of the complex process, responded quickly to all of our questions, and helped make what could have been a stressful experience, an enjoyable one. We put our complete trust in her and we are glad we did.
Gail, I'm so glad that the house has met your expectations! Thank you for the awesome review. I'm glad we hit a home run!
Fantastic experience: Leslie patiently showed me many homes for several years (!), and I never once felt pressured into making any decisions. When I did find the right home, Leslie had the difficult task of representing both buyer and seller. She did so with complete integrity, honesty, and fairness. She is straightforward, helpful, responsive, and ethical. I would highly recommend her.
Patrick, your positive review made my day! It was worth the wait to find your forever home in Carbondale! Wish you the best!
Fantastic experience: Leslie was an absolute pleasure to work with, she was attentive to our wants and needs for a home. My husband and I had never bought a house before and she didn't give up until we found our perfect home. She was able to walk us through the entire process and there's no way we could have done it without her. We are so grateful that we had the opportunity to work with her.
Emily, thank you for the kind words and valuable feedback! I was thrilled that everything worked out so smoothly and we found a great home in Carbondale! Best to you and Jesse!
Fantastic experience: It was my husband and I's first time purchasing a home and we couldn't have had anyone better than Leslie Pankey to help us through that process. She is knowledgeable, engaged and accountable. She helped us throughout the entirety of the process from prep-work all the way to handing us the key to our new home. If you want a smooth and pleasant experience when buying and or selling your next home, go no further, Leslie is the right person for you.
Mackenzie, it was a pleasure helping you and Austin find a home here! Wish you both the best!
Fantastic experience: We didn’t know a realtor in the Carbondale area. I read reviews and Leslie’s were great. We were moving from Clearwater, Fl to this area, not knowing anyone and only visiting the area once was going to be a task for any realtor. I spoke with Leslie and she immediately started sending us houses to review. We found a home in Cobden, it was only on the market for 2 days and we decided to make an offer site unseen. Leslie did a excellent, thorough FaceTime video tour. She did an amazing job for us, always had our back and her expertise and solid suggestions and quick response to calls, texts, etc helped made our dream come true. We highly recommend Leslie without any reservations whatsoever! Thank you so much for going above and beyond for us. Thank you, Kathy & Roberto Coccia
Thank you for the kind words, Kathy! Welcome to Illinois! Im looking forward to Roberto and your progress in the vineyard!
Fantastic experience: Leslie was professional and worked very hard to help sell our home. She was always available and very down to earth.
It was great working with you Scott! Hope you find a wonderful new home out east!
Fantastic experience: Leslie Pankey is simply the best realtor I've dealt with. She is very responsive and stays constantly in touch. She is ethical and is careful in all her business dealings. She listens carefully and asks all the important questions. She is enthusiastic and does everything in her power to accommodate both the seller and the buyer. I would trust her with anything. I strongly recommend Leslie for anyone looking to sell!
Ed, it was a pleasure working with you and Casey! I'm so glad that the house will continue to be loved and cared for and know you'll always be welcome there. Thank you for the kind words!
Fantastic experience: Professionally guiding through the house selling process and producing a satisfactory result
Thank you, Steve!
Fantastic experience: If you are looking to buy or sell a home in Carbondale, I highly recommend Leslie Pankey. She sold my parents' home, coordinating every detail and communicating with my parents (who had moved away already) and me (I was helping, and I don't live in Carbondale anymore). Everything went very smoothly, in large part because Leslie was running the show.
Sarita, it was a pleasure working with you. I especially enjoyed speaking !with your father through the transaction and am glad things went so smoothly
Fantastic experience: We had so many complications in our purchase and Leslie was there all of the way through it and well beyond. She was amazing all of the way through the process and well after it as well! Leslie is truly dedicated to her clients.
Jeanne, I’m so glad things worked out and the house has lived up to your expectations! Don’t hesitate to reach out if there are any “bumps” in the road!
Fantastic experience: Leslie was a great broker to deal with and really provided knowledgeable full service to help sell the property and solve problems. She went the extra mile to get the deal done.
I’m so glad that we had smooth sailing! Your Dad definitely had a vision when he designed the home in the woods. The new owners are thrilled with the house!
Fantastic experience: We were purchasing a house in Carbondale that needed some work and since we live out of state, Leslie went above and beyond in helping us get estimates from local contractors that she knew did quality work. She was professional, knowledgeable and VERY helpful with our unique situation. I highly recommend her to anyone who is looking buy or sell a rental, starter house, or their forever home!! She is truly looking out for her clients
Shaun it was great meeting you and Abbie to help with your house hunt! She is going to love the neighborhood and proximity to campus. If you need any other tradespeople I know some great ones! Take care!
Fantastic experience: Leslie Pankey was a pleasure to work with. My calls/texts were always answered promptly. She was respectful of my needs during the sale and always up front about the transaction. She goes the extra mile and is always pleasant. I highly recommend Leslie to anyone who is interested in finding a relator who will be timely, go the extra mile and sell your property in a professional manner. She is the BEST. Our house was sold in a day!
Terri, it was a pleasure getting to know you through! Your Mom’s special home has happy new owners, who I’m sure will love the house just as y’all have! Hope to see you again soon!
Negative experience: I was really disappointed that my experience with Leslie did not match what others said in these reviews. She was rude and unprofessional.
Hi Casey,
I'm extremely sorry for my lack of professionalism. I've gone through our emails and realize that we only spoke once but emailed several times and to my embarrassment found that i forgot to hit "send" on my last email. If you're still looking for a home, I'd be glad to recommend an agent in my office who would be glad to help you and your Mom find a home in the area. Again, my most sincere apologies. And I'm sorry if you found me rude when we spoke.
Fantastic experience: Lesley listed my property, which was promptly sold within a few months. She patiently answered all of my questions. Highly recommended!
Thank you for the kind review! I hope all your future real estate transactions sell as quickly!
Fantastic experience: Leslie Pankey may be the best real estate agent I have ever known. She is smart, incisive, quick and discreet. She is knowledgable, humorous and indefatigable. She drives a good bargain - but she makes sure you are central to the transaction. She can be trusted.
Thank you for the kind words! You and Jane have been great. Here’s to future success in all your real estate ventures!
Fantastic experience: Leslie did a great job selling my home and I enjoyed my interactions with her. I couldn't have wished for a better agent.
Marie, it was a pleasure working with you! Everything just fell into place for you!
Fantastic experience: I have bought a house from Leslie and used Leslie to sell a house. She is the only agent I would use in Southern Illinois! She knows how to get the deal closed and I always felt like she was looking out for my best interest and both closings were seamless! She answered all my questions about the home buying/selling process. I would not use anyone other than Leslie to buy or sell a house!
Thank you, Anne! You've been a pleasure to get to know and work with. Best to you down south!
Fantastic experience: Leslie is very friendly and honest. We love working with her!!!! When showing homes, she makes sure to show us the bad along with the good points in the property. She is patient and understanding. I highly recommend her!!!
So happy that everything has worked out! You'll be Southern Illinoisans before you know it!
Fantastic experience: Knows her stuff and always on top of things.
Eileen, it's been fun working with you! Best to you up north!
Fantastic experience: She is so professional and with so much experience that she will make your experience painless. Excellent professional and the best realtor ever I have worked
I'm so glad that things worked out for you! Good luck in KC!
Fantastic experience: We are very happy to have found Leslie Pankey.she is very professional,nice and always happy to answer any questions we have she has helped us every step of the way through this delicate journey of our new beginnings and we will be closing on our very first house me and my husband are very pleased
We are in the home stretch! I'm excited for your both!
Fantastic experience: Our house in Carbondale had been on the market for almost a year when we began to work with Leslie Pankey. Not only did she quickly find us a buyer, she worked tirelessly and efficiently to facilitate the sale. Leslie is an excellent communicator and was always available to answer our questions. She also goes above and beyond: dealing with teething troubles like finding a handyman and communicating with various builders, inspectors and service people. We especially appreciated this since we had moved away from the area and couldn't deal with these issues ourselves.
Fantastic experience: Bought my first home and really knew little about the process (if anything), and Leslie made it such a clear and smooth path right through it. Went above and beyond. She immediately felt like a friend. Great, great experience. And got us a great deal to boot! I would and will recommend her to anyone I know looking to buy a house. :)
Fantastic experience: Leslie Pankey Is an excellent Real Estate Agent. I bought a home from her and she helped me sell one. She works closely with you, guiding you through everything that needs to be done. She can find companies and agencies to accomplish the sale.
Fantastic experience: Leslie was very helpful when it came to the feedback from potential buyers. She was very professional in selling our house and has a lot of experience in the field.
You and George are definitely missed in Woodland Hills! So glad you landed in such a tax friendly area!
Fantastic experience: Leslie Pankey is in one word ' impeccable'. A top of the line professional. Always prompt to answer questions. Always with alacrity in all transactions. Extremely knowledgeable of the house, surrounding areas, shopping, craft people in the area. Directed us to a mortgage lender, electrician, plumber, lock smith, inspection service, and all that we requested. A pleasant, personable gentlelady. The best real estate person that I have worked with in the last 40 years.
George, it was a pleasure working with you, Ann and Sarah! I look forward to seeing you again in Carbondale soon. Good luck with the B & B! If my husband and I ever get up to your neck of the woods, I'll look forward to paying you a visit!
Fantastic experience: Leslie is a great realtor who knows the region very well! We had the pleasure of working with her twice: she was the seller's agent when we bought our home and was our agent when we sold the home 12 years later! Would highly recommend her to anyone looking for an agent!
Fantastic experience: Wonderful realtor... I can't say enough good things about Leslie. She's has a great personality, is easy to work with, and knows her stuff. I couldn't have sold my house quickly without her and I'm so grateful we chose Leslie!
It was a pleasure to work with you both! I wish you the best in your new home and in all your future real estate endeavors!
Fantastic experience: Leslie is working with my husband and me as we plan a relocation to Southern Illinois. She is well informed on all aspects related to the real estate world. In addition, she is very knowledgeable about the region as a whole. She is also very personable and fun to work with. I would highly recommend Leslie to anyone buying or selling a home. She’s the BEST.
Thank you, Dianne! Looking forward to your next trip south to continue the search!
Fantastic experience: Leslie was our saving grace in a whirlwind of bad luck. She was extremely responsive and always went out of her way to reach out to the other real estate agents, clients, etc. She provided us with honest advise (even when we didn't want to hear it!). I always trusted her and I knew we were being taken care of. I can't say enough about how glad I am that we listed our home with her!!! Thanks for everything, Leslie!
Fantastic experience: Leslie is the best! She helped us sell our home a couple of years ago, and really worked with us... giving us honest feedback, which we sincerely appreciated. If we look to buy or sell in Jackson or Williamson counties, we will definitely call on Leslie again!!
Thank you, Lexie! So grateful to have worked with you and it's great to hear from you! I appreciate you taking time to leave me a review and hope we get a chance to work together again. Take care!
Fantastic experience: Leslie was wonderful to work with. Since it had been 20 years since we last bought/sold a house her expertise was greatly appreciated. She always notified us well in advance when she had a client who wanted to view the house. Client's feed-back was always prompt. When we received an offer on the house she explained it and answered our questions. Closing was a snap! No mystery moments! Always available for questions and quick to respond. Would recommend her without exception!
Thank you, Connie! It was a pleasure to work with you and I am so glad we were able to sell your home! Best wishes for your future!
Fantastic experience: Leslie is AMAZING! She is extremely knowledgable, patient, kind, and is always honest! I am new to the area & she has gone above & beyond to help me in my search for a new home and always shared her vast knowledge on a array of vital information needed when purchasing a home.
Thank you, Alicia! I have confidence that your next endeavor will be a great success!
Fantastic experience: Leslie Pankey is by far one of the best realtors I have done business with. She is very well knowledgeable and is very helpful through out the whole process. A major bonus about her is that she does more than just sell you a house, she makes it her personal goal to make sure you find the best house for you. Also she will give you recommendation on the house it's self and the people to do the rest of the process ( bank, inspector, carpenter, plumber, ect.) If you need it she will most likely know who is the best to use. I absolutely loved working with her and look forward to doing more business with her.
Thank you, Branden! We are in the home stretch! You and Cheyenne will be celebrating the Holiday in your new home! I'm so happy for you both!
Fantastic experience: Leslie Pankey is an outstanding agent and always went above and beyond to help us get the house we wanted and even helped us out long after the sale. Highly recommended!!!
Thank you, Chris! Be sure to let me know how your appeal works out!
Fantastic experience: Leslie is a professional, knowledgeable and thoughtful agent! This is our second time to work with her in buying a new home. And she nailed it again!
Fantastic experience: If you're looking to buy or sell a home in the Southern Illinois region, I highly recommend doing so through Leslie, especially if you are a first time home buyer. She is incredibly patient, kind, knowledgeable, and trustworthy. I purchased one home through her several years ago and am now in the process of selling that home and buying a new one with her help. She has always taken the time to explain everything about the process and answer even the most silly questions in great detail. She regularly goes out of her way to work around my schedule and is always willing to fight for her clients. She is an absolute joy to work with.
Thank you, David! It's been such a pleasure working with you and your lovely, wife!
Fantastic experience: Leslie Pankey was wonderful to work with. She responds to emails and returns phone calls very quickly. Absolutely great and friendly person. You will be happy you gave her the opportunity to assist you with all of your real estate needs. I promise!
Fantastic experience: Leslie really knows the business and the Carbondale real estate market so well. And you can trust her to be honest with you and help you through the process. We bought one house and sold another through her and we have recommended her to friends. It's a pleasure to work with her and you know you're in good hands.
Fantastic experience: Leslie is a consummate professional and she made the home buying/selling process very enjoyable for us. We bought our first home in southern Illinois with her, and she was exceedingly patient and helpful. When the time came to look for something a little bigger, she was there to help again in a million different ways. She is the best!!
Fantastic experience: Not only is Leslie Pankey the best realtor around, she is also one of the best people around. We have worked with Leslie on all 3 of our house sales/purchases since we have been in southern Illinois and in each case we have been so thankful for her expertise and support. Many realtors are giant windbags who like to talk nonsense and blow smoke in an attempt to sell properties, but not Leslie - she keeps it real. She had our trust from day one and she is the consummate professional. Beyond that, she is a pillar in the community - I am proud to call her a friend. Go with Leslie Pankey - you won't regret it. She is the BEST.
Fantastic experience: Leslie is my favorite Realtor in Southern IL. I am extremely hard on realtors and expect a lot out of them and Leslie has never disappointed. She is extremely knowledgeable and honest. She sold a house for me years ago in Desoto within a few weeks and ever since I have used her to sell several others and bought my personal home through her and several friends have all loved their experiences with her. YOU WONT BE DISAPPOINTED!!!!!
Leave your opinion about Leslie Pankey, Broker, Five Star Realty:
Leslie Pankey, Broker, Five Star Realty appears in the following listings:
Other real estate agencies you might be interested in
Add your real estate agency to our directory for free
If you manage a real estate agency and want to appear in our guide, send us your company information and you can appear completely free of charge.