Finger Lakes Only Irish Realtor

Fantastic experience: We can't speak highly enough of our experience with Paul! This is the second home we have sold and Paul was our agent on both homes. Just like the first time, Paul was on top of everything from start to finish. He communicated with us frequently and professionally, and took the time to explain each step of the process. He also helped us with the process of purchasing our current home. We are incredibly grateful for all of Paul's hard work and would highly recommend him to anyone looking to buy or sell a home. Thank you Paul for helping us through such an important milestone!

Fantastic experience: Paul was great to work with in purchasing our home! He’s very responsive and made the whole process great! I will definitely be using him any future real estate investments!

Fantastic experience: Paul is extremely knowledgeable, personable, and efficient in what he does! He has been very responsive and flexible throughout our home buying process. He looks out for your best interest, not just a sale, and is honest and reliable. If you’re looking for a realtor that easily turns into someone you can call a friend, reach out to Paul!

Fantastic experience: Paul was very knowledgeable throughout the sale of our house. He told us what was going to need to be fixed before we listed it. Even if things weren't going our way, Paul remained positive and optimistic throughout the process. We appreciate him so much!

Fantastic experience: Absolutely recommend! He made selling my house so easy. Took care of all the stressful things and made it absolutely stress free! Also closed super quickly! Thank you Paul!

Fantastic experience: Our recent experience with Mr. Tyrrell was pleasant and professional! His knowledge of the current market in our area proved beneficial in the sale of our home. We were able to have the home prepared as he suggested and ready for the showings. Mr. Tyrrell’s guidance through the legal work was especially appreciated! Overall, we were extremely impressed with how easy Mr. Tyrrell made this major undertaking in our life!

Fantastic experience: We had an amazing experience working with Paul on the purchase of our lake house. From start to finish, Paul was extremely responsive and always available to answer questions or provide guidance. He went above and beyond what is normally expected of a realtor, and his knowledge of the market and the home-buying process made us feel confident every step of the way. Paul was an invaluable resource as we toured prospective homes, pointing out details we wouldn’t have noticed ourselves, and he was incredible in helping us navigate a tense lead-up to closing. He also encouraged us to see a property we had initially dismissed after spotting it online — and that ended up being the home we purchased. We are so grateful for his professionalism, dedication, and support — we couldn’t recommend him more highly!

Fantastic experience: Loved working with Paul, he is very professional and kept on top of everything during our buying process. I would reccomend Paul Tyrrell to anyone selling/buying a home!

Fantastic experience: We couldn’t have asked for a better Realtor to sell our Lake home than Paul Tyrrell! From start to finish, Paul brought an incredible level of professionalism, market insight, and genuine care that made the entire process smooth and stress-free. Paul provided expert guidance on staging, pricing, and timing our listing just right. Thanks to his strategy and dedication, our home attracted a cash offer almost immediately and sold faster than we expected—at a great price! What truly set Paul apart was his consistent communication and personal attention to every detail. We never felt like just another client—Paul treated our home sale as if it were his own, always making us feel confident and supported through each step. If you’re looking to sell your home, we wholeheartedly recommend Paul Tyrrell. He’s not just a Realtor—he’s a trusted professional who truly goes above and beyond for his clients.

Fantastic experience: Paul is awesome, second time we've used him and would definitely recommend him to anyone. He's honest and up front, has a sense of humor, easy to talk with and, IMO, really understood my queen and I, I truly feel he legitimately wanted the best for us. Great guy

Fantastic experience: Paul works very quickly and efficiently, always making the process as smooth as possible for us. He always makes himself available for any questions or issues that arise! Best realtor in the finger lakes!

Fantastic experience: Paul is awesome!! He is so patient and very honest about every house he showed my wife and I. He didn't just try to sell us any old house but really looked out for our best interest and always went over the pros and cons with each property. Other agents gave you the feeling they were just trying to sell anything. I would highly recommend Paul to anyone looking for an honest and reliable agent!!

Fantastic experience: Paul is everything you want in a person and a realtor: friendly, hard working, gives great advice, Irish. I manifested the street and the house, just needed the right person to come and help us get the right deal. Paul was the guy! 10/10 would recommend.

Fantastic experience: Paul did an awesome job helping us sell our old home and buy a new home. He is very professional and has great attention to detail. Would highly recommend!

Fantastic experience: Paul did a wonderful job for us. He always kept us up-to-date on what was happening; gave good advice and found folks to step in and get things done. Our listing was outstanding and had lots of "hits". He is also a special person.

Fantastic experience: Paul was great to work with! He communicated consistently and clearly, was helpful to navigate uncertainty and followed through with every detail. We highly recommend him as a realtor.

Fantastic experience: We recently sold our family lake home, and Paul Tyrell was instrumental in making the process smooth and successful. His extensive knowledge of lake property sales was evident from the start. After we accepted an offer, Paul diligently handled all the necessary steps to ensure we closed on time. When our father passed away just two days after signing the contract, Paul was incredibly supportive. He made sure we had the time and space to grieve, which meant a lot to us during such a difficult time. I wholeheartedly recommend Paul to anyone considering buying or selling lake property in the Finger Lakes. His expertise and dedication to his clients are truly exceptional.

Fantastic experience: Paul was great to work with! Excellent communication and everything was handled in a timely manner. Highly recommend!!

Fantastic experience: I could not recommend Paul enough He is kind, patient and above all professional. Your search for a realtor should end with him. Thank you Paul- Bier Bau

Fantastic experience: Ran into this guy at my work - super friendly and charming, would absolutely utilize him as a realtor and recommend him!

Fantastic experience: Paul assisted us with finding and purchasing our new home. He was prompt and thorough throughout the entire process. Definitely the best in the business!

Fantastic experience: We have benefitted from Paul’s real estate expertise on multiple properties, and feel fortunate to have him as our realtor! His knowledge, patience and sense of humor help to reduce the stress associated with buying and selling. Paul goes above and beyond and we will definitely continue to use him again in the future!

Fantastic experience: We are so lucky to have chosen Paul to be our realtor! We came from out of state and he always made time for us-even on the weekends and in the evenings. He was extremely patient with our millions of questions. He is well versed about the market and never steered us wrong. He was always responsive and replied quickly with accurate and informative answers. He was honest with us about all the properties we saw. He is also very knowledgeable about the area and has a robust professional network of contacts. We are so grateful to Paul-if we ever buy/sell again, we would love to work with him again.

Fantastic experience: Paul has helped with a few house sales now and has performed in excellent fashion, in every single facet, every single time! He is thorough, responsive, and a man of honor who follows through with what he promises to do. THAT is a rarity in our current world and a sign of character. I would strongly suggest him as a representative for your real estate needs!

Fantastic experience: My partner and I were on the hunt for a home and really fell in love with the Finger Lakes. We found Paul after searching for highly rated realtors in the region (we’re from out of state), and we quickly saw how well-deserved the good reviews are! Paul is honest, and a straight talker. He has a strong local network, and is an expert in his market. Just tell him what kind of home you’re looking for, and he has the insight to help you decide if what you’re looking at is the right choice for you and your situation. Ultimately, a home purchase is a huge decision that always lies with us as buyers, and this can be intimidating. Paul doesn’t pressure, he truly advises & counsels - he is there to serve, not just “sell.” Another reason that led to our choosing Paul is communication. We had an agent who dropped the ball and was not timely with phone calls and texts. Paul picked that ball up and ran with it! All phone calls/texts/emails were answered promptly and he would even check-in periodically to see how we were doing. I highly recommend Paul whether buying or selling a property in the Finger Lakes. He’s a class act and an expert in his field. You can’t go wrong with the area’s only Irish realtor!

Fantastic experience: Paul has been very helpful and thorough in helping us find and sell local properties. Very personable and informative, follows through and keeps you up to date timely. Extremely trustworthy and good at his job. We will use him next time the need arises.

Fantastic experience: When I first decided to sell my home I must admit that even just the thought of it was overwhelming. Where do you start? What do you do? Who do you call? How do you do all of this? The answer was simple. Paul Tyrrell! Just like that in one phone call everything was taken care of. And when I say everything I mean everything. His knowledge of what needs to be done and how to get it done is impeccable. His attention to detail and attentiveness to his customers is incomparable. The process of selling my house went so smooth and it really is all because of Paul. He is an amazing guy and really gives his all to his clients. I would highly recommend giving him a call today!

Fantastic experience: I recently had the pleasure of working with Paul. Paul was very professional and highly knowledgeable at each step in the process. I am very pleased I chose Paul for my real estate process needs.

Fantastic experience: Whether buying or selling a home, I would not choose any other realtor than Paul Tyrell. He makes the entire process seamless and will always go the extra mile to make sure your needs are taken care of. I have worked with Paul several times now and he continues to exceed my expectations.

Fantastic experience: This was my first time buying a home, and Paul was very helpful throughout the entire process and always returned my calls. I’m very happy in my new home!

Fantastic experience: Paul, Worked extremely hard selling my property on Keuka Lake! He was committed, thoughtful, timely & on top of everything!! There's only 1 Irish realtor!

Fantastic experience: Paul is my favorite Irish realtor!!!

Fantastic experience: Working with Paul was a positive experience, always very professional, and very knowledgeable in local real estate.

Fantastic experience: Paul worked tirelessly with us for over a year, never bothered by the many, sometimes random, questions. When it came time to put in an offer, he walked us through the process. We are very pleased with the way he smoothed that process by using his many contacts throughout the area. When all was finalized, he was willing to go the extra mile for some things we wanted to be done. With us living 250 miles away, he stepped up over and above his call of duty.

Fantastic experience: I am a real estate agent in Ithaca NY and I did a transaction with Paul. He was so easy to deal with and his communication with me on everything was on point. It was a pleasure getting the deal to the finish line with him and I hope to do it again sometime. I highly recommend him to any buyers/sellers in his area. Thanks, Paul!

Fantastic experience: Paul had patience with us, showing us many homes until we found the right house. He took us step by step advising us what to do all the while finding a buyer for our old house, again taling us step by step on what to do. Even after the sale and purchase, he stays in touch and answers our questions. I would highly recommend Paul!!

Fantastic experience: Paul was phenomenal! He made the process of looking, finding, buying, then listing, showing and selling so easy. He was there to help for the endless questions, worries, and decisions. If I ever have to move again he is the only one that I will want to work with. He is professional but also understands moving with kids and the extra factors of moving a family. He works with you and your schedule and keeps you up to date on all the behind the scenes stuff too. Highly recommend Paul!

Fantastic experience: Looking for a home as a single female can be super intimidating, Paul explained every step along the way and took time to answer all of my questions and address all of my concerns (I have a lot of both). He is super knowledgeable and would point out things to be concerned about in a home, what could wait a couple years to be fixed and what was a non issue. He is well networked and had great recommendations as to who I should contact for a home inspection, home improvements, financing and whatever else, I may of needed along the way. Plus he has a kind, approachable personality, he truly made searching for my first home an enjoyable experience. I highly recommend him to anyone looking to buy or sell a home.

Fantastic experience: I cannot possibly shower Paul with enough praise. He is a godsend! I wasn't on the phone with him for long before I knew I wanted him representing us on the purchase of our new home. He had an answer for ever question I asked and more importantly, advised me on what I didn't know to ask. It was a big move for us, out of state. We knew nothing about the ins and outs of buying a home in New York, but Paul guided us through every step of the way. They say buying a home is one of the most stressful things you can do. Not for us. There was never a single moment of worry or stress because we knew we had Paul in our corner. Once we found the right house, Paul guided us through the offer process and every single thing he told us worked! It was pretty much set it and forget it once our offer was accepted. He kept on top of the commitment dates on the sellers side, our attorney he referred us to made sure we stayed on track with ours and also kept tabs on the seller. The mortgage company was lovely to work with too. Speaking of lovely to work with, Paul isn't just knowledgeable about everything real estate and everything Finger Lakes region, but he's an all around great guy! I wouldn't hesitate to recommend him to anyone looking to buy or sell a home. He's simply the greatest!

Fantastic experience: In summary - Paul is extremely professional, knowledgable, and a great communicator; I'd recommend Paul to anyone who needs a realtor in Western NY/The Finger Lakes, without hesitation. We were lucky enough to have randomly been connected to Paul via an internet real-estate site - talk about good fortune! Paul is extremely motivated and knowledgable when it comes to NY real-estate and especially the Western NY, Finger Lakes region. We were moving from out of state and had to find a place fast. We had no idea how different the NY laws compared to where we were moving from. Paul guided us through the whole process without a hitch and we love our new home.

Fantastic experience: Paul is an awesome realtor with a strong drive to sell your property. He went above and beyond to sell my house. I would strongly recommend him to anyone looking to sell or buy.

Fantastic experience: I highly recommend Paul as your realtor. Guaranteed to have the best customer service and the best Irish accent around!

Fantastic experience: It was a pleasure to work with Paul when we bought our house. He was knowledgeable, timely and very accommodating to our schedules!

Fantastic experience: The absolute best real estate company in the Southern Tier and Paul is the best real estate agent we've ever worked with. Highly recommended.

Fantastic experience: I am excited to recommend Paul Tyrrell. Paul helped us navigate selling our parents home after they died. From the beginning he was responsive, helpful, patient and reassuring. He had a solution to each bump in the road. The video in the listing was spectacular. I am grateful for the service the Paul provided to us.

Fantastic experience: I wholeheartedly recommend Paul to anyone who needs a realtor in the Finger Lakes. He helped us find a great home, at the right time, while we were still living several states away. He really understood what we were looking for and used his knowledge of the area to help us narrow the search. Being well acquainted with the area, he could provide insights on certain places and refer us to quality businesses, like a home inspector and a local mortgage lender (better than our initial choice). Throughout the closing process, we had clarity on the status of the deal and how to keep the ball rolling. Buying a home is not so hard if you have the right agent on your side!

Fantastic experience: Paul Tyrell is on top of his stuff! Almost always available for a chat and keeps his customers up to date on necessary info! I had him as the realtor when I bought property a few years ago and used him again recently as I sold property. He is reliable, straightforward and always willing to go above and beyond to help!

Fantastic experience: It is a pleasure to work with Paul. He is truthful, to the point, and does everything in his power to make your home sale/purchase as smooth as possible. Highly recommended!!!

Fantastic experience: I can’t say enough good things about our experience with Paul as our realtor during our recent house purchase. He has excellent communication skills, he’s terrific at following through on even the smallest detail, and he was infinitely patient with us as we looked for just the right property. He’s great at navigating the entire process and also a very nice person. I highly recommend using Paul for your real estate transactions!

Fantastic experience: My wife and I were first time home buyers and we are so thankful we decided to go with Paul as our realtor. He was extremely helpful with any questions we had, didn't matter if it was day or night. Paul was great with working around schedules for showings, even showed a house at 9 pm on a Friday. He made the whole process simple and easy for us. Keuka lake and land reality is lucky to have him and he is the only realtor I will recommend for my family and friends.

Fantastic experience: Paul did an amazing job helping my husband and I buy our first home. Even during a difficult housing market Paul was able to make the whole buying process easy and left us feeling confident in our decisions. He went above and beyond and helped us whenever we needed him. We would recommend  Paul to anyone looking for a honest and reliable realtor.

Fantastic experience: Paul is an exceptional realtor to work with. He is kind, caring and has a buyers best interest in mind. He was thoughtful in the homes that he showed us and was realistic in offering homes that would suite our needs. He was on top of the buying process and everything went very smoothly because of him. He was able to answer all of our questions and anticipated issues and dealt with them before they became a problem. I would definitely recommend Paul to anyone looking to buy or sell a home!!

Fantastic experience: Paul was an absolute pleasure to work with as my buyers agent! He was professional, personable, always responsive and I would recommend him to anyone looking to buy (or sell) a home in the finger lakes region! Buying a lake house in a state I didn’t live in was intimidating but Paul always put my mind at ease with his professionalism and sense of humor. As an added bonus, I got to meet his adorable young children who provided us with some good entertainment during a walk through!

Fantastic experience: Paul has been my rock throughout the home buying process, so much so, that I truly believe "Paul is always right!." He always had my best interest in mind, listened to my house needs, was a strong advocate, and was incredibly patient as well as flexible. Paul is an incredible realtor and I highly recommend him.

Fantastic experience: Coming from out of state Paul was the perfect realtor to help us navigate through a difficult purchase. He was always responsive to the many phone calls and texts I sent his way. Even after we closed on our property Paul was so helpful in providing us with local information and contacts we needed for our new home. It’s been almost a year since we purchased our property with Paul as our realtor and he still answers my calls ! We will absolutely use Paul if we decide to buy another house.

Fantastic experience: Thank you, Paul, for helping us purchase our first house! :)

Fantastic experience: My wife and I needed a new house, and Paul worked with us to find our home quickly. He made sure to check up on us and the new place after the buy was completed. He made a stressful time much easier.

Fantastic experience: Paul Tyrrell provided excellent service for my recent real estate transaction. He kept me well informed throughout and I am happy to give him the very highest recommendation.

Fantastic experience: As a night nurse that works crazy hours it was important to me to have a realtor that understood my schedule. Paul made several evening appointments to accommodate my schedule. Texted and emailed so he wouldn't disturb my sleep. He made everything clear and easy to understand from the first step to the last step. He even stays in contact to help clients afterwards!

Fantastic experience: Paul was incredible to work with while buying our first home. Great communication, experience, and local knowledge. Highly recommend!

Fantastic experience: My wife found Paul through word of mouth from friends and locals. We were looking to buy our first home and as soon as we reached out Paul contacted us immediately to get to know us and what we were looking for. Within days Paul had us set up for multiple home walk-throughs. We fell in love with one home and we made our offer. Paul was with us every step of the way staying in contact with us, the other realtor our lawyers and even the bank. He was hands on and always helpful. He really made the home buying process easy and straight forward for us. I would highly recommend Paul for any home buying endeavors you might have. I know if i ever move again Paul will be the first Person i talk to.

Fantastic experience: I have used Paul for the purchase of my last 2 homes. He is extremely knowledgeable and helpful throughout the entire process. Paul goes out of his way to follow up with all parties necessary and kept me in the loop the entire way. He goes above and beyond the role of realtor and provides his own advice when needed to help ease the stress of buying a home. I will for sure use Paul again with my next purchase.

Fantastic experience: Being new to the Finger Lakes area Paul was the perfect real estate agent for my husband and me. He was professional and persistent without being overly aggressive. Paul seems to "have a guy" for everything. This was helpful even after we purchased our home and needed help with everything from home renovations to daycare suggestions. Paul continues to be a reliable source for information about the area. I would highly recommend him for all of your real estate needs!

Fantastic experience: Paul is super professional and is always putting in any and all effort to make everyone happy! He is also very responsive and does it at a timely manner. Would recommend!