William Pitt Sotheby's International Realty - Great Barrington Brokerage

306 Main St, 01230, Great Barrington

Located in the heart of the Berkshires, William Pitt Sotheby's International Realty - Great Barrington Brokerage offers a sophisticated yet approachable real estate experience. With over 40 expert advisors dedicated to the region, we bring the global prestige of the Sotheby's brand to a uniquely local market. Our team combines deep, intimate knowledge of the Berkshire landscape with exceptional, personalized service for a discerning clientele.

Great Barrington serves as a gateway to one of Western Massachusetts' most coveted destinations. The Berkshires is celebrated for its year-round appeal, featuring scenic mountains, serene lakes, and a vibrant cultural scene. From world-class artisans and organic farms to farm-to-table dining and creative energy, the area attracts accomplished residents from across the globe. We specialize in helping clients find their sanctuary beyond the city, whether they are seeking historic estates, waterfront properties, golf communities, or modern rural retreats.

Our brokerage covers a wide array of communities including Lenox, Stockbridge, Williamstown, Lee, Sheffield, and Pittsfield, among others. We provide comprehensive support for buying, selling, and renting, including access to exclusive listings and new developments. Led by experienced management including Regional Brokerage Manager Stephanie McNair and CEO Carolyn Fugere, our office is committed to guiding you through every step of your real estate journey with integrity and expertise.

Opening hours

  • sunday: 9h-17h
  • monday: 9h-17h
  • tuesday: 9h-17h
  • wednesday: 9h-17h
  • thursday: 9h-17h
  • friday: 9h-17h
  • saturday: 9h-17h

Our comment from ImmoNetwork about William Pitt Sotheby's International Realty - Great Barrington Brokerage:

Combining Prestige with Personalized Berkshire Expertise

Situated in the heart of the Berkshires, William Pitt Sotheby's International Realty - Great Barrington Brokerage offers a sophisticated real estate experience that blends global prestige with deep local knowledge. The office is led by experienced management, including Regional Director Stephanie McNair and CEO Carolyn Fugere, ensuring a high standard of integrity and expertise. With a team of over 40 expert advisors, they cater to a discerning clientele, helping clients find everything from historic estates and waterfront properties to modern rural retreats and golf communities across Lenox, Stockbridge, Williamstown, and beyond.

The agency is particularly praised for its dedicated and highly knowledgeable agents who go above and beyond to ensure client satisfaction. Customers frequently highlight the personalized attention and transparent communication provided by top performers in the team, making the complex process of buying or selling a home feel manageable and secure.

Top-Rated Agents and Client Success Stories

Clients consistently celebrate the exceptional service provided by specific agents, noting their ability to navigate competitive markets with skill and care. Thom Garvey is repeatedly described as phenomenal, patient, and an expert on the Otis and Berkshire market, helping buyers find homes that exceed expectations and guiding sellers through smooth transactions. Herb Butzke is lauded for his dedication and attention to detail, with clients noting he is "the absolute best" for both buying and selling.

Other agents have garnered similar acclaim for their professionalism and local insight. Nick Geranios is recognized for his work ethic and humor, making the buying process a breeze, while Tonia (Tonya) Scalise is praised for her indefatigable effort, deep neighborhood knowledge, and ability to craft winning offers in multiple-bid situations. Martha Piper is highlighted for her sensitivity to client needs and proactive approach, and Jennifer Capala is celebrated for her strategic, honest, and creative handling of complex sales.

Comprehensive Support Beyond the Transaction

Whether clients are moving from out of state or navigating a retirement plan, the team provides invaluable support. Gladys Montgomery received high praise for her honest advice, helping a client avoid a property with significant structural issues, and ensuring a smooth relocation from California. Elle Villetto was commended for coordinating home preparations and cleaning when sellers moved away, ensuring a seamless sale in Pittsfield. Jen Capala and Patrice Melluzzo are also noted for their excellence in preparing properties for sale and achieving successful closures.

  • Local Market Mastery: Agents possess astonishing knowledge of neighborhood history, soil quality, and town planning, such as Tonia Scalise's insights.
  • Client-Centered Approach: Agents like Thom Garvey and Martha Piper are noted for keeping clients calm and in control throughout the process.
  • Problem-Solving: The team excels at coordinating with various stakeholders, from inspectors to sellers' agents, to resolve issues efficiently.

Commitment to Quality and Integrity

The brokerage is dedicated to maintaining the high standards of the Sotheby's brand. Agents like Jeff Loholdt and Maggie Merelle have helped clients with business and residential sales through honest, professional dealings. For first-time buyers like those who worked with Katie Williams, the agency offers patience and education, helping them navigate unfamiliar towns and secure their first choice home. The overwhelming sentiment from reviews is one of gratitude, with clients describing their agents as not just professionals, but trusted friends and advocates who truly look out for their best interests.

William Pitt Sotheby's International Realty - Great Barrington Brokerage: Reviews

4.8/5 (57 Reviews)

Reviews are the opinions of their authors. We do not verify that the author was a customer.

Reviews on Google

4,8 out of 5 from 57 reviews

Eric Williamson Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Elle Villetto made selling our house in Pittsfield seamless. We’ve worked with many agents, but none earned our trust like Elle. She was kind, genuine, and incredibly communicative. We moved away before the sale, and she went above and beyond, coordinating work on the house and even doing some cleaning herself. I honestly don’t believe we would have sold our house in the time we did, or had such a positive experience, without her. She deserves more than 5 stars. We’re incredibly grateful and recommend her without hesitation.

Christopher Felker Published on Google

Negative experience: In 2025 we engaged Sotheby's to assist in renting a home while we re located to Italy. Although the marketing photographs were promising, the agent assigned to assist provided very little support for the effort. There was, for example no standard lease forms offered, no tenant screening and very poor communications with almost no details about potential inquiries. Until we took independent steps to post the listing on Zillow - where we received numerous inquiries which were forwarded to the agent, very little progress was made. No one at either the Great Barrington or Lenox office appears to monitor the expiration of the exclusive listing agreements - so we ended the cycle by having to write a letter to ask they remove their sign. One great observation did emerge from this experience - that was the decision to hire an property steward / manager to be available to perform all the functions of a realtor like attending open houses, helping tenants to establish payment arrangements and curate a lease that befits the property. In a county where so much housing need goes unmet, the inability of the company to match its reputation for quality is a real disappointment. I envy our neighbours in the Hudson Valley who have firms like Elyse Harney to assist with brokerage work. The potential broker fees are much better invested in hiring an independent contractor to handle property management.

donna long Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Thom Garvey has been my realtor for a number of real estate transactions. He is caring, knows the market well, and ensures the process goes as smoothly as possible. It is obvious he enjoys working within the realty profession and in meeting with his clients. I would not hesitate in recommending him to anyone wishing to purchase or sell a home or business.

Kevin Johnson Published on Google

Fantastic experience: It was a great experience working with Herb, his dedication, attention to detail brought a successful sale of our home and would recommend him to anyone interested in selling or buying

Carol Ginsburg Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I can only say that our Agent, Thom Garvey was a professional, kind and calm presence in our life through the entire process of selling our Berkshires home. He gave us excellent advice (which we took) about refreshing and improving some aspects of the house to better appeal to a buyer. He advised us very step of the way through the sale process, kept us calm and feeling in control.I highly recommend Thom whether you are buying or selling a home. He is great!!

Marla Curtis Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Jeffrey Loholdt was fantastic. He guided us through the sales process, helped orchestrate what needed to be done to prepare the property for sale and went out of his way to make sure that everything was done correctly.

Gwen Anthony Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Thom Garvey was phenomenal! He’s easy to work with and seeks your input from start to finish. He’s able to take all the moving parts and assemble them to make the deal happen. Thom works with all the stakeholders involved in the sale of your house, which takes the burden off of you.Thom knows Otis, He knows the market And above all, he knows the people. Give Thom a call today. Mark&Wendy Anthony

Carl Lucas Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Elle was awesome throughout the entire process. I would highly recommend her to anyone looking to sell or buy a house in the lower Berkshire area.

Beth Balawick Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Herb Butzke is the absolute BEST realtor. He goes above and beyond to help you buy or sell a home. I loved working with him, and I will definitely do so again in the future.

Lea King Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Jeff Loholdt has helped me sell several of my businesses and my primary home as I plan my retirement in their Berkshires. He has been resourceful and deal with all stakeholders honestly and professionally and has been a tremendous asset. I highly recommend him and his firm.

Howard Bass Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I had a great experience working with Herb Butzke. He was easy to work with, answered my many texts and emails promptly, and helped me find my new home in Pittsfield, Ma.

mike rodgers Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Exceptional service and results!

Brittany Slater Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Nick was amazing to work with. His work ethic, expertise and humor along the way made the home buying process a breeze. He was thorough and always worked dilligently for our best intrests. Would highly recommend Nick Geranios to anyone buying or selling a home!

Kathleen Connor Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I can not say enough positive things about my broker, Tonia Scalise. She is professional, efficient, helpful, knows just how much to push and just how much to let you decide, makes great suggestions on a variety of issues that can arise in the buying and selling of a home.

Andy Voorhis Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Thom Garvey was an excellent realtor for us. He worked very hard and looked out for our interests while we were in the process of buying our home. Thom has high energy, corresponded with us frequently and answered all our question promptly. He is very enthusiastic guy and we would use him again as he is very knowledgeable of the real estate market in Berkshire county.

vivian kimmelman Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Martha Piper, representing Great Barrington Brokerage is knowledgeable, helpful and will pay attention to the smallest detail and have your welfare in mind. I would highly recommend working with Martha on your future real estate needs.

Kip Strawbridge Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Our home-buying experience with Thom Garvey was exceptional. We were given personal care, relevant information for making sound decisions, and helpful insights along the way. Thom was professional yet personable and also very punctual as we reached each deadline or meeting. Communication throughout the entire experience couldn't have been better. I highly recommend Thom and William Pitt Sotheby's.

Patricia Leahey-Hays Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Amazing experience. Selling a home seemed extremely stressful and nerve-wracking to us. Herb with Sotheby's was helpful and went above and beyond several times to make this process as simple and as successful as possible.

Marguerite Braun Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Nick was a superb realtor. He helped me in so many ways that I can't list them all. He made a difficult move possible and livable.

Rick Pocock Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Nick Geranios significantly exceeded our high expectations at every stage of the sale of our home. His knowledge of the residential real estate market is remarkable, and his professionalism is exemplary. We feel so very fortunate to be the beneficiaries of Nick’s skills, knowledge, and commitment to excellence.

Johnathan Griffin Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Love working with Herb Butzke - great realtor and a wonderful person.

Daniel Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I can't imagine having gone through the purchase and sale process without your help. Thank you so much for everything!

Karen Adams Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Tonya Scalise was outstanding, answered every question and helped us every step of the way to sell our home.

Darcy Jacobsen Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I can safely say if I had not worked with Tonia Scalise I would not have my dream home. I was fortunate enough to witness Tonia in action as a seller's agent when I made my first offer on a home in Pittsfield. I was not successful in that offer, but I walked away with something just as valuable — the best real estate agent in the Berkshires!! Completely impressed with her skill and friendliness on behalf of her sellers, I called Tonia the following Monday and asked if she would serve as my buyer's agent. Over the following months, she was indefatigable on my behalf. As a first-time homebuyer and self-employed single mom I had dozens of anxious questions. Tonia answered them all cheerfully and gave me hope, showing me scores of homes. I always knew she was in my corner as she helped me strategize on how to be the most attractive buyer in this ridiculously competitive market — and as she put together the best possible offers for me. Tonia knows this market like no one else. She walks up to properties with a depth of knowledge that is astonishing — with thoughts on things like flooding likelihood and soil quality of neighborhoods, sewers, original builders, and town planning. There wasn't a neighborhood we looked at where she didn't have history as an agent. The acceptance of my offer on my home, in a multiple-bid situation, was absolutely down to Tonia's advice and clever and creative positioning. I am incredibly grateful to her. If you have a chance to work with her, TAKE IT!

Donna Ebbs Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Gladys Montgomery made my future possible. Moving from California back to my home state was a daunting prospect, to say the least. With a job waiting, but a clock also ticking, I dove in, not knowing what to expect, what inventory might be, and how realistic I would have to get in terms of money, environment and location. Gladys gave great perspectives, listened to my thoughts, my needs, my fantasies...extrapolated what that all looked like, not only in a home, but in beginning a new life and growing a support system. She probed, guided, supported. And when we honed in on a house, she went the extra mile and thank god she did as only through her going there and talking to neighbors did we realize a massive sound issue existed. She caught it, and despite a huge upside to her if I bought the home, she fully supported me pulling out. When we found the right home, she was dogged in getting me in to see it (before the open house that had been delayed due to snow), and worked hard with the sellers' agent to make sure we, as a team, got what was fair. I'm ready to start my new life, and know that Gladys will be a permanent part if it, if not as my ongoing realtor, then as a friend. Hang on to her for as long as you possibly can. She's the best of the best.

tomkat books Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Herb is the best! Michael Crane

Fane Roberts Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I cannot recommend Maggie Merelle more highly! Fantastic job finding interested potential buyers and bringing a cash sale at the right price for a lovely property with some special considerations. Otis Reservoir home, closed February 2023.

Chris Ferrone Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Jen Capala is the best!

Em Published on Google

Negative experience: They photoshopped the house we went to look at. They photoshopped out all the rot on the house, the circled photo is the one they posted to Zillow. The second photo is the photo we took of the house when we arrived. We traveled an hour to see this house and their listing agent booked us wrong resulting in the home owner yelling at us and our realtor to get off her property. We traveled an hour and never got to even see the inside of the house.

Al Moorad Published on Google

Fantastic experience: a great experience with agent martha piper.

Judy Orlando Published on Google

Fantastic experience: From showing to bidding to purchase, our agent Martha Piper was professional, responsive, proactive and a pleasure to work with.

Nathaniel Woodward Published on Google

Fantastic experience: We were very pleased with our experience with Katie Williams. We are first-time home buyers, and she was very patient and informative with our rookie questions. She was always available for emails, texts, or phone calls as needed. We are moving to an area we don't know well yet: Katie's local knowledge and experience with the town, the community, and the people gave us valuable insight into successfully closing on our first choice home.

Vicki Weiner Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Martha Piper is smart, professional and sensitive to the needs of clients. I highly recommend her.

Robert Fenton Published on Google

Fantastic experience: We are very pleased with our experience of purchasing a home through Thom Garvey. We selected him as a buyer's broker after meeting with other realtors and he was a delight to work with. He brought us to homes he thought we might like, stayed within the parameters we provided, gently guided us away from some properties we located (with good reason) and, ultimately, found us the house we purchased. It's important to note that not only did Thom locate the right home for us, he located the perfect home for us. He listened carefully to how we spoke about what we wanted in a home and found a property that far exceeded our expectations.

Ron Bisiewicz Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Patrice Melluzzo did a wonderful job in selling my house. She was so helpful in getting the house prepared for the sale. Everything about this transaction went smoothly. I recommend that anyone selling a home in the Great Barrington, MA area call Pat first. She is the best!

Paige Orloff Published on Google

Fantastic experience: The best real estate experience we have ever had, thanks to Jennifer Capala’s work. She was prepared, strategic, thoughtful, creative, kind, and scrupulously honest at every step. We will continue to work with her and cannot recommend her highly enough.

Jody Soules Published on Google

Positive experience: Pat Melluzzo did an excellent job selling our house. She is a true professional.

Leave your opinion about William Pitt Sotheby's International Realty - Great Barrington Brokerage:

1 = Poor
5 = Excellent

Reviews are checked before they are published. We do not publish reviews containing insults, accusations of criminal conduct or references to specific individuals. We also do not verify that the author was a customer.

William Pitt Sotheby's International Realty - Great Barrington Brokerage appears in the following listings:

Other real estate agencies you might be interested in

Add your real estate agency to our directory for free

If you manage a real estate agency and want to appear in our guide, send us your company information and you can appear completely free of charge.

Add your real estate agency for free

The largest real estate directory in United States

Find the best real estate agencies near you