Cottage Realty

118 S Main St, 52641, Mount Pleasant

Located in the heart of Mount Pleasant, Iowa, Cottage Realty LLC is a dedicated real estate agency that combines deep local roots with professional expertise. The team takes immense pride in their intimate knowledge of the Southeast Iowa area, leveraging their personal history in the region to guide clients toward their ideal properties. Whether you are searching for a family home, a commercial investment, or rental properties, the agents at Cottage Realty provide personalized service tailored to your unique needs.

Cottage Realty offers comprehensive real estate services, including the sale of residential homes, commercial properties, and ground/lots. Their highly trained REALTORS® are skilled in marketing your property to the entire real estate community, determining the optimal market price, and negotiating the best possible terms. They manage every detail of the transaction, from finding prospective buyers to handling complex paperwork, ensuring a smooth and successful closing process.

Beyond sales, Cottage Realty also assists with rental properties, serving both landlords seeking qualified tenants and renters looking for their next home. The agency is an active member of the Mt. Pleasant Multiple Listing Service, Southeast Iowa Board of REALTORS®, Iowa Association of REALTORS®, National Association of REALTORS®, and the Mt. Pleasant Chamber of Commerce. This involvement ensures they stay connected to the community and available to help past and future customers find that special place in Southeast Iowa.

Opening hours

  • sunday: (closed)
  • monday: 13h-16h
  • tuesday: 9h-16h
  • wednesday: 9h-16h
  • thursday: 13h-16h
  • friday: 13h-16h
  • saturday: (closed)

Our comment from ImmoNetwork about Cottage Realty:

Deep Local Roots and Professional Expertise

Cottage Realty LLC, located in the heart of Mount Pleasant, Iowa, distinguishes itself by combining deep regional roots with high-level professional service. The agency specializes in the southeastern Iowa market, offering comprehensive services for residential sales, commercial properties, and land. Their team of REALTORS® is highly trained to market properties effectively, determine optimal pricing, and negotiate favorable terms, ensuring that both buyers and sellers receive expert guidance tailored to their unique needs.

Exceptional Client Advocacy and Stress Reduction

What truly sets Cottage Realty apart is the dedication of its agents, particularly Mackenzie Barton, Renee Smith, and Melissa Peitz, who consistently receive praise for going above and beyond. Clients frequently highlight how these agents simplify complex transactions, making the buying or selling process feel effortless and stress-free. Whether handling estate sales for clients living out of state or managing double closings for growing families, the team ensures that every detail is managed with care and professionalism.

Responsive Communication and Personalized Support

Communication is a standout strength for this agency. Clients repeatedly mention that their agents are prompt in returning calls and texts, providing clear updates, and answering every question thoroughly. Mackenzie Barton is frequently described as a trusted guide who educates first-time buyers and advocates for their needs, while Renee Smith is celebrated for her reliability and ability to provide immediate answers. This level of personalized attention ensures clients feel supported and informed at every stage of their transaction.

Proven Track Record of Success

The agency’s commitment to results is evident in numerous client testimonials. Agents have been credited with selling properties quickly, securing ideal homes for hard-to-fit families, and providing compassionate support during difficult times, such as selling a loved one’s home. With long-term clients praising the team’s consistency over many years and new clients highly recommending their services, Cottage Realty has established a reputation for integrity, hard work, and exceptional customer satisfaction in the Iowa real estate market.

Cottage Realty: Reviews

5/5 (52 Reviews)

Reviews are the opinions of their authors. We do not verify that the author was a customer.

Reviews on Google

5,0 out of 5 from 52 reviews

The Cavins Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Renee Smith was great to work with all throughout the process of searching for and purchasing our home. She had been the property manager for the house we were renting, so when it was time for us to look at buying our first home we knew we wanted to work with her. She watched out for homes that we may be interested in, and whenever we had questions about the process she was there with an answer. Renee set up all the inspections and the lawyer, making it a very easy process. We would definitely recommend Renee the next time you need a realtor!

Carolyn Prottsman Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Friends staff. Great place to find land

Clint Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Matthew and Mackenzie Barton were amazing to work with and made our listing and double closing a breeze! Any questions were immediately addressed and there were no uncertainties during the entire process. I could not ask for a better team to work with. 10/10

Randy Poos Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Great realtor, easy to work with, great communicators, goes the extra mile

Randy Cochran Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Cottage hit a home run at every step of the process during our sale. MacKenzie was such a joy to work with, wonderfully explaining the minutiae of selling our father’s home, what to expect, and when. I wholeheartedly recommend Cottage for anyone looking to sell their property in SE Iowa!

Kylee Coleman Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Mackenzie Barton has been absolutely amazing to work with at Cottage Realty! We just closed on our first home together and she made the process so effortless. She truly took the time to make sure we found the perfect home for us. Not only does she have lots of advice and knowledge, she is also one of the sweetest people you will ever meet! She is a great communicator and always took the time to answer any of our questions we had. She makes you feel very supported throughout the whole process. Mackenzie exceeded all of our expectations. We will be using her for any future real estate needs of ours! I cannot recommend her enough! Thank you for all you’ve done for us, Mackenzie!

Ryan Mordick Published on Google

Fantastic experience: When it came time to purchase our first home we knew exactly who we were going to work with. Melissa Peitz had been the property manager at our rental for five years so we were already very used to working with her and when we asked her to help us find a home of our own she didn't hesitate to help! She's punctual, helpful, responsive, flexible, and most of all very kind! She listened to all of our needs, gave us many suggestions and was a huge asset in securing our home. Melissa and Cottage Realty got us through the entire process from offer to close in less than 30 days. We will always be thankful for Cottage Realty and they will continue to get our business!

Jen Gracey Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Mackenzie Barton was the best realtor for us. We challenged her to find a house to fit our blended family and sell both of our separate homes. What we thought would be a difficult task Mackenzie made the whole process smooth and stress free. We cannot recommend her enough and are so thankful for all she did!!

Rhonda Lowenberg Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Mackenzie Barton made the process of buying a new house and selling our house very stress free!!! She gave us tips on how to make our house more appealing to buyers and posted it on all types of social media and websites to get the word out to as many as possible potential buyers. The whole experience was very successful and she made it so easy for us! I would HIGHLY recommend her to anyone looking for a realtor!

Kurt Lowenberg Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Mackenzie is the best! She made everything so easy and smooth. Always was straight forward in guiding us to make the best decisions for us. She was always very quick to respond with our concerns or questions. I know who I will deal with in the future. Very enjoyable experience.

Rachel Mills Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Mackenzie Barton was fantastic to work with. I moved out of state prior to my house selling and she took care of everything. She made the process seamless and painless. I highly recommend using Mackenzie as your realtor, rather you are selling or buying!

Phillip Grandinetti Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I have had many experiences buying and selling properties with Renee through the years and she always delivers and gets the job done with excellent performance and great care of her clients! Call Renee and Todd with any and all of your real estate business!!!

Melissa Stapleton Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Melissa Peitz at Cottage Realty made our estate sale simple, stress-free, and incredibly smooth—even with my brother and me living out of state. She treated the sale of our family home as if it were her own, handling every detail with care and professionalism. Melissa coordinated everything from cleaning to necessary house repairs, making the entire process easy and manageable from afar. Her communication was excellent, and we always felt informed and supported every step of the way. We couldn’t have asked for a better experience. Melissa’s dedication and compassion truly set her apart. Highly recommend—an absolute 5-star service!

Tedd McTee Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Melissa Peitz of Cottage Realty provided exceptional support during the difficult process of selling our mother's home after her passing. Living out of state, my sister and I relied heavily on Melissa, and she consistently exceeded our expectations. She expertly coordinated all aspects of the sale, from scheduling showings and providing regular feedback to managing necessary repairs with reliable local contractors. Melissa's proactive approach and clear communication alleviated significant stress and made the entire process remarkably smooth. Her professionalism and genuine compassion truly set her apart. Melissa handled every detail, including the seamless virtual signing, with efficiency and care. We are incredibly grateful for her dedication and expertise, which made a challenging time much more manageable. For anyone seeking a highly competent, empathetic, and truly dedicated real estate agent, we wholeheartedly recommend Melissa Peitz. She goes above and beyond for her clients and delivers outstanding results.

Samantha Harrison Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Working with Mackenzie Barton and Cottage Realty was the best decision we could have made! She made the entire process so easy, and truly helped us find exactly what we were looking for. From start to finish we felt 100% supported and heard. We would recommend her 100 times over!

laura luadzers Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Mackenzie was very helpful in our process of buying a house

Derek Dietrich Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Highly recommend. I had Mackenzie as my realtor and she was a huge help with me finding the right house for me.

Katelyn Pearson Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Cottage Realty and Renee helped me buy my 1st house! The process was made easy with Renee she had all the answers to all my first time buyer problems/ dumb questions. I 1000% recommend Cottage Realty and Renee Smith for your real-estate needs.

Adrian Gonzales Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I decided to work with Cottage Realty for my real estate needs, and I had the absolute pleasure of working with Renee. From start to finish, she was nothing short of incredible, demonstrating a level of commitment that truly exceeded my expectations. Renee consistently went above and beyond to ensure that every aspect of the process was smooth and enjoyable. I wholeheartedly recommend reaching out to her for any realty needs you might have, she is dedicated to doing everything in her power to assist you!

Jolyne Crossett Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Working with Cottage Realty and Renee was such a great experience! Renee made everything so easy and worry free, she had all the answers, knew all the steps and was always ready to help! Renee is prompt about returning messages or calls and is very efficient in getting things done in a timely manner. I highly recommend Cottage Realty and Renee Smith if you need any help with real estate in southeast Iowa!

Jessica Mazzanti Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Renee was great!!

Paul Weinstock Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Renee is absolutely the best. We have been using her for the last 11 years and she's helped us buy and sell several properties. She's always worked hard for us. There's several choices of realtors in town but in my opinion, you can't go wrong with Cottage Realty and Renee.

Kelly Kauchis Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Excited to share my incredible experience with Renee Smith at Cottage Realty. She went above and beyond to help my husband and I purchase our dream home. From start to finish Renee made the entire process feel effortless and stress free. Her dedication and professionalism reassured me every step of the way. If you are looking for a hardworking, dedicated real estate agent, look no further than Renee Smith at Cottage Realty LLC.

Erin Grandinetti Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Renee was awesome to work with and very thorough! Buying our new home was a wonderful experience!

Jay Gee Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Mackenzie Barton is an exceptional realtor who exceeded all my expectations. From our first meeting, she demonstrated a genuine interest in understanding my needs and preferences, making me feel like her top priority throughout the entire process. Her wealth of knowledge and expertise in the real estate market was truly impressive and she always went above and beyond to provide me with valuable insights and guidance. What sets Mackenzie apart is her unwavering dedication and commitment. She was always available to answer my questions and address any concerns, making the home buying experience smooth and stress-free, especially when buying my first home AND coming from out of state. Working with Mackenzie felt like having a trusted friend by my side, guiding me through every step of the journey. If you are looking for a realtor who is not only professional, informative, and attentive, but also genuinely cares about your needs and satisfaction, Mackenzie is the one for you. I am incredibly grateful for her support and expertise in helping me find my home. I wholeheartedly recommend Mackenzie to anyone in search of a top-notch realtor who will go above and beyond to make your real estate goals a reality. Thank you, Mackenzie, for your outstanding service!

Ashley Reed Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I was a first time home buyer and I seriously could not have had any better of an experience than I did with Mackenzie Barton. She is truly a blessing! ✔️ Constant communication with updates and checks in even though I worked night shift. ✔️ Listened and truly heard every single one of my worries/concerns and helped me understand. ✔️ No questions went unanswered. She would always go above and beyond to find answers. ✔️ Educated me along the way of not only the “Do’s and Don’ts” with house purchasing but also went into full detail of any and all paperwork and why it was needed. But most important of all, to me, she is a kind hearted trustworthy person that is understanding of real life situations. I would recommend Mackenzie Barton for all of your home buying/selling needs!

Kristen Ellingboe Published on Google

Fantastic experience: We had the best experience with Mackenzie Barton! She helped find the right buyer for our house and made closing very easy. She made it seem effortless even though we were in another state for closing. We can’t say enough good things about the brokerage and Mackenzie! 11/10 recommend her!

Megan Winsor Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Renee Smith was absolutely amazing and made our sale easy and smooth. Highly recommend!

Anita Evans Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I definitely recommend Cottage Realty - Renee and Todd Smith are both great. We had our home listed with another agent and it didn’t show at all. After a few months of getting discouraged we decided to re-list with Cottage Realty and we had showing and an offer on our home within a couple weeks. The communication was great and the closing went so smooth. You will not be disappointed!

Brett Snaadt Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Melissa Peitz sold my lot in St Paul in about 4 days. Closed in a few weeks. Couldn't be any more pleased with her and the process. Great job!

Janet Vance Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I would highly recommend Mackenzie Barton with Cottage Realty when searching for a home in the Mt. Pleasant area. She was very attentive to all our parameters in looking for a house and was prompt in letting us know about new listings. She responds quickly to calls & texts and was a true professional.

David Kroll Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Great agents and a wonderful experience working with Melissa & Renee!

jessica miller Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Mackenzie was amazing through the entire process! She listened to what I wanted and showed me a LOT of properties until we found the one. She answered all of my questions and was very prompt when I sent her texts. Highly recommend using her!!!!!

Sydney Smith Published on Google

Fantastic experience: We just closed on our first home with the help of Mackenzie Barton, and she was absolutely wonderful! This was our first time purchasing a home and she was extremely patient with us as we learned how this process works and took the time to explain everything thoroughly to us. Mackenzie has superb communication and keeps you in the loop every step of the way, which was very important to us. She constantly advocated for our needs & we could not be more appreciative. We most definitely recommend her services to anybody looking. Thank you, Mackenzie!

jacob brauman Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Recently bought a home through Cottage Realty and had exceptional service from our realtor! Mrs. Peitz went above and beyond to help us locate and get our new home purchased. Highly recommend this realty office and more importantly, Mrs. Peitz!

Mike Papas Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Our experience with Cottage Realty and McKenzie Barton this year was exceptional. McKenzie's expertise and commitment to customer satisfaction made the entire process effortless. Her ability to streamline communication and her proactive approach exceeded our expectations, making her the best in the business. Thank you so much for everything you done 10/10

Emilee Rooney Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Mackenzie was super helpful and the best choice when it came to finding our home! She was always there every step of the way and always answered every question we had. I would highly recommend choosing Mackenzie as your Realtor!

Mia DeTolve Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Our experience was great! Mackenzie was always there when we needed her. She answered all of our questions and went above and beyond each time we needed her. The process would not have been easy for my fiancée and I if she wasn’t our Realtor.

Amanda Eleazer Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Melissa was amazing to work with. Finding and buying our home.

sarah lauer Published on Google

Fantastic experience: We used Cottage Realty for our last 3 home purchases, they have made it such a seamless process. Renee Smith made sure everything was done and completed and we will be using her again soon!

Leanne Salmeron Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Holly Burden is amazing to work with! She listens to my parameters for a home, responds quickly to my calls and texts, and demonstrates honesty and integrity. I am pleased to have her support in the real estate world.

Brian Anderson Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Steve is very responsive and professional

Wendy Box Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Great place to buy a house!! Holly was fantastic with us and highly highly recommend!

Kevin Hotop Published on Google

Positive experience: Great friendly people, most listings in the area.

Prophet Livingood Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Realtors usually post addresses and photos of homes for sale on their websites, check it out !

Leave your opinion about Cottage Realty:

1 = Poor
5 = Excellent

Reviews are checked before they are published. We do not publish reviews containing insults, accusations of criminal conduct or references to specific individuals. We also do not verify that the author was a customer.

Cottage Realty appears in the following listings:

Other real estate agencies you might be interested in

5 (60)
Meadow & Main
Meadow & Main

Meadow & Main

View address and contact details
129 N Jefferson St - 52641, Mount Pleasant
+1319-209-8089

Add your real estate agency to our directory for free

If you manage a real estate agency and want to appear in our guide, send us your company information and you can appear completely free of charge.

Add your real estate agency for free

The largest real estate directory in United States

Find the best real estate agencies near you