Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.

123 W Franklin St Suite 302, 47394, Winchester

Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co. is your premier "one-stop shop" for all real estate needs in Winchester, Indiana, and the surrounding East Central Indiana and Western Ohio regions. With over a decade of experience, the team combines professionalism, integrity, and deep local expertise to serve clients in Randolph, Delaware, Henry, Wayne, Jay, and Blackford counties, covering towns such as Muncie, Richmond, New Castle, and Yorktown.

Beyond traditional buying and selling, Tarter Realty offers a comprehensive suite of specialized services. They are home to **three state-certified real estate appraisers** who provide accurate valuations for estates, divorces, and personal property. The company also features a robust **auction division**, hosting both personal property and land auctions online, ensuring maximum exposure and competitive bidding for sellers.

For investors and landlords, their dedicated **Property Management division** handles hundreds of residential, multi-family, and commercial properties, taking the hassle out of the rental process. Additionally, they offer **free home evaluations** to help sellers understand their property's market value and **expert real estate consulting** to guide clients through complex transactions. Whether you are buying your first home, selling land, or managing an investment portfolio, Tarter Realty provides the tools and expertise to make it happen.

Opening hours

  • sunday: (closed)
  • monday: 9h-16:30
  • tuesday: 9h-16:30
  • wednesday: 9h-16:30
  • thursday: 9h-16:30
  • friday: 9h-16:30
  • saturday: (closed)

Our comment from ImmoNetwork about Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.:

A Comprehensive Real Estate Solution with Local Expertise

Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co. stands as a definitive partner for real estate needs across Winchester, Indiana, and surrounding regions in central-eastern Indiana and western Ohio. With over a decade of industry experience, the agency combines professional integrity with a deep understanding of local markets, including counties like Randolph, Delaware, Henry, Wayne, Jay, and Blackford. Clients consistently highlight the team's ability to handle diverse transactions with **high levels of professionalism and responsiveness**.

For those seeking a trusted advisor, the agency offers **expert guidance through complex transactions**, whether buying a first home, selling land, or managing an investment portfolio. Reviews frequently praise specific agents for being **reachable, patient, and dedicated** to finding the perfect fit for their clients. This personalized approach ensures that customers feel supported and informed at every stage of the process.

Specialized Services: Auctions, Appraisals, and Property Management

What sets Tarter Realty apart is its multi-faceted service division. The agency features **three state-certified appraisers** who provide accurate valuations for estates, divorces, and personal property. Clients note that the appraisal process is not only **fair and reasonably priced** but also delivered in a **timely and professional manner**. The reports are described as high-quality and essential for making informed decisions.

The company's **robust auction division** is a particular favorite among buyers and sellers. Users describe the bidding process as **simple, fair, and transparent**, with a platform that provides maximum visibility. The agency also manages hundreds of residential and commercial properties through its **dedicated property management division**, eliminating the headaches of rental management for owners and providing reliable support for tenants. This versatility makes them a one-stop shop for various real estate goals.

Customer-Centric Culture and Integrity

The most recurring theme in customer feedback is the **genuine care and integrity** demonstrated by the staff. Agents are described as honest, straightforward, and willing to go above and beyond to ensure a smooth transition, whether for a sale or a move. Many clients appreciate the **clear communication and proactive problem-solving**, which helps reduce stress during critical life changes. The team's friendliness and respectfulness create a welcoming environment for all interactions, reinforcing their reputation as a **reliable and highly recommended local business**.

Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.: Reviews

4.5/5 (52 Reviews)

Reviews are the opinions of their authors. We do not verify that the author was a customer.

Reviews on Google

4,5 out of 5 from 52 reviews

Sandra Palmer Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Matt Tarter was a exceptional agent to work with. He was always reachable and very professional. We let him appraise our home auction off a huge house full of furniure and he sold our home.The experience of working with him was great!

Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.
Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.

Thank you, Sandra! It was our pleasure to work with you!

Nicole Morrow Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I bid on their auctions a few times a year and have always had a great experience with them!

Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.
Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.

Thank you Nicole! We appreciate your kind words and business!

Conan Wallace Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Professional, reliable and very responsive to anything and everything about selling real estate and personal property. I recommend Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal to those who desire a trusted partner through the whole process. Their team is genuine and provides a great service.

Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.
Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.

Thank you for your thoughtful review. We genuinely appreciate your trust in our team and are grateful for the opportunity to have worked with you.

Natalia Extin Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Great people!

Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.
Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.

Thank you!

Chris Grant Published on Google

Negative experience: Personal inspect before buying, items are not very well described.

Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.
Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.

Chris, I wasn’t able to find your name in our system, but I’d really like the opportunity to learn more about your experience. We do our best to provide clear descriptions and photos, and we always recommend personal inspections when possible. Please feel free to reach out to me directly at 765-595-8155 so we can discuss this further. Thanks, Alena

Kenny E. Published on Google

Positive experience: Seems fair and easy to bid. Only 1 pickup time is a little difficult but its workable. Update: Thanks for the extra day, it will make it easier to get the product.

Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.
Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.

Thank you for the feedback Kenny! If there is a pickup that isn't accessible for you, please let us know beforehand and we would be happy to help accommodate!

Hey Kenny, wanted to give an update. We have added a second pickup day on Saturdays for our auctions. I hope this helps!

Brandon Nunez Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Excelent Staff. Quick on getting back to any question. Also willing to go above and beyond to get a rental or buying a house. Even polite and respectful.

Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.
Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.

Thanks Brandon!

Brent Wasson Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I needed an evaluation on an estate property. They were extremely helpful and great to work with. They took time to listen and understand my situation and went above and beyond. They made me feel like they had my best interest at heart. Great customer service. I would highly recommend them.

Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.
Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.

Thank you Brent! We appreciate your trust in us!

Larissa Thoman Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Big thank you to Mark Tooley for taking the time and patience to help me search for the perfect home. You did amazing. Thanks again!

Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.
Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.

Thank you Larissa!

boarhog11 Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Our family has used Tarter Auction and Reality a couple of times this year as we endeavored to determine property values. Each time the service was professional and seamless as well as priced reasonably.

Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.
Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.

Thank you! Please let us know if we can be of further assistance in the future!

John Burkhardt Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Tarter Company provided excellent services and product on two home appraisals for me recently. They are professional, courteous, and provide a high quality report product in a timely fashion. I would certainly retain their services in the future.

Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.
Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.

Thank you John! It was a pleasure to work with you!

Susan Carey Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Tarter was referred to us for an independent appraisal on our property. Very nice and efficient to work with. Highly recommend.

Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.
Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.

Thank you Susan! Please do not hesitate to contact us if you need anything in the future!

Jennifer Eviston Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Highly recommend Jennifer and Matt. They are professional, friendly, responsive, and great to work with.

Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.
Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.

Thank you Jennifer! It was a pleasure to work with you!

Silvia Wright Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Very professional, excellent service!! Recommended to anybody that needs an appraisal.

Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.
Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.

Thank you Silvia!

Nicole Hampton Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Bidding and picking up my 'wins' is always a fun experience with Tarter auctions. You've always got some unusual, unique items. Brianna is a joy to work with, picking up items. She always has everything organized and receipt attached. All of the people there are nice and helpful!

Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.
Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.

Thank you Nicole! Glad to hear!

Bob Byers Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Matt and his team sold our house at a fair price in a short amount of time. His auction team came in and took care of everything that we were leaving. Because of Matt and his team, we were able to focus on moving to our new address and never had to worry about the sale of our home. They took care of everything. Communication was top notch and very much appreciated. We also appreciated Matts honesty and being straightforward. With all the facts at hand, we were able to prepare for contingencies as well as we could. The sale and auction could not have gone more smoothly. My wife and I are very happy with the way things went and we would not hesitate to recommend Tarter Realty in the future.

Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.
Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.

Thank you Bob! We appreciate you trusting us to assist you!

Dan Neuenschwander Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Always simple to bid and pay for items.

Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.
Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.

Thank you for the feedback, Dan!

Alan White Published on Google

Fantastic experience: We have gotten several great deals at Tarter Auctions. Speedy check out and timely pick ups. Thanks so much.

Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.
Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.

Thank you for the feedback, Alan!

Curt Long Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Very good and honest place of business. I've had nothing but positive dealings with Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal. They are good people to do business with.

Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.
Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.

Thank so much, Curt!

H. Coy Applegate Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Paul and Melanie are awesome to work with. They made the transition into moving smooth and very painless. They answered all of our questions and have a great system in place to help renters turn in issues and take care of the other landlord/renter issues. Definitely recommend

Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.
Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.

We appreciate your feedback! We love helping take care of our tenants!

Kelby Purdin Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Jammie Michael was a wonderful real estate agent. She was very responsive and helped us with anything we needed. Highly recommend!

Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.
Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.

Thank you for the kind words Kelby!

Gavin Richards Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I have had nothing but great experiences working with Tarter Realty. Jammie Michael, specifically, who has helped me with multiple transactions, provided exceptional availability while looking at properties. Her insight and knowledge of the local real estate market is top notch. If you’re looking for an incredible agent to help buy or sell, she is that person!

Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.
Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.

Thank you for the kind words Gavin!

Dustyn Hangen Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Great Company to work with

Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.
Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.

Thank you Dustyn!

Gabe Bogue Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Great customer service, excellent group of people to work with, best in the business.

Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.
Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.

Thank you Gabe!

Nicole Shandy Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Very professional and knowledgeable, always a great experience when we have needed their services. My parents bought a house through them last year and couldn't be more happy with the process, I was thankful for them making the process easy for them and finding their forever home.

Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.
Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.

Thank you Nicole!! We really enjoyed working with your parents as well!

Travis Arbogast Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Tarter Realty Auction and Appraisal is an amazing company ran by even better employees. If you want to deal with people of high character and integrity, this is your company! Don’t hesitate to do business with Team Tarter!

Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.
Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.

Thank you for your kind words Travis!!

Shannon A Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Top notch company to deal with. Very pleased with my experience. Highly recommend.

Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.
Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.

Thank you Shannon!

Amber Tutterrow Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Professional & personable. We have used Tarter Realty many times over the last several years and have always had great experiences.

Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.
Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.

Thank you Amber!

Angie Wilt Published on Google

Fantastic experience: My house was sold in 30 minutes!

Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.
Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.

Thank you!!!

Richard Hoffmann Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Promptly replies to email. Very courteous and customer oriented. Best experience ever.

Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.
Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.

Thank you Richard!

Am Yo Published on Google

Negative experience: Very rude to sec 8 HUD renters

Stacey Chalfant Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I've had Tarter do appraisals for me and bought in auctions. Great company and great people.

Jerry Pitman Published on Google

Positive experience: Friendly staff

John Hankins Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Very pleased with the service I’ve received. I’ve had several questions about real estate and rentals in the Winchester area. Mr. Tarter gave me his personal cell number and has answered every single time I’ve called. Great folks and very helpful in my quest for property in the Winchester area.

Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.
Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.

Thank you John! Please let us know if we can further assist you!

Kristen Weigand Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Our family could not have been more pleased with our experience with Tarter Realty! The team at Tarter worked to help us move easily through the process and welcomed our family home. Thanks Team Tarter!

Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.
Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.

Thank you Kristen! You have been great to work with!

Casey Dyer Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Excellent local business with a group of professionals! Done business with them buying & selling. Smooth transactions each time.

Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.
Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.

Thanks Casey! We have enjoyed working with you and helping you purchase your beautiful home!

Nathan Simmons Published on Google

Negative experience: Horrible experience, expensive items without a photo and not advertised, unclear communication, no way that I will attend another of their auctions. I would never use them to sell anything. Dishonest approach in my opinion.

Bill Rinehart Published on Google

Negative experience: My total correspondence consisted of text messages. Never a phone call. Very impersonal. Made me feel as though I wasn't important enough for a one on one phone call. Might want to rethink their approach to being customer oriented.

Leave your opinion about Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co.:

1 = Poor
5 = Excellent

Reviews are checked before they are published. We do not publish reviews containing insults, accusations of criminal conduct or references to specific individuals. We also do not verify that the author was a customer.

Tarter Realty Auction & Appraisal Co. appears in the following listings:

Other real estate agencies you might be interested in

5 (51)
Paul Faddis - Your Real Estate Professional

Paul Faddis - Your Real Estate Professional

View address and contact details
123 W Franklin St Suite 300 - 47394, Winchester
+1765-595-8155

Add your real estate agency to our directory for free

If you manage a real estate agency and want to appear in our guide, send us your company information and you can appear completely free of charge.

Add your real estate agency for free

The largest real estate directory in United States

Find the best real estate agencies near you