Dietrich Rentals
Dietrich Rentals is a premier local property management company dedicated to serving Madison, Limestone, and Morgan County. We specialize in helping homeowners maximize their rental income while freeing them from the day-to-day hassles of property management. Our philosophy is simple yet powerful: we treat every home as if it were our own, with an unwavering commitment to quality over quantity.
We offer a comprehensive suite of management services designed to provide peace of mind and professionalism. From conducting thorough tenant background checks and credit verifications to handling all maintenance requests with licensed and insured contractors, we manage every detail. Our services include strategic advertising, lease drafting, rent collection, and secure escrow management for security deposits. We pride ourselves on providing exceptional customer service, integrity, and transparency to our property owners.
Whether you are an active military member, a homeowner seeking reliable management, or a prospective tenant looking for high-quality rentals in the Madison area, Dietrich Rentals is here to help. We ensure a smooth leasing process for applicants and deliver reliable, professional support for owners. Contact us today at (256) 457-3903 for a free consultation or to explore our available properties.
Opening hours
- sunday: (closed)
- monday: 9h-18h
- tuesday: 9h-14h
- wednesday: 9h-18h
- thursday: 9h-14h
- friday: 9h-14h
- saturday: (closed)
Photos of Dietrich Rentals
Our comment from ImmoNetwork about Dietrich Rentals:
A Proven Track Record of Property Management Excellence
Dietrich Rentals has established itself as a leading property management firm serving Madison, Limestone, and Morgan counties. With a philosophy centered on treating every home as if it were their own, the agency prioritizes **quality over quantity**, offering owners a turnkey solution that maximizes rental income while eliminating daily management burdens. Their comprehensive approach covers the entire lifecycle of a rental property, from strategic marketing and thorough tenant background checks to secure deposit management and **24/7 maintenance coordination** with licensed contractors.
Exceptional Responsiveness and Transparent Communication
What truly distinguishes Dietrich Rentals is the **exceptional responsiveness** of its team, particularly owner Carolyn Dietrich and her core staff. Numerous long-term clients highlight the team's ability to resolve issues with remarkable speed, often describing their service as "above and beyond." Whether addressing emergency maintenance requests or providing regular financial updates, the company fosters a relationship built on **transparency and trust**. Owners frequently praise the ease of their management portal and the proactive communication that keeps properties running smoothly without the need for micromanagement.
Expertise in Commercials and Sales
Beyond rental management, the agency demonstrates strong competency in **real estate sales and relocation services**. Their deep local knowledge has proven invaluable for military families and professionals relocating to the area, ensuring quick placement in high-quality homes. Furthermore, their ability to manage the sale of managed properties has been noted as a significant asset, with agents effectively handling staging, repairs, and negotiations to secure favorable outcomes for their clients.
Client-Centric Values and Community Care
The agency’s commitment extends beyond business transactions, reflecting a genuine care for its community. Clients have appreciated thoughtful gestures such as providing severe weather warnings and shelter information, reinforcing the company’s reputation for **integrity and human connection**. While the company maintains rigorous standards for lease compliance, the overwhelming consensus among satisfied clients is that Dietrich Rentals offers a professional, reliable, and supportive partnership for both property owners and tenants alike.
Dietrich Rentals: Reviews
Reviews are the opinions of their authors. We do not verify that the author was a customer.
Reviews on Google
4,0 out of 5 from 55 reviews
Fantastic experience: Our family had an excellent experience renting from Dietrich Rentals. As first-time renters, we weren’t sure what to expect, but the entire process was smooth and professional from start to finish. Whenever an issue came up, their team responded quickly and took care of it right away. Their prompt communication and maintenance gave us peace of mind throughout our time there. The neighborhood was quiet, well-kept, and the neighbors took pride in maintaining their yards, making it a wonderful place to live. We were also very pleased with every staff member we interacted with—they were always friendly, helpful, and professional. We would have happily stayed longer, but we were fortunate enough to purchase our forever home. We truly appreciate the great experience we had with Dietrich Rentals and would highly recommend them to anyone looking for a rental home.
Fantastic experience: I have never seen a property manager so responsive and flexible. Handled and emergency like an absolute champ!! If I ever move, it will be somewhere within the Dietrich properties. They have more than won my loyalty and trust! Thank you Shy and crew for all you do :) UPDATE: 5+ years later and I am still with Dietrich and my review holds firm. Absolute class act all around! Our supervisor, Mindi, is an absolute wonder. Thank you Dietrich and all your hardworking crew. You have really help make my place feel like home!
Negative experience: Do not recommend. We lived in a property for 2+ years. They ended up taking over 75% of our security deposit for things like replacing 2 cheap LVP boards, small spots where tape took a nickel sized piece of paint off the ceiling, replacing an air filter, “repair a loose towel bar”, and several other normal wear and tear aspects of living in a house. Also charged us $400 for “a lot of cleaning” when the only thing I can think of that we didn’t clean were some leaves in the garage
Fantastic experience: Carolyn at Dietrich Rentals has been an excellent property manager for my long-term rental in Madison. She’s extremely communicative, easy to reach when questions come up, and handles issues quickly and professionally. Maintenance requests are coordinated fast and I get clear status updates throughout. Move-out and turnover items were handled efficiently and professionally. Her systems make ownership genuinely passive without me needing to micromanage. Highly recommend Carolyn if you want a seamless, reliable property management experience.
Negative experience: I thought we had a great thing, getting a 1300 sq ft house, with a fenced backyard, for $1700/month in Madison. Best Elementary school in MadCo. I was a teacher working at Sparkman, and the commute was simple, basically a straight line. I loved the location. Fast forward to now, we've moved out and they sent us the itemized reason why we didn't get our security deposit back. Let me tell you, this is where this company will STEAL from you. They will fabricate things. They will charge you for nearly everything they can and leave you with nothing. When we moved in, the house was dirty. The kitchen was unclean, and I do not mean dust... I mean, it was NEVER cleaned. There were roach pads everywhere, similar to a handyman buying a 12 pack and dropping them everywhere. Guess what? When we moved in, we saw dead roaches and threw them out. They've dealt with it, right? NOPE! They billed us for their own infestation. Go further, my wife works in a kitchen. She was Publix manager for 10 years in the Bakery, where an external company that's tougher than the state, comes in and judges everything. Let me tell you, she keeps the cleanest kitchen I've ever seen. But no, there was another "billable." The kitchen wasn't clean, they stated. Now, I'm starting to think that I have to take them to court. Additionally, they allowed pets, and we had two ESA dogs, that slept in cages, in the living room with it's vinyl flooring. But, SOMEHOW, 2/3 rooms had a "pet smell." Regardless of our deep cleanings, Rug Doctor, Deodorizers, and everything else. No, what it is, is a simple fact they know that we had dogs, and they're going to "tax" us for it. Even though it was okay and acceptable, we're paying for it, twice. In fact, the only thing that was worth their taking some of the funds, was a ring, caused by an office chair, on their precious vinyl flooring. $600. They "smell" pets, don't clean themselves, but charge you for "not cleaning," even when you completely did, and everything else... you've lost that money. THESE PEOPLE ARE CROOKS. Stay away. You don't need to do business with them. And stay away from the ROACH infested 121 Grayson. They knew it was a problem and charged us $300 to fix the problem that they knew was there. This company is awful. Money is God, I guess... because customer service isn't. Don't even look into their actual open office hours.
Fantastic experience: All around a great rental management company. I was with them for 3 years as a renter. They're responsive to maintenance requests, questions, and any assistance with cold weather, or other unique issues we encountered. There's an easy to deal with portal for payments, application, and maintenance requests. Consistent professional crew working there and solid contractors. They're responsibly stringent about their terms in the rental agreement; if not a bit exhaustive, but do your due dilligence, in good faith, and they'll treat you the same, in my experience. It seems they care about the homes they manage on behalf of the owners - there were occasions when they seemed to act as an active bridge for communication between the homeowner and renter as well. The rental company owner even helped me out personally on a few occasions and I'd wish her and the team nothing but the best.
Fantastic experience: I appreciate this company so much. They have done us a service by sending us severe weather warnings and listing storm shelter locations. Thank you for the humanity and kindness you have extended to your tenants.
Fantastic experience: You would be hard pressed to find a better property management company in the Huntsville area. I have been doing business with Carolyn and her team for years. They are professional, responsive and honest. They have absolutely gone above and beyond in their duties as a property management company and I would highly recommend them to anyone looking for an excellent property management company.
Fantastic experience: Dietrich rentals has been outstanding! I have used Dietrich as my property manager since 2015. The first time we received orders to Korea and Carolyn (Owner) and her team made our transition easy and promptly had the house rented after a few weeks. We returned to our home in 2019, and the house had been maintained very well. We again received orders to Belgium in 2021 and immediately contacted Dietrich to get our house rent ready. It did not take long for us to have a tenant, a few months after we left. Unfortunately, we have listed our house for sale as we’re retiring in Texas. Our realtor stated that Dietrich had been instrumental in ensuring the house was under contract so quickly. I want to thank the whole Dietrich team for the many years of support, professionalism, and dedication to their customers!
Fantastic experience: We rent with Dietrich from recommendation from a realtor friend, in a quiet & convenient part of town. The property is lovely, and we're so happy to have a whole house & yard! Our rental company repairman is prompt, professional, and personable, and communication from Dietrich is very timely. Overall, we love our rental home!
Fantastic experience: Excellent property management service. Good, honest people. They went above and beyond in helping us get into a rental in Huntsville. We can't thank them enough. Highly recommended!
Fantastic experience: I’ve been renting with Dietrich going on 3 years now ( 2 different properties) and I’ve had nothing but positive experiences from the office staff to Maintance staff.
Fantastic experience: Always enjoyed Dietrich!
Fantastic experience: Good rentals housing ..good property manger
Fantastic experience: I would like to say that I am more than happy with the apartment that I am renting through Dietrich Rental. Aside from the apartment itself, I am extremely happy with the service provided by their staff. Carolyn and her staff has been such a huge help to me and my wife . Whenever we need anything, we contact her and receive a response instantly. I give a 5 star rating and would highly recommend them to others.
Fantastic experience: Carolyn is wonderful to work with. Very responsive, professional, and knowledgeable! We have been working with her to get our rental property listed and she has been 100% on top of every question and request we have had
Negative experience: If you are an owner: Choose a different property manager. I was a renter, and while the house I rented was in livable condition, it was in no way maintained in excellent condition. This was the first rental company I've used that did not provide pest control or lawn care. Service is hit or miss. For plumbing issues we had service same week. It took two months plus to get electrical work done on a GFCI in the kitchen. When the technician came out, he commented that the neutral was burned and melted. A clear fire risk. The company's excuse was that they have 500ish properties and only three employees. Only one of them deals with maintenance. Your property will get lost in the cracks. At move out we had no correspondence for a month. When I inquired, I was told that the move out would be finished that weekend. Two weeks later I had to threaten legal action for them to actually finish our move out. Their excuse: they had 60 days to finish and 90 days to pay me. Look up Alabama statutes and you will see this is blatantly incorrect. When my fiancé moved in I informed them that we may be having service dogs, and the customer service rep asked: "Well what does she need them for? What's her problem?" which I'm fairly sure is against ADA. They don't know the law and May end up getting themselves and you as an owner sued. Overall a poorly run business that will not maintain your property's value. For renters: All of the above, and the rent increase at the end of the lease was almost 10%. I know it's cheap, but you get what you pay for.
Fantastic experience: This is the second time we have worked with Dietrich, and we are so thankful for them! They make the process so easy & after working with a horrible company previously, this was such a nice change. They really go above and beyond to get things done in a timely manner and I truly appreciate that. Thank you Carolyn!
Fantastic experience: I’ve rented 3 different properties from Dietrich and have had nothing but good experiences with them. When ever a problem occurred they handled it quickly and professionally. They always followed up the few times we did need repairs or service on the properties. I couldn’t recommend them enough.
Negative experience: One of the worst decisions I ever made was renting through Dietrich. They're unprofessional and rude to their renters. They'll threaten you by telling you things like " we better not get on a bad foot" when I asked about the status of the AC guys and the manager said that I gave the AC guys the wrong number when the only number that the AC guys have is the number that is in Dietrich system, but yet Dietrich is able to contact me for payment on the phone that they said is the wrong number I gave them when I signed the lease. The manager is very obnoxious and argumentative and doesn't communicate very well. I wouldn't be surprised if the good reviews that you see on this feed are people who have no association with Dietrich. I would stay far away!
Negative experience: If I could leave less than 0 stars I would. I have lived in numerous rental houses and apartments and the last two years have easily been the worst experience my husband and I have ever had. We have always been (and continue to be) extremely respectful and honest tenants anywhere we’ve been. Shy Needle was usually our contact, and she consistently treated my husband and I with immense disrespect. The few times we got to interact with Carolyn she was very respectful and professional. Over these two years, the house we rented had major water damage as well as termites, and Shy made a very unpleasant situation even more difficult. Even the owners of the house reached out to us to apologize for her poor behavior - we had been out of the house due to it being a complete construction zone and she had not even notified them until a few weeks into the process. She was always difficult to get in contact with and seemed to brush our needs off to the side. Dietrich violated our lease multiple times, and upon move out Shy unethically charged us money from our initial deposit. I would never recommend renting through this company simply because of her. Very disappointed with our Dietrich experience and very glad it’s over.
Positive experience: Molly is the best!!!!!
Negative experience: No response
Fantastic experience: Best in town great customer service
Fantastic experience: I have used Dietrich Rentals to manage my property over the past eight years. Carolyn and her team are all very professional and have the process down for finding quality long-term tenants. I am pleased to say that my property remained rented throughout the duration of our business arrangement, providing a good secondary income stream for my family. I highly recommend their services. Sincerely, D.R.
Thank you for trusting us to manage your property and all the great years of business! Glad we could help you sell your house too, we’ll miss you!
Fantastic experience: Great reality company
Negative experience: I do not recommend this company at all. Very disappointed from beginning to end.
Fantastic experience: Currently renting and the staff is professional and wonderful. Response to maintenance needs urgently and with qualified candidates/companies.
Positive experience: Nice people
Fantastic experience: Where do I begin? I first met Carolyn Dietrich in 2015. I was trying to rent my home while going through several major life events. Needless to say, I was very overwhelmed. A friend highly recommended her to me. I had contacted a few property management companies prior to my first conversation with Carolyn. To the outsider, another person’s home is just a dwelling without an emotional connection. To me, my home was a blessing from God and a source of pride at being able to independently acquire it as a single woman. During the telephone interview, I asked her what made her so special or set her apart from the other companies. Among other things, she told me that as a small business, she was able to provide red carpet service. I was sold! Over the years, she did NOT disappoint me. She ensured my home had renters who cared for it and actually enjoyed residing there. She professionally resolved the few disagreements between the renters and me. She and her team ensured my home was SPOTLESS when the first renter vacated. Due to her team’s diligence and tenacity, new tenants were qualified and in place in about 15 days. On the afternoon of 31 October 2017, Carolyn informed me that the tenants would like to not only purchase my home but also close before Christmas! I was elated and skeptical at the same time because I knew they were first time home buyers. I prayed about the situation. God answered my prayer. Carolyn agreed to represent both parties and went above and beyond to create a win-win situation for both parties. We closed on 20 December 2017! That is a BIG deal for first time home buyers to get qualified, obtain a down payment, have inspection issues resolved, and have all paperwork correct to close in 50 days during a holiday period! Carolyn Dietrich has been and continues to be a blessing and great source of information in recommending companies to perform work in my current home. Carolyn, THANK YOU for all you have done for me! I whole-heartedly appreciate you! Without a doubt, Carolyn Dietrich, Dietrich & Associates Real Estate, and Dietrich Rentals sincerely provide RED CARPET service.
Fantastic experience: Carolyn and her staff are true property management professionals. They responded to tenant issues immediately and provided all rental documentation accurately and on time. Absolutely glitch free!
Fantastic experience: My wife and I moved to the Huntsville/Madison County area on extremely short notice right after the Christmas holiday season. We had a very short timeframe to find a rental house, and luckily the home we found ended up being one that was managed by Carolyn Dietrich/Dietrich Rentals. We stayed in this house for 18 months until we were ready to purchase our own house, and during that time the service from Dietrich rentals was nothing short of excellent. Any time we reported a maintenance issue, we had a phone call within the hour from either Dietrich Rentals or a service company asking when they could come fix the issue. This includes an air conditioning unit that decided to stop working at 10 pm on a Saturday night in the middle of the Alabama Summer. Quick response is an understatement. In our experience, sometimes even the best property management companies really show their true colors when it comes time to leave a rental. Thankfully, Dietrich Rentals was nothing like this when we moved out. They were completely transparent about property condition throughout our stay at the rental house and recouping our deposit after we moved out was extremely easy. This alone puts Dietrich Rentals above any property management company that I have ever personally dealt with. I would absolutely recommend Dietrich Rentals/Carolyn Dietrich to anyone in the Huntsville area.
Fantastic experience: Our experience with Carolyn was fantastic! With 3 kids and one on the way, needing to stay in the same school district, and several other specifics, Carolyn was great at finding houses that met all of our needs. She was very patient with my extremely sick, pregnant wife, and when we found "THE" house, she did everything in her power to help us get this house.
Fantastic experience: Carolyn is awesome. She was the agent on a rental property I owned for several years and she did a great job with that. Her team was always responsive, they were good about taking care of repairs, and my payments were always received on time. Also, I recently sold the rental property and I used Carolyn as the agent. She did a great job on that as well. She went above and beyond and took care of any repairs or maintenance that needed to be done while the house was vacant. She also staged the house, which was very helpful. I didn't live in the same state as the house, so It would of been very difficult for me to sell the house without someone like her helping. I would highly recommend her as both a rental agent and a selling agent.
Positive experience: First time renting from them. So far so good!
Fantastic experience: Absolutely love working with Carolyn, Shy and staff at Dietrich Rentals. They have been managing our property for several years and have done an outstanding job. They keep us informed and have made our job so much easier. We appreciate the great job and plan on having a long relationship with them. Highly recommend!!!!
Fantastic experience: Working with Carolyn Dietrich or David Dill is always a pleasure. They really take great care of their properties. In this day and age its very hard to find someone who truly cares and Dietrich Rentals is one who does. I highly recommend them.
Fantastic experience: We have used Dietrich Rentals for a year now to manage our investment properties. Carolyn and her staff have helped us grow our portfolio to six homes. They have always been attentive, courteous, professional, and offer great advice. We recommend her every chance we get!
Negative experience: THE WORST PROPERTY MANAGEMENT COMPANY ON PLANET EARTH!!! I would rather live under a bridge before ever renting from this company again!
Fantastic experience: Dietrich rentals is a first class professional rental company. The agents are some of the best in the business from returning phone calls to offering other home options to closing on the property. I have enjoyed doing business with them.
Fantastic experience: I rented a home from this company many years ago and they are currently my property manager for my personal rental property. That should say enough in itself. Best property management company in North Alabama!
Fantastic experience: We rented a home from Dietrich Rentals for a year and had no problems. Ms. Carolyn was very helpful, kind and was able to answer all of our questions. I would recommend her company to anyone. ^_^
Negative experience: Dietrich Rentals is the most unprofessional real estate company I've ever dealt with. My husband and I and my father have excellent rental history with references to prove it so we are not just some disgruntled clients. We have never had problems like we have had here with Dietrich. Her partner, Lisa, is a liar and makes promises she can't keep and does so without permission from the owner. She tells her associated one thing when relaying a message but then does another. For example, we were told we would not have to have the carpets cleaned when we left. Yet they charged us for carpet cleaning. They told us we had to clean the house before we left. I did. On hands and knees and with help. Yet they charged us $450 for a cleaning lady. We viewed the house we rented as others were moving out. It was in serious disrepair and it was filthy. She assured us that all would be taken care of. It wasn't. The yard was a mud hole and they refused to fix it. I made a seriously detailed walk-through sheet listing every little nail hole. Turns out they lost it and had the audacity to insist that we, of course, never turned one in. We were charged for things because of their idiocy.. I have never been more displeased with someone in my life. Not only that but they didn't even have the decency to let us see what "damage" they claimed we had done. We've yet to see pictures or proof of anything and they already have people living in there now. I wouldn't wish them on anyone.
Leave your opinion about Dietrich Rentals:
Dietrich Rentals appears in the following listings:
Other real estate agencies you might be interested in
The Jill Heffernan Group
John Wesley Brooks - Huntsville Alabama Real Estate Agent. Relocation, Luxury Homes & Investment
Ainsley Runels, BHHS Rise Real Estate Huntsville
Embry Group at Crue Realty
Cornerstone Real Estate
Cummings Real Estate
Rosenblum Realty, Inc.
Add your real estate agency to our directory for free
If you manage a real estate agency and want to appear in our guide, send us your company information and you can appear completely free of charge.