Yellow Key Property Management

401 North Ave Ste 16, 60181, Villa Park

Yellow Key Property Management is a premier, full-service real estate agency and property management firm based in Villa Park, IL, with over 22 years of experience serving the Chicagoland area. Specializing in the western suburbs, the company provides comprehensive management solutions for property owners and investors across DuPage County, Kane County, and parts of suburban Cook and Will County. Their extensive local expertise covers numerous communities including Naperville, Aurora, Downers Grove, Elmhurst, and Schaumburg, ensuring that every investment is managed by experts who understand the nuances of the regional rental market.

The team at Yellow Key is dedicated to building mutually beneficial, long-term relationships with their clients rather than focusing on quick profits. Their approach is holistic and transparent, offering a complete suite of services designed to maximize rental income while minimizing owner hassle. Key services include aggressive property marketing to secure high-quality tenants quickly, rigorous tenant screening processes, and efficient rent collection with a remarkable 99.3% collection rate. Owners benefit from detailed financial reporting, online portal access for real-time account monitoring, and proactive maintenance coordination that handles everything from routine repairs to emergency responses 24/7.

Backed by a leadership team of licensed Illinois brokers and real estate professionals, Yellow Key Property Management combines financial acumen with operational excellence. They assist with lease drafting, eviction support, rental license compliance, and even offer advanced tools like ROI and vacancy loss calculators to help investors make informed decisions. Whether managing a single home or a large portfolio, Yellow Key ensures properties remain profitable, well-maintained, and compliant with local regulations, providing peace of mind for property owners throughout the Chicago metropolitan area.

Opening hours

  • sunday: (closed)
  • monday: 10h-17h
  • tuesday: 10h-17h
  • wednesday: 10h-17h
  • thursday: 10h-17h
  • friday: 10h-17h
  • saturday: (closed)

Yellow Key Property Management: Reviews

4.9/5 (96 Reviews)

Reviews are the opinions of their authors. We do not verify that the author was a customer.

Reviews on Google

4,9 out of 5 from 96 reviews

Diane Paxton Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Yellow Key management company responses immediately to any request that is submitted. I have never been so happy with a management company as I am with this one They take very good care of all their tenants and no problem is too small for them to address immediately. The communication with Yellow Key property is excellent, Constant communication until the job is done.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thank you for the great review. We're always happy to help.

Nicholas Robins Published on Google

Negative experience: Don't recommend. Think twice before using this company. They ended my contract early while I still had a tenant in the house. Left me with a very bad tenant. They wont provide proof that they vetted the tenant, such as proof of income, cash Flow (consecutive bank statements), 1099s, W-2s, filed tax returns, Employment/Business Verification, or credit details and score. The tenant skipped rent twice and left utility bills in my name, along with damage to the house I had to pay for. I had to pay to get new tenants in. I was deployed and not in Chicago, so that I couldn't manage the property myself, and it left me with a mess that cost about 10k in damages, time off work, and bills. Ultimately, I paid them to find good tenants; they got a bad one, and they left me to manage it myself while I was deployed. I had to cover the damage. I want my fee back for the first month's rent because of this, but based on prior emails, I will have to use certified mail since I haven't heard back from them.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thank you for your input. We understand landlord related frustration better than most, but context is important. We have not managed your property since June of 2025. Now, 15 months later, you appear to have had a dispute with your outgoing tenant.

In September 2023, we sent you a screening summary covering the applicant’s income, background, and credit information. You approved the tenant via email at that time. In two years of interacting with your tenants, they were respectful, reasonable regarding maintenance requests, and paid their rent.

In 2025 we terminated management of your property due to your direct contact and verbal abuse of one of our maintenance vendors in violation of our business practices.

At that time, we provided adequate notice per our management agreement, provided all proper documentation, provided you with the full tenant security deposit (which was substantial), and notified the tenant properly. We also provided you with a referral to another local management company who could help you with ongoing management of the property. Your tenant’s rental balance was 100% paid in full, and they had not violated any portion of their lease agreement in any way.

We do understand your difficulty while managing the property yourself after we were no longer your agent, but your account was closed out professionally and with all rents and deposits paid in full. We wish you the best moving forward and we thank you for your service.

jbernard_ Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I've been working with Yellow Key for years and they’ve been fantastic. If looking for a property management company in western suburbs I highly recommend!

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thank you. We appreciate it.

Karen Sebring Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Very pleased at how quickly yellow key gets back to us and resolves any issues that have occurred around the property, they have responded immediately and have had someone out ASAP to repair. Everything from moving in to currently we’ve been very pleased and definitely would rent from yellow key again based on our experience.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thanks Karen. We're always happy to help.

Greg H Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Fantastic company to work with. Have made renting easy and carefree. Would work with them again in a heartbeat.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thanks Greg! Always happy to assist. Let us know if there is anything else we can do to help make your stay at the property a positive one.

J L Published on Google

Fantastic experience: We’ve had a great experience with Yellow Key Property Management. Anthony was great during the leasing process. Juan and Tim have been fantastic with any maintenance requests. They have been professional, responsive, and I think they are one of the best property management companies around.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thank you for the great review. Our team works hard to help make the resident experience a positive one. We're always happy to help in any way we can. We appreciate you as a tenant.

Debra Ross Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I have been with Yellow Key for many years. They have ALWAYS been attentive and courteous. Almost all of of the contractors have been as well (99%).

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thank you Debra. Great tenants make it easy to do our job well. We appreciate having you as a long-time resident in the property.

Sanjuana Ruiz Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Buen día sí tenemos muy buena respuesta y eficiencia y atención de Yellow Key Property Management al momento son muy profesionales y en nuestra experiencia la empresa es muy cumplida siempre gracias por su confianza es excelente de la mejor de aquí del Condado de Dupage.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thank you very much for the review. We're glad that all of your maintenance issues are being resolved promptly and you are happy with the property. We work hard to respond as quickly as possible.

Clyde Porter Published on Google

Fantastic experience: “We’ve had a great experience with Yellow Key Property Management. Over the past 3 years, they’ve been professional, responsive, and I think they are one of the best property management companies in DuPage County. They even helped to facilitate a conversation of support with our Landlord, related to readjusting our rent. It was truly appreciated, and I'm hopeful we can continue to count on each other - in the future.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Clyde, we appreciate the great review and we’re happy to help whenever we can. As always, contact us if we can be of any further assistance.

Rob Serpico Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Ben and his team are the best! Always a pleasure working with them

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thank you Rob.

Cristian Delgado Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Great experience renting with Yellow Key. They’re always quick to respond to any questions or concerns and genuinely go the extra mile for their tenants. Everyone has been friendly and easy to work with, and the online payment portal makes everything super convenient. Definitely recommend!

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thanks Christian. Glad we were able to help you out with the service call this past weekend.

Peter LIPTAY Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Never had a problem .Ben and all the staff were fantastic. If there was something wrong they always got right on it. Good people. Thanks guys.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thank you. It's been great having you guys as tenants these last 7 years.

Aidan Hanlon Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Great company! Love working with you guys.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thank you Aidan.

Steven Rigitano Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I’m so very thankful to Ben is been very helpful and very polite and he works well with his tenants. He’s a great project manager. Thank you again Steve.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thanks Steve! Glad to have you as a tenant in the building in Villa Park.

Miguel Dominguez Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Juan siempre así responsable cuando tenemos un problema en el departamento los soluciona el problema

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thanks Miguel. Glad we have been able to help with any items you needed in the apartment.

Jason Dy-Johnson Published on Google

Fantastic experience: We've had a great experience with Yellow Key managing our rental property. They respond quickly and professionally to any questions or issues.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thanks Jason. It was great working with you as well.

rajesh pulinthanathu Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Yellow key prop mgmt has been helping us for the past 18 years. excellent customer service. Strongly recommend.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thanks Rajesh. Hard to believe we've been working together so long. As always, let us know if we can ever be of any further assistance.

J FM Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Yellow Key has managed our property for several years. From the very beginning, Anthony has been consistently reliable, responsive, and proactive. The entire team makes ownership entirely stress-free, and we highly recommend their services to anyone seeking dependable property management.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thank you so much for the review. We truly appreciate having you as a client and working with you to manage the property.

Mark Leventhal Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I"ve had a great experience with Yellow Key Property Management, they’ve been professional, responsive, and I think they are one of the best property management companies.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thanks Mark. We appreciate having you as a long term client over the last 12+ years.

Jayantilal Patel Published on Google

Fantastic experience: “We’ve had a great experience with Yellow Key Property Management, they’ve been professional, responsive, and I think they are one of the best property management companies in DuPage County.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Christian and the Yellow Key Property Management team are committed to providing professional service, and we're glad to hear that our responsiveness and communication have been helpful for both you and your tenants.

Dawn Jacobs Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Great management company. We view our rentals as investments and are thrilled to work with a company that appreciates that. The contractors they use are fair and do the job right.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thank you Dawn. I has been great working with you over these last 12 years. As always, let us know if there is anything we can assist with.

Tim Altergott Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Anthony and Ben were very helpful in explaining the process of working with Yellow Key up front, how to prepare our first home to be rented out so it was ready for a new family to move in, the listing process, tenant screening, etc. Smooth sailing - Thank you!

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Tim, you've been a great client to work with. We really appreciate you being responsive and reasonable with requests to keep the property in good shape. Thank you.

Noah Jones Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Yellow Key is a wonderful management group. They are easy to work with and do a great job!

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thanks Noah. We look forward to continuing to work together.

Paola Ramos Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Hemos tenido una muy buena experiencia con yellow key .son muy eficientes en sus servios atienden muy rápido gracias al señor Juan Cabrera por estar al pendiente

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Paola, thank you for the review. We're glad Juan has been able to help with your service requests.

Dora Mendoza Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I have No complains. I always get respond when I needed. One time. I was locked outside of my Apartment and Maintenance guy. It was not at the Apartments at the time the Manager came to open my door and I really appreciate that Definitely we have a good management

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Dora, thank you. No problem on the lockout. We were happy to help.

Gwendolyn Harris Published on Google

Fantastic experience: STML Realty Group is professional, prompt and courteous. They consistently go the extra mile for their clients and tenants.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thank you for your wonderful review!

GLORIA Simosky Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Always available to answer questions . Anthony listens and communicates quickly. He always has the owner's best interests. Yet, the tenants are happy, too. Payments are promptly taken and made. Choosing Yellow Key Property Management is one of the best choices I have made.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Gloria, thank you for the thoughtful review. We enjoy working with you to manage the properties. Continue to let us know if we can be of any assistance.

Jan Lescher Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Yellow Key has been great - we switched to their services several years ago after a bad experience with another property manager, and we are very happy with our decision. Their statements are easy to understand and responses are fast and efficient. Thank you!

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thank you for your kind review! We're so glad to hear that your decision to switch to Yellow Key Property Management has been a positive one. We strive to provide clear, efficient communication and are happy that our services have met your expectations.

Jeanne Winsted Rosser, LCSW Published on Google

Fantastic experience: The staff at Yellow Key Property Management, starting with my first encounter with Anais was extremely helpful. Ben, in particular, went out of his way to provide assistance. It was truly a pleasure to deal with them.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Jeanne. Thank you for the kind words. Glad we were able to assist and get you the information that you needed.

Matthew Schulz Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Yellow Key is very easy to work with and always provides fast communication.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Matt, thank you for the review. It's been great working with you so far. We look forward to continuing the positive experience. As always, please reach out if we can help with anything or if you have any questions.

A Wollenberg Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Yellow Key has been tremendously helpful with three separate major maintenance issues at my property. They coordinated with and secured a company that did a great job rebuilding our porch and balcony. They also helped us out with a difficult roof replacement. Most recently, I had a washing machine fail and flood my laundry room and finished basement. I called Yellow Key at 6:30am on a Saturday morning and they arrived at my property with a mediation company within 90 minutes. Work started the same day. They do a great job maintaining their properties and use high quality companies for repairs.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thank you. We are proud of the work our vendors do at our rental properties. They are an extension of our company and we take a lot of time to select and vet them carefully.

Andrew C Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Yellow Key has managed my home for the past 3 years. Always extremely responsive and professional. Highly recommend their services. Anthony has been a pleasure to work with.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Andrew, thank you for the review. We appreciate your continued business.

Blake Booth Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Great property management company. Kylie was very communicative, responsive, and easy to work with. Highly recommend.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thank you for your kind words and recommendation! We’re glad to hear Kylie provided such communicative and responsive service.

Jorge Nicolas Published on Google

Fantastic experience: This guy help me up to get my keys faster good company to work with 100%

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Jorge, thanks for stopping by the office to grab keys to your new apartment. Happy to get you in a few days early so that you can get started with your move-in before the end of the month.

Christopher Curtin Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Yellow Key represented the owner of a condo I rented for a number of years. They were always prompt to respond to any issues I had with the property, and also very good in forwarding any necessary communication from the seller and the HOA that I could not receive directly. It was a pleasure to have their services available during my time as a renter.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Christopher, we really appreciate the kind words. You were a great tenant and we're thrilled that you were able to close on the property. Reach out to us if we can ever be of further assistance.

ddonato Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Go Minis & Glen Ellyn Mayflower are happy to be working with Yellow Key Property Management and their clients. We will be providing moving and storage services. Ben is great to work with and we are excited about our future partnership.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thank you very much. We look forward to working with you.

Vicky Medina Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Yellow Key Property Management is truly an outstanding company. They are very attentive and quick to respond to any and all questions you may have. I have to give a special thanks to Juan Cabrera he is very understanding and polite any issues we had he was always quick to schedule someone to get to us. I recommend anyone that is thinking about them you will be in good hands. Company has great communication and outstanding customer service, you will not regret working with them.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Vicky, thank you very much. Juan does a great job taking care of our tenants. We're happy that you had a good experience with our team.

Tim Johnson Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Yellow key takes great care in the upkeep and management of their properties. As a vendor it’s great to always have the staff be available for answers or approval. Payment is always prompt; never have to wait or chase down invoices. Yellow Key is one of the best out there. Evolution Property Maintenance

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Tim, thanks for the positive feedback. It's important for us to have good relationships with our preferred vendors. We appreciate the quality of the maintenance work that you do at the properties.

Ralph Wheaton Published on Google

Fantastic experience: As property owner I am extremely happy with their professionalism and reliability. They make it much easier to be a landlord.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thanks Ralph. It was a pleasure working with you guys over the last 10 years. Let us know if there is anything else we can help you with down the road.

Sergio Perez Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Great Company to work with never had any issues , very communicative also they pay their invoices super quick never had issues with this company!

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thanks Sergio.

Bob Sloan Published on Google

Fantastic experience: It is my pleasure to share our experience with Christian Carlson and YellowKey. Christian served us for most of the time we resided at 1247 Timberline Drive in Bartlett, IL. During this time, my wife and I often commented on the outstanding service we received from Christian. He was prompt, knowledgeable, and personally involved when we needed assistance. I have rarely, if ever, been involved with a professional who provided such excellent service.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thank you Bob.

Dana Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I rented with Yellow Key for three years in Naperville. Any issues that came up were addressed immediately. Christian was always looking out for me and the property. Easy payment online. I would work with them again in a heartbeat.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Dana, it has been a pleasure having you as a tenant for the last few years. We've cared for that property for 14 years and are happy that you will have the opportunity to enjoy the home moving forward. Let us know if there is anything else you need.

Karen Wehrli Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Anthony was quick to respond and extremely professional. In this business, communication is paramount especially working with clients that under a timeframe with little inventory. Anthony was refreshing to work with!

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thanks Karen. Anthony works hard to make sure our communication and leasing processes run smoothly and professionally. Please keep us in mind if any opportunities arise in the future.

Jeffrey Heyn Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Yellow Key is a very efficient, punctual and transparent company. The mgmt team was a pleasure to work with. I highly recommend them.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Jeff, it's been great doing business with you. Thanks.

nickbdoin Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Pleasant experience from start to finish. Christian has been great and would recommend Yellow Key.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thanks Nick. It was great having you as a tenant. We wish you the best moving forward.

Kimberlee (KiKi) Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I personally cannot say enough about Yellow Key Property Management. From the easy use of their website, to the fulfillment of your requests, and through the customer service, you will be taken care of on all fronts thoroughly and promptly. They are a hands on company, that make the conscious effort to be successful in making your place not just a property, but a home. Christian is phenomenal.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thank you! We appreciate your feedback.

Jack Knox Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Had a leak at our home over the weekend and management had someone on site within hours. The few problems we have had over the past 5 years have been fixed quickly and efficiently. Yellow Key is a very good group that cares about their tenants! Thanks to all of you!

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thanks Jack. Let us know if there is anything else you need.

Eliud Echevarria Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Very impressed!!! I would highly recommend Yellow Key Property & Chistan Carlson..They go over & beyond to make sure issues are solved in a timely matter, i locked myself out my apartment & Mr.Christan Carlson made a heroic effert to make sure my problem was solved in a timely matter!!!! 5 STARS PLUS IF POSSIBLE!!

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Eliud, thank you. Glad we were able to help out.

B Nolan Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Looking for attentive, courteous, friendly people to have as your management company? Look no further than the people at Yellowkey. I've spent many years trusting them with my needs, and have not be disappointed.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thank you sir. You’ve been a great tenant in multiple homes under our management over the years. You’ll always have the option to continue as a valued resident in one of the properties we manage.

terrill finley Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Christian is the best!! This property management company cares for tenants. Thank you for the last 6 years!!

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Terrill, thanks for the review and for being a great tenant!

Brady Feece Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Yellow Key has been a great resource for me and my family. Would highly recommend them to anyone in the Kane County area who is in need of property management services

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thank you for the feedback.

Melanie Husk Published on Google

Fantastic experience: For the last 4 years, I've had the opportunity to work with Christian and Yellow Key for my renting needs. He was always receptive to answering my calls, maintenance needs, and questions about lease renewal in a timely manner. We felt like he cared and made everything smooth sailing. I'd highly recommend them!

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thank you Melanie! We appreciate the positive feedback.

Tim Urbanowicz Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Fantastic firm! Great service and low cost

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Tim, thank you. It was a pleasure working with you as a client. Again, good luck with the closing on the Wheaton property. If you need anything at all, you know how to reach us.

M. Marquette Hunter Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Top Tier Business

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thank you sir. Appreciate working with you thus far. Look forward to running into you over at the property.

Eriel Davis Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Ben and Anthony at Yellow Key are great! All of their clients speak very highly of their management company, and love how communicative they are. You can't go wrong with this company, and they will take care of your property as if it's their own!

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thank you Eriel. We look forward to collaborating and working together in the future.

Bree Gray Published on Google

Fantastic experience: We rented our home within a rough market, lots of other options out there and a bad time of year. But, Ben and Anthony at yellow key really took it upon themselves to make our situation a priority and went above to ensure our house rented.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thank you Bree. Sometimes we need to think outside the box to get results. We appreciate you working with us to adjust our strategy quickly in order to place a good tenant. We look forward to managing the property moving forward.

Terri Roche Published on Google

Fantastic experience: My experience with Yellow Key Property Management and Christian has been amazing since it could have turned into a bad situation. He was very professional and took great care of the Warrenville rental and the negotiations between owner and tenant. I appreciate the quality and work ethic they bring to the area and I highly recommend using them as an owner or a tenant. It’s nice to have such a great experience.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Terri, we were happy to help. Thank you for working with us to close things out smoothly.

Jean Y Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Yellow Key Property Management is doing a great job to manage my rental property in Glendale Heights for the past few years . They are reliable . I would highly recommend if anyone needs property management service.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

It has been a pleasure to work with you over the last several years. Please let us know if there is anything at all that we can assist you with in the future. We wish you the best of luck with the sale of the property. Thank you again for being a great client.

rskone1 Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Yellow Key Property Management has been a great property manager. They provided property management services over the past couple years for my rental unit in Lincoln Park, they always found great tenants quickly, were very responsive to any incidents and were overall a joy to work with.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thank you for the review. We're happy that we were able to meet your expectations while managing your rental property.

Stephanie Athans Published on Google

Fantastic experience: This team helped me and my kids get into an amazing apt. Very helpful and understanding with all of my family's needs. Thank you. I would say if your looking to find a place. Let them know and they will find you what your looking for. Thanks again!!!

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Stephanie, we were happy to help. Let us know if you need any assistance in the future.

Hibah Ahmed Published on Google

Negative experience: Most unprofessional & unreliable realtor group i’ve ever come across. Don’t work with Anthony Holubecki. Took an ungodly amount of of calls and messages to get a hold of someone. I scheduled a showing with them and no one showed up, even after receiving a confirmation for the showing the day off. Was planning on buying a home soon and would never use realtor.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Hibah, thank you for providing these details and we regret that you had a poor experience trying to view one of our properties. Unfortunately, your attempts to contact us and schedule your initial showing were going through an automated scheduling system which did not allow you to be easily redirected to the listing broker by phone. As we receive hundreds of inquiries for each listing it is necessary to utilize these scheduling tools. We do apologize if you arrived for a showing and could not view the home. It appears that you did reach our broker at a later time and rescheduled the showing. However, the property was leased prior to you being able to view the home. We did notify you of this and offered to show you another property that we had listed in the area. As we do not sell properties we would not have been of assistance with your future purchase, but we wish you the best of luck with your rental search.

Nancy Eastman Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Yellow Key Property Management performed an exemplary service in managing our property in Illinois for ten years. Christian Carlson devoted appropriate attention to all responsiblities effectively promoting the highest degree of corporate support. He often confronted difficult issues with the renter achieving consistent accuracy. Indeed, Yellow Key Property Management is among the very best.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Nancy, thanks for the kind words. It was a pleasure working with you over all of these years.

Andy Alt Published on Google

Fantastic experience: From start to finish and everything in between, Yellow Key was the best property management company I’ve ever worked with. Christian was incredibly responsive and reasonable. Our place was clean when we moved in, and any issue we raised was dealt with quickly and fairly. Highly recommend Yellow Key to anyone looking for a home, apartment, or other rental arrangement.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Andy, we're happy that you had a great experience with the property. Contact us if we can ever be of assistance in the future.

Lois Ephraim Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Yellow Key did an excellent job of managing my property which was a mixed use building with five tenants. Christian helped with all details from screening applicants, managing rental payments, paying bills, reconciling expenses. The portal made it very easy for me to see what was happening with all the financial details relating to my property. He was responsive through email, phone and text and responded in a timely manner to ensure that tenants needs were met -- and I had peace of mind. After several years of trying to manage the headaches myself, I found peace of mind with Yellow Key. I just wish I had hired them sooner!!

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Lois, we appreciate the review and thank you for your business. The property was a challenge, but we enjoyed working with you to get the job done.

Julie Wojtas Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Yellow Key Property is a very reliable, honest management company. If you are looking for a property management company that you can rely on, and won’t charge you an arm and a leg, this one is for you. Christian is very helpful and always went above normal duties to help me.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thank you Julie. Pleasure working with you.

Kevin Ackermann Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Ive used Yellow Key to manage my out of town townhome for a number of years. Always responsive to my and my tenants’ needs.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Always a pleasure to work with good tenants and responsible owner clients. Thank you for your business.

Cori Olayos Published on Google

Fantastic experience: This was the first time I've rented in over 30 years. Christian was wonderful to deal with. He was responsive and helpful. An overall great guy! I highly recommend his company!

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thank you Cori. It's very important for us that both our property owners and our tenants have a great experience. We appreciate it.

Mike Conley Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I would highly recommend Yellow Key to manage your properties, they are very professional, have supplied quality tenants and service managing my rental property. After renting for 11 years we've decided to sell the property and have been grateful to have great management company assist us during this time. Mike and Tina Conley Richton Park, Illinois

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thank you, Mike and Tina, for your kind words! It has been a pleasure managing your property and assisting with finding quality tenants. We’re grateful for the opportunity to support you through this process.

A Ashaye Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Yellow key Property managed my rental property for many years. They were always responsive, professional and organized. I highly recommend their services.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

We appreciate the trust you've placed in Yellow Key Property Management over the years. It's been a pleasure providing responsive, professional, and organized services for your rental property. We truly value your recommendation and are here for any future needs.

David Christopher Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Working with Yellow Key Property was a pleasure and the staff there was very professional. The staff went out of their way to help me during the last year. I would recommend tis company to anyone.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thank you for your thoughtful review! We're glad to hear that working with Yellow Key Property Management was a positive experience for you. Our team is dedicated to providing professional service and support, and we're happy we could assist you.

Midwestbones Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Yellow Key was professional, reasonable and honest. We had a very difficult landlord who undermined his property management. Christian and his team handled it like true professionals at every turn. I look forward to working with him in future and would recommend Yellow Key to any Property Owner needing a 5 star management team behind them.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

We're grateful for the opportunity to work with you and are pleased to hear that Christian and our team were able to handle the challenges professionally. We’re committed to providing 5-star service for all property owners. Your trust and recommendation mean a lot to us, and we look forward to continuing to work with you in the future.

Sandra Davis Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Yellow Key Property Management has been great to work with. The contractors used are also professional and easy to work with. They also do a great job of vetting tenants.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

We're glad to hear that your experience with Yellow Key Property Management has been a great one. We take pride in working with professional contractors and ensuring that we vet tenants thoroughly to provide the best service possible.

Heather Wieworka Published on Google

Fantastic experience: My experience with Yellow Key was Excellent. Ben and Christian have been professional and very responsive throughout my tenancy . I’ve dealt with many property management companies over the years Yellow Key is by far the Best !!! Their streamlined online portal provides up to the minute communications, any requests or issues I’ve had with the property were addressed within 24 hrs . That’s unheard of in property management. If you are looking for a new rental property Yellow Key is hands down the company to use. Heather W

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

We're pleased to hear that your experience with Yellow Key Property Management has been excellent. Ben, Christian, and the entire team are committed to providing responsive, professional service, and we're glad to know that our online portal and quick resolution times have made a difference.

Halee Stover Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I have had great experiences with this company. This company is very professional and timely. Communication between the tenants and staff is impressive.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

We're glad to hear that your experiences with Yellow Key Property Management have been great. We take pride in our professionalism and timely service, and we're happy that our communication with both tenants and property owners has made a positive impact.

Ralph Keipert Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Great partner for any real estate investor with rentals in the western suburbs of Chicago. Very reliable and solid knowledge of the market!

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

We're pleased to hear that Yellow Key Property Management has been a reliable partner for your real estate investments in the western suburbs of Chicago. Our team is committed to providing solid market knowledge and dependable service, and we appreciate your trust.

Logan Tomasik Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Very timely response time when our appliance broke down. Christian stayed in communication from initial email until resolution. Thanks!!!!!!!

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thank you for your wonderful feedback! We're glad to hear that Christian was able to keep you informed throughout the process and that your appliance issue was resolved promptly.

Josh Mulder Published on Google

Fantastic experience: It has honestly been the best experience for me and my family ever. Very professional, upfront and honest. Does all maintenance in a timely fashion. Was very flexible and reliable throughout the entire time we rented.(4 years). Works with you on every aspect of the renting process including your deposit. Would recommend to anyone looking to rent a home, plenty of option to choose from and at the very least you know your getting an honest company that cares.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thank you for your kind words! We’re so glad to hear that your experience with Yellow Key Property Management has been exceptional over the past four years. Our team strives to be professional, transparent, and responsive, and we're happy that we could meet your needs.

Distinct Flooring Published on Google

Fantastic experience: We have had a great working relationship for over 10 years and they always work hard for their clients and have been great to work with as a vendor. I don't have a client that pays any quicker! This is a credit to their great business sense.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thank you for your continued trust and positive feedback!

Anna D Published on Google

Fantastic experience: We had a great experience with STML in management of our rental property. Communication is always detailed and timely. Any issues with tenants are always resolved. They are very professional and I highly recommend the company.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thank you for your wonderful review!

Tim Dowt Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Christian and his team are an excellent management team. They are attentive to issues when the come up and have gone above and beyond to help me with managing my properties.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thank you for your kind words! We’re glad to hear that Christian and the team have been attentive and helpful in managing your properties. Going above and beyond is what we strive for, and we appreciate your trust and support.

Andrew S Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I have known the team at STML for quite some time now, and we've always worked very well together. If there's a referral that I can't handle for some reason, I've connected that property owner to the guys at STML. They make the transition very easy for the owners, and the overall experience for tenants and owners have been great across the board. They're excellent to work with!

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thank you for your kind words!

Vito DiPerte Published on Google

Fantastic experience: STML has managed my rental property for the past 10 years, they do an excellent job & are very responsive. I highly recommend their services.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thank you for your kind review!

Malvin Tang Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Very easy to work with and kept me informed throughout the process.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thank you so much!

Daryl McClendon Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I have used STML Realty to manage my properties in Naperville for many years and have always found them to be professional, communicative and responsive to all my needs. I highly recommend them for property management. Daryl McClendon

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

Thank you for your wonderful review! Our team is committed to providing professional, communicative, and responsive service, and we’re thrilled to have met your needs.

Mike Wiederholt Published on Google

Fantastic experience: As a property owner, Ben and Christian have always gone the extra mile to handle everything about my rental properties, from finding new tenants, maintenance issues, dealing with associations, etc. They are prompt and do a great job keeping me in the know. Also, their tenants are usually longer-term and higher quality than I would find on my own. I've been working with STML for almost 10 years now and have no regrets.

Yellow Key Property Management
Yellow Key Property Management

We’re glad to hear that our efforts to handle all aspects of your rental properties have made a positive impact, from finding quality tenants to managing maintenance and associations. We appreciate your support!

Leave your opinion about Yellow Key Property Management:

1 = Poor
5 = Excellent

Reviews are checked before they are published. We do not publish reviews containing insults, accusations of criminal conduct or references to specific individuals. We also do not verify that the author was a customer.

Yellow Key Property Management appears in the following listings:

Other real estate agencies you might be interested in

5 (70)
Maranda Real Estate Group | Christie's International Real Estate
Maranda Real Estate Group | Christie's International Real Estate

Maranda Real Estate Group | Christie's International Real Estate

View address and contact details
130 W Park Ave - 60126, Elmhurst
+1630-699-2211
5 (71)
Mary Beth Ryan - LW Reedy Real Estate
Mary Beth Ryan - LW Reedy Real Estate

Mary Beth Ryan - LW Reedy Real Estate

View address and contact details
101 N York St - 60126, Elmhurst
+1630-675-7835
5 (69)
Mauricio Lopez & Marlene Lopez Real Estate Brokers - West Suburbs and Chicago - Brokered by eXp Realty
Mauricio Lopez & Marlene Lopez Real Estate Brokers - West Suburbs and Chicago - Brokered by eXp Realty

Mauricio Lopez & Marlene Lopez Real Estate Brokers - West Suburbs and Chicago - Brokered by eXp Realty

View address and contact details
1025 West Wise Road #200 - 60193, Schaumburg
+1708-512-4729
5 (72)
Rishawn Boone, Realtor
Rishawn Boone, Realtor

Rishawn Boone, Realtor

View address and contact details
1 Mid America Plaza 3; #1803 - 60181, Lombard
+1630-723-4163
5 (61)
The Haque Group Oak Brook Coldwell Bankers
The Haque Group Oak Brook Coldwell Bankers

The Haque Group Oak Brook Coldwell Bankers

View address and contact details
1 Parkview Dr Suite 100 - 60181, Lombard
+1630-518-0806
4.6 (62)
Oak Brook Real Estate Broker - LINA SHAH
Oak Brook Real Estate Broker - LINA SHAH

Oak Brook Real Estate Broker - LINA SHAH

View address and contact details
1 Parkview Dr Suite 100 - 60523, Lombard
+1312-593-4818
5 (67)
Quaid & Rooney - Keller Williams Premiere Properties
Quaid & Rooney - Keller Williams Premiere Properties

Quaid & Rooney - Keller Williams Premiere Properties

View address and contact details
580 Duane St - 60137, Glen Ellyn
+1630-790-5904
5 (63)
The Bulava Group | Chicago Suburbs Realtor | Keller Williams Premiere Properties
The Bulava Group | Chicago Suburbs Realtor | Keller Williams Premiere Properties

The Bulava Group | Chicago Suburbs Realtor | Keller Williams Premiere Properties

View address and contact details
580 Duane St - 60137, Glen Ellyn
+1630-529-0022
5 (62)
Neil Verhagen, Baird & Warner- The Commercial Group
Neil Verhagen, Baird & Warner- The Commercial Group

Neil Verhagen, Baird & Warner- The Commercial Group

View address and contact details
543 Pennsylvania Ave - 60137, Glen Ellyn
+1630-668-8343
4.9 (68)
Compass | Mike Wolson | Realtor

Compass | Mike Wolson | Realtor

View address and contact details
490 Pennsylvania Ave - 60137, Glen Ellyn
+1312-388-8840
5 (63)
Dawn Butkunas, Realtor
Dawn Butkunas, Realtor

Dawn Butkunas, Realtor

View address and contact details
1860 S Mannheim Rd - 60154, Westchester
+1708-275-2938
5 (62)
Annamarie Moise
Annamarie Moise

Annamarie Moise

View address and contact details
45 S Park Blvd #300 - 60137, Glen Ellyn
+1630-205-3596

Add your real estate agency to our directory for free

If you manage a real estate agency and want to appear in our guide, send us your company information and you can appear completely free of charge.

Add your real estate agency for free

The largest real estate directory in United States

Find the best real estate agencies near you