Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

402 Rehoboth Ave, 19971, Rehoboth Beach

Joe Maggio Group, now partnered with Dave McCarthy & Associates, proudly serves Sussex County and the Delaware coast. With years of experience, Joe Maggio is a trusted real estate agent specializing in Rehoboth Beach and nearby coastal communities — and now, recently licensed to serve buyers and sellers in South Florida, focusing on Fort Lauderdale and Miami.
Whether you’re looking to buy or sell a single-family home, luxury condo, townhouse, or new build, we offer clear guidance, market expertise, and personal service. Our listings include homes in Rehoboth Beach, Lewes, Bethany Beach, Dewey Beach, Fenwick Island, Millsboro, Milton, Dagsboro, Milford, and beyond. Contact Joe today to discuss your property investment requirements.

Opening hours

  • sunday: 10h-15h
  • monday: 9h-17h
  • tuesday: 9h-17h
  • wednesday: 9h-17h
  • thursday: 9h-17h
  • friday: 9h-17h
  • saturday: 9h-17h

Photos of Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates: Reviews

4/5 (67 Reviews)

Reviews are the opinions of their authors. We do not verify that the author was a customer.

Les McCarty Published on Google 1 month ago

Fantastic experience: Looking for a beach accessible condo in Rehobeth. Personal and professional Joe took the time to listen and understand what we were looking for and where we wanted to be. He worked closely with us as a liaison with the listing agent and the seller. He has an impressive list of professionals that help with every aspect of the buying process

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

Thank you so much, Les, for your wonderful review! I'm thrilled to hear that you had such a positive experience finding your beach accessible condo in Rehoboth. It was truly my pleasure to listen and work closely with you to ensure we found a place that met all your needs. Having a seamless process is important, and I’m glad that my network of professionals could assist in making your buying experience smooth and enjoyable. If you ever have any more questions or need further assistance, don't hesitate to reach out. Enjoy your new home by the beach!

Nicole Zollo Published on Google 1 month ago

Negative experience: ⭐☆☆☆☆ This was, without question, the worst vacation rental we’ve ever stayed in. From the moment we pulled into the driveway, it was obvious the property had been neglected for years. The exterior was run-down, paint was peeling, landscaping was overgrown, and the entire place looked like it was literally falling apart. Unfortunately, the inside was even worse. The house was filthy. There was dust on every surface, grime in the bathrooms, sticky floors, stained furniture, and a musty odor that hit us as soon as we walked through the door. It didn’t feel like the home had been properly cleaned in a very long time. Many of the amenities listed either didn’t work or were in terrible condition. Cabinets were loose, doors barely closed, furniture was worn out, and there were obvious signs of water damage throughout the home. Several fixtures were broken, and it felt like every room had something that needed repair. The kitchen was especially disappointing. Appliances looked old and poorly maintained, cookware was dirty, and we didn’t feel comfortable preparing meals there. The bathrooms were equally unpleasant, with mold, cracked tiles, and fixtures that looked like they were on the verge of breaking. This was supposed to be a relaxing beach getaway, but instead we spent most of our trip trying to avoid spending time inside the house. For the price charged, this property is completely unacceptable and nowhere near the condition advertised. I rarely leave negative reviews, but future guests deserve to know what they’re walking into. Until this property undergoes a complete deep cleaning and major renovation, I cannot recommend it to anyone. Save yourself the disappointment and book somewhere else.

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

Nicole I don’t do Vacation Rentals so I believe you’re mistaken.

Philip Gansert Published on Google 2 months ago

Fantastic experience: Bought a house with Joe's help in 2012. Very difficult time to get a real estate deal done. Joe was great - taking care of all the details! He has also helped my daughter with a house purchase.

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

Thank you Phil. Always here when you need me. Thanks, Joe Maggio

robin dunlap Published on Google 3 months ago

Fantastic experience: Joe was wonderful to work with. I highly recommend . Joe was very responsive and walked us through the entire process. He did an amazing job and he also was a wonderful person. I highly recommend!

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

It was my pleasure and I’m thrilled to have you both as neighbors.

Ed Gonzalez Published on Google 3 months ago

Fantastic experience: Dream Home Found. Joe is an excellent Realtor. Personal, professional, and takes the time to find out what a buyer is looking for. We found our dream home in our first day of searching. Thank you so much, Joe!

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

So happy that we were able to do that and I am so glad to be able to welcome you guys to the beach. I know you’re gonna love it here.lewes. It’s a magical place.

Sharon Lemaire Published on Google 5 months ago

Fantastic experience: Joe Maggio is amazing. There was an offer and contract on the house in one day. Joe took care of everything and made this such as smooth process.

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

Thank you, Love. Always happy to help.

Lisa Roberts Published on Google 5 months ago

Fantastic experience: My husband and I have had the pleasure of working with Joe Maggio twice in recent years. He is truly the best - on both sides of the transaction. He goes above and beyond, responding to messages quickly no matter the time of day. He showed us every house in downtown Rehoboth until we found our dream house! Even after the closing, Joe was there, stopping by to check on us offering to take care of a couple small issues that came up. One less thing for us to do! Amazing! Joe should be your first call if you are looking to buy or sell a property in Rehoboth/Lewes area.

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

It is always a pleasure working with you and David. Looking forward to see what you do with that lovely home. See you soon and thank you again for that wonderful review. Enjoy your Rehoboth Beach home.

Clifton McCracken Published on Google 5 months ago

Fantastic experience: Many thanks to realtor Joseph Maggio for finding my family our forever home at The Flats at Coastal Station. Joe made our transition from a single family home to a luxury condominium a seamless process, and he was a delight to work with. I strongly urge you to contact Joe for all of your residential or commercial needs as he is thorough and scrupulous to every detail.

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

Thank you so much, Clifton, for your kind words! I'm thrilled to hear that you and your Wolfgang are enjoying your new home at The Flats at Coastal Station. It was an absolute pleasure assisting you both through the transition from your single-family home to your luxury condominium. I'm delighted to know the process felt seamless for you. If there's anything you need or any questions arise in the future, please feel free to reach out. And I’m just a few steps away for dinner or a cocktail. Wishing both of you many happy years in your new home!

colleen deturk Published on Google 6 months ago

Fantastic experience: Joe goes above and beyond to help dreams become reality. I had such a great experience working with Joe to purchase my property in Lewes. He was always available to discuss concerns and listen to my needs. He went out of his way to find a property that was perfect for me before it even went to market by utilizing his connections. He knew what I was looking for and actively searched for prospective listings. We had a few hiccups before closing, and as always, Joe was available to discuss the issues and help resolve them. I am excited to move on to the next phase and build the house of my dreams. Now that I have the property of my dreams.

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

Thank you for the incredibly kind review. Looking forward to see what you build.

Robin Published on Google 6 months ago

Fantastic experience: Excellent, knowledgeable, kind. We purchased our first home with Joe 13 yrs ago. There wasn’t even a thought to go through any one else but Joe when we decided to sell our home. Joe is extremely knowledgeable of the Rehoboth area and beyond, including being licensed in FL. During our 13 yrs of having our vacation home in Rehoboth Beach, DE, we felt free to reach out to Joe about various questions over the yrs. He was always, kind, welcoming and highly knowledgeable. You don’t just have a realtor to get you through a transaction, you have one ongoing with Joe. You quickly feel like Joe is your friend, not just your realtor. Both of our transactions were seamless! We would never use, or recommend anyone else but Joe Maggio!

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

You and Nick are always a pleasure to work with. Thank you both for this incredible review. Hope you enjoyed the vacation.

Eric Durant Published on Google 7 months ago

Fantastic experience: Stress Free Professional Agent . I've purchased a previous home, and the process was so 360 from this purchase because Joe was amazing. Joe made every aspect of purchasing this condo stress free, as if we were family. If we had questions, he quickly answered them and worked with us closely and candidly until we were content. I would recommend Joe to anyone who wants to avoid that "stressful" , nail biting real estate experience. Joe has a plethora of resources and references at his disposal to help ease one into the transition of being a new home owner. Please give Joe a call if you think you want/need a new home, and he will help you reach that goal.

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

Thank you Eric for the incredible review. I truly hope you enjoy your new home in Rehoboth Beach and I’m looking forward to being your neighbor.

Mary Cross Published on Google 9 months ago

Fantastic experience: Joe you are the best. You have a great attitude and you made me laugh so many times. It was my pleasure working with you. Bless you and keep smiling.

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

Thank you so much. I hope we keep in touch and you enjoy the Holiday Season.

Christina Ager Published on Google 10 months ago

Fantastic experience: Joe is an absolute gem to work with. He's knowledgeable in all aspects of Real Estate and has a 'tell it like it is' attitude which is appreciated. His upbeat personality is infectious! I'd be thrilled to work with Joe over and over again! Highly recommend!

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

Right back at you it’s always great to work with one of the pros in new construction field. Always happy to introduce my clients to a great builder and a diligence sales representative.

L Pl Published on Google 1 year ago

Fantastic experience: Excellent Service. We have dealt with Joe and his team for quite a few years, both as handling our unit for rent and for selling the apartment. The service provided has been never been anything but PERFECT. The dealings were always long distance and it was like we were right there all the time. Strongly recommend The Maggio team!!

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

Thank you so much for your kind review! It has truly been a pleasure working with you over the years, both with renting out your unit and eventually selling your apartment. I'm thrilled to hear that our team could make the process feel seamless, even from a distance. Your recommendation means a lot to us, and we'll continue striving to provide the perfect service you described. If you ever need assistance in the future, we're just a call away!

Elizabeth Nhu Published on Google 1 year ago

Fantastic experience: "We highly admire Joe Maggio's exceptional work and sales expertise in real estate." Elizabeth & David

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

Looking forward to working for you and David and selling your beautiful home. Thank you.

Gina Verhalen Published on Google 1 year ago

Fantastic experience: Joe is the best! Our transaction was easy and flawless because of him. We highly recommend him!!

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

Thanks so much for taking the time to leave this review. So happy to have you both join our beach community.

Anthony Tuskweth Published on Google 1 year ago

Fantastic experience: Joe and his team went above and beyond to make the sale of my home and incredible experience. I just wish I had another house to sell…..

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

Thanks so much for the kind words. Please reach out if I can help with anything in the future.

Kim VanBuskirk Published on Google 1 year ago

Fantastic experience: Very impressed with Joe’s professionalism and customer service. . Joe’s expertise and knowledge of our area of interest was evident from our first phone call. He promptly answered calls, texts and emails keeping us informed from the time of purchase through settlement which was flawless. Joe’s insight was extremely valuable to us and we would not hesitate to recommend his services to our family and friends.

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

Thank you so much, Kim! I'm thrilled to hear that you were impressed with the professionalism and customer service I provided. It's fantastic to know that my expertise and familiarity with your area of interest made such a positive impact on your experience. Keeping communication open and prompt was a priority for me, and it's gratifying to hear that it helped make the process seamless for you. Your kind recommendation to family and friends means the world to me, and I'm truly grateful for your trust and support! And the pups are adorable.

Lindsay Coyle Published on Google 1 year ago

Fantastic experience: 10 Star Realtor!!!! Joe Maggio exceeded our expectations and made home buying a happy experience! His funny, knowledgeable personality the first time we met, we knew we struck gold! He listened to everything we wanted and could afford and found us our forever home in the perfect location! Five stars will never be good enough to rate Joe. He is a solid 10 and we will recommend him to everyone!!!!

Victor Devlin Published on Google 2 years ago

Fantastic experience: Great Experience. Joe did a great job for us. We lived in another state and he did virtual tours of different homes. He understood what we were looking for and helped us find a great home. Highly recommend!

David Irwin Published on Google 2 years ago

Fantastic experience: Joe is awesome! Extremely knowledgeable about the market he serves. He kept us informed and up to date throughout the purchase. Always picked up the phone whenever we called. And he continues to be a resource for us as we settle into our new home … Highly recommend.

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

So happy to help you and Lisa find a place at the beach. Thank you for the review.

Jack and Todd Published on Google 2 years ago

Fantastic experience: We highly recommend Joe Maggio and his team for all of your Real Estate needs! From our initial consultation through both settlements, Joe went above and beyond handling every detail to make the transition as seamless as possible. He offered honest communication, clear foresight, and effective leadership throughout the entire process. Joe was open to very particular opportunities and quickly developed strategies to meet our needs. Most importantly, he was dependable for every question, concern or need. Anytime we felt anxious or stressed, he was a call or text away to put our minds at ease. If you are buying or selling Real Estate in Delaware, contact Joe Maggio. He's the best!

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

Thank you both so much. I can’t wait to see what you guys do with the lake house it’s gonna be absolutely gorgeous.

Bart Murphy Published on Google 3 years ago

Fantastic experience: Having purchasing many homes this was our best experience. Joe Maggio and team were a joy to work with, We highly recommend, Joe Maggio

Tracy Halstead Published on Google 4 years ago

Fantastic experience: Great service!

Sophia Kimball Published on Google 5 years ago

Fantastic experience: Joe Sterner is a rock star realtor! Such a delight to work with, keeps client's wants and needs first, and works quickly and efficiently to get them into their dream home!

Frank Boston Published on Google 5 years ago

Fantastic experience: Joe Maggio was the real estate agent for our recent purchase of property on the North Shore‘s in Rehoboth Beach. He is excellent! Joe’s experience, knowledge of the real estate landscape, and practical advice is priceless! Joe knows everyone in Rehoboth beach; this proved to be a valuable asset as he navigated us through logistical issues. Moreover, Joe made looking for a beach home a very fun and enjoyable experience for us. We had a lot of fun working with him… So much so, Joe is now a close family friend. My wife and daughters (ages 21 and 26) love him. Please note that Joe follows through even after the closing. He is still working with my family to secure certain repairs to our newly acquired home. Joe will find you exactly what you’re looking for at the price you want. Simply stated, Joe is the quintessential real estate agent for the beach! Thanks, Frank Boston

jolene caselli Published on Google 5 years ago

Negative experience: What a nightmare this vacation rental was that Mary Lue from Joe Maggio ( Rehoboth Beach) rented us. The address is 50 Maryland Ave Rehoboth. Don’t be fooled when they say it is a charming house. It is NOT a beach house! The inside looks like the house on the Conjuring. Not quaint but more terrifying. It is VERY old, dark and smelly. The entire inside is dark wood & paneling (even the ceilings are dark wood). It is decorated with antique lamps and the rug is stained and damp with mildew. If you have any allergies you will NOT be able to stay in this house. We had to wear masks while we were in there as my kids, husband and I could not breath in the moldy smell. We did not use the kitchen b/c there was no way we could even stay to eat in the house the smell was so bad. We also drove around the city until we were too tired to drive so that we did not have to be in the house. I called the Mary Lue and told her that we cannot stay the last two days due to the health effects that my family was having ( headaches, chest and nasal congestion) we asked if she could refund us at least the last day we were supposed to stay but she refused she even hung up on my husband. She sent over a dehumidifier to take out the mold and mildew smell. I DO NOT recommend this rental and would absolutely see the rentals the company offers before you rent it. BTW- this rental is $681a night!!!!! Ugh

Sarah Kirk Published on Google 5 years ago

Negative experience: We had so many problems with this rental and the mean owner of the house. Firstly, we paid $589 for a cleaning fee (you would expect to come to a clean house, right?) but upon arrival the house was an absolute disgusting disaster. Dirt and sand everywhere, dead cockroaches just lying on the bathroom floors, cobwebs and spiders in EVERY SINGLE corner of the house. We paid for clean linens but they were dirty and stained. We spent the entire first day purchasing OUR OWN cleaning products and cleaning the house extensively. We couldn’t sit on the couches because we all got bug bites from being on them! It was atrocious. Halfway through our stay an older gentleman knocked on the door and asked to come in, saying he was the owner, although we never received a phone call or any correspondence telling us he was coming. Upon telling him we did not want him coming in because we were all women and extremely uncomfortable, he got angry at us and said he needed to inspect a problem at the house but wouldn’t tell us what the problem was because he thought we would get upset about it! He angrily stormed off. After that encounter we saw him standing outside of the house every single day but not approaching us. It was very bizarre and made us extremely uncomfortable. Do not use this realty company.

Kathleen Stevenson Published on Google 5 years ago

Negative experience: I sent a message to the host of a property asking about availability of a specific date. I had a response of “Yes, it is available and we will be glad to take your reservation.” So, I’m good faith, I proceeded through VRBO to reserve. My purchase, including insurance, was charged to my credit card. Shortly after, I receive an email from this realtor that the property was not available. When I called to inquire about the issue and being refunded, I was told this was not their problem and I had to do this all through VRBO. When that call didn’t work and they told me the realtor had to had to cancel it, this real estate agency again told me it was not their problem and to deal with vrbo or my credit card company because they were not responsible. They were so Unprofessional and took no interest or effort in rectifying their error. Totally did not care that THEY were the ones who initially told me the property was available and then were so very rude about helping me. I would never attempt to deal with this realtor again and would advise all people who look at them to run! There are so many awesome people to work with and so many beautiful rentals in the area. You can do better than this agency ! This is the first time I’ve spent my time writing a bad review- I like to review only the good stuff. But the professionalism of this company is so poor that I felt the need to save others from dealing with them. My credit card company did file a claim but that was still time consuming for me; in addition to the calls I made to VRBO, the protection policy agency, and of course, Joe Maggio Realty.

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

Hello Mrs. Stevenson, my sincere apologies for the situation. It is not often that a customer would contact our Agency and then book through a third-party for additional booking fees. Once you do book through a Travel Broker you are obligated to their rules and policies, which I am sure are clearly stated. We are near capacity every week as our guests have been eager to shake off what we have been living through. Its been a tough year in the service industry and for everyone and we ask for your patience and we will try to assist even when not booking through us. You can always book our homes directly and save at www.delaware.rentals . I do hope you enjoy the rest of the summer. Thank you, Joe Maggio

Nancy Hudes Published on Google 5 years ago

Fantastic experience: We loved working with Joe to find our dream home in Rehoboth Beach! He showed us homes that were listed as well as ones that were not on the market yet. He knows the town inside and out! He went above and beyond to walk us through the process and was still accessible after we had closed. We definitely gained a friend in the process!

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

You absolutely gained a friend. Can’t wait to have you both here in season.

bill goerlich Published on Google 5 years ago

Negative experience: On AirBnb Joe Maggio Realty (JMR) charged us $589 for their 'cleaning'. Instead, we arrived at a rental that hadn't been cleaned at all. Because we had arrived after their office hours (they closed at 5) around 8pm, and had kids to put to bed, we had to go about cleaning the place up ourselves as we couldn't wait until the next day for a cleaning crew that was already clearly unreliable. The kitchen was a disgrace, with a dirty counter top, dishwasher full of dirty dishes, cups and containers on the counter and fridge filled with old and nasty looking who-knows-what. The bunk bed in the kids room had box springs on it instead of mattresses. BOX SPRINGS. To anyone who has ever owned a box spring, there is no mistaking the feel of hard unyielding metal coils below thin fabric with no padding. Luckily, we found a couple gross looking twin size mattresses in a garage straight out of an episode of Hoarders and were able to swap them out. Thankfully, we had thought to bring our own water-proof mattress protectors. I eventually managed to get a hold of someone from JMR the next day. The lady I spoke with, while polite, was mostly unhelpful. Regarding the filthy condition of the property, she offered to send out the cleaning crew, but we declined as we already did that ourselves. When asked why we didn't call the emergency line about it, I said because an emergency is a problem that isn't solvable by me and the instructions clearly stated that number was for true emergencies. The house wasn't burning down, we found cleaning supplies, and had no desire to wait around sitting and sleeping in filth for a cleaning company that wouldn't have shown up until the next day anyway. During one of our many conversations with JMR I make it plain that we expected a full refund of the cleaning charges since we didn't receive those services. JMR lady says they will get back to us on that. Spoiler: She doesn't. From there it was radio silence from their side until I called again the day before our checkout. During that call she tells me the owner will compensate us for the cleaning and that she'd call back with more info. She doesn't and I had to call several more times after our vacation. First she says their accountant or whoever doesn't come in every day so I had to wait until he did, which was Wednesday and that she'd call back then. She didn't. I call on Thursday and she now seems to be forgetting who I am and why I keep calling. A reminder of the filth and threat of a bad review jogs her memory. And guess what, she hasn't spoken to the accountant and doesn't know the status of the refund, but don't worry, she'll call back before the end of the day! Did that happen? You guessed it. NOPE. Additionally, we also sent several messages via AirBnB to JMR about our multitude of issues and to date have received exactly zero responses. They finally call back about the refund. Oh and guess what.. the guise of friendliness is gone from the conversation. We were coldly told we're only getting $175 because "that's their cleaning fee", sorry no negotiations and the matter is closed goodbye. No discussion, no sympathy, no nothing. Customer service at its finest! This was my first experience with Joe Maggio Realty and it was a horrible one. My advice: stay away from any property managed by Joe Maggio. For Joe: I won't be on your client list as the renting wasn't explicitly in my name, it was in my girlfriend's, however via AirBnB you can find me as one of the people listed as a guest. Why did I become the point person for contact? Because my gf is a non-native English speaker and the lady we spoke with "couldn't understand her". From AirBnB help section: "A cleaning fee is a one-time fee for cleaning the space you stay in, set by the hosts" Keywords: "set by the hosts" JMR in this scenario is the host. Yes, you charged us $589 and only refunded $175. You can skip the fake 'sorry' replies unless you intend to refund the remainder of the cleaning fee.

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

Wow Bill, so sorry to hear about your experience. If you could email a reservation ID I can look it up [email protected]. There was an issue with the cleaner over the Holiday, which is being resolved. When you book through a third party like Airbnb some of the fees are combined. It could be that your Linen and Towel Rental are combined in the cleaning block.

Sergei Pustylnikov Published on Google 5 years ago

Negative experience: Terrible customer service, unfair charges. Emergency number did not respond.

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

Hello Sergei, I can not find you as a customer in our Lodging Database. Your charges should be clearly defined in your lodging agreement that everyone gets. If you booked through a third-party, i.e. Airbnb or VRBO they have their own charges and set of rules. Don't hesitate to email me directly so that I can take a better look at your reservation [email protected] . I do hope you had a great vacation.

Rena Steinzor Published on Google 5 years ago

Negative experience: I rented 120 Norfolk Street from Joe Maggio. The price was $4500/week BEFORE Memorial Day. The property was an absolute dump. The carpet reeked of cat urine to the point that we needed to burn a scented candle. The bedrooms advertised were two on the ground floor and more upstairs, but the upstairs rooms were under the eaves and difficult to stand up in. The furniture was filthy and uncomfortable. A rip-off except for the location, which was walking distance from the beach but not at all worth it at that time of year.

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

Mrs. Steinzor, I’m sorry you had this experience in one of original Rehoboth Cottage Homes. I wish you had brought this to my attention during your stay. The cleaning is provided by a co-listing Brokerage, but I would have sent our crew over to correct any missed areas. Please feel free to call me directly 302-226-3770. I hope you enjoy the rest of the Summer and try us again in the future. Joe Maggio

Rick Thomas Published on Google 5 years ago

Fantastic experience: As a newcomer to Sussex County, I appreciated the personal and professional real estate services provided by Joe Maggio and his team. They were there from the private showings to the escrow table and Joe successfully negotiated a price reduction in a seller's market. The entire transaction went smoothly and I am very happy that I picked the right guy for the job! Thanks again, Joe!

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

Rick thanks for the stellar review. So glad that you are going to make Delaware your home. Looking forward to seeing more of you over the summer. Thank you. Joe Maggio

Paul deLaski Published on Google 5 years ago

Fantastic experience: Joe was every bit the professional. He was responsive, helpful, on-time and very capable during our search for our new home. I would highly recommend him.

Viktoriia Zhur Published on Google 5 years ago

Fantastic experience: I have known Joe for almost 10 years now. He is sweet, kind person and a true friend. He is a professional and always passionate about everything he does, especially when it comes to doing business. After i contacted him about looking for a place in Rehoboth/Lewes area and told him i wasn’t able to find any year round rentals and only had a little over a month to move, within a day or two i received a phone call from one of his real estate agents, MarryLou. She was very helpful and attentive to all my requests and questions and was able to find a year round rental for me literally within days!! I love my new home now and I am thankful for people like Joe and MarryLou, who show concern and put clients and their needs first also do such a great job in a timely manner. Thank you again!!!

Jaime Aparisi Published on Google 5 years ago

Fantastic experience: We bought a beach house through Joe in December (he put up with us as clients for 2 years!) and he knows all the other realtors, got us all the info on all properties ASAP and knew exactly how quickly the properties would go and what they would go for. If you want to buy at the beach I would go with Joe! We are very satisfied and now we're hiring him to rent our place when we're not there.

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

Thank you for the kind words, Jamie, and we are pleased that you are happy with your purchase and look forward to seeing you in the future. Looking forward to many Happy Hours neighbors.

Jamie Middelton Published on Google 5 years ago

Fantastic experience: Mary Lou was a great help in renting my place out and helping me find a rental. Very friendly, good follow through and helped me find the perfect rental in a timely fashion. Thanks Joe for all crew!

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

Thank you for the review. We are thrilled you are happy with your rental and look forward to seeing you again.

Peter Pizzolongo Published on Google 5 years ago

Fantastic experience: The firm has been managing our year-round rental for several years. They did an excellent job finding the ideal tenants for us & managing the property. Having a company deal with problems that arise & solve them quickly is the best way to have a rental apartment! Thanks to Joe, Val, & Marylou.

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

Peter thanks so much for the kind words. We certainly appreciate the acknowledgment of work well done. Thank you.

Michelle Kaczor Published on Google 5 years ago

Negative experience: This review is for the Rehoboth office. They facilitated a VRBO rental of mine this summer, which was a great little condo. The realty office was another story. First of all, the phone number listed on Google sends you to the Bethany office, and while they can transfer you over, there clearly isn't much communication between them, so I was made to feel like I called the wrong place when I called them. Onto the bigger issues: the paperwork about check-in stated multiple times that we couldn't check in before 3pm, and if we arrived after 5pm we needed to give a heads-up. Since we arrived at 2:30, we grabbed lunch to kill time. At 3:45 a woman from the office called me and asked if I was coming or not, because she was leaving in 5 minutes. I panicked and rushed out of the restaurant to get there, and then it turned out she was still waiting on other folks to pick up their keys too. Very unprofessional on all accounts. 2 days prior to arrival, I emailed them asking if a second car would be an issue. No one answered. When we got to the office I asked again, and the woman blamed me for not asking sooner because it apparently WAS a problem, and according to her, a big one. When I told her I emailed 2 days prior she said, "oh I wasn't in I probably didn't see it" ok..... so then she spent 20 minutes trying to explain to us how to get to the parking authority, giving us these roundabout instructions, when she could have told us to put the police dept in our GPS and then walk to the parking authority building right behind it. She made the whole thing into a big issue when in fact all we had to do was go to the parking authority and pay $15/day for a pass. Not the cheapest, but also not something to get us upset and worried over. Overall I would never use this realty office again if I had a choice, but I would definitely visit Rehoboth again as it's a cute little beach town with some good food and nice beaches.

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

Michelle so sorry you had this experience with our Office. Between our move, merger and Covid we are all ready to put 2020 to bed. I do hope despite your checkin that you had a good vacation. I will personally look in to your stay and the occurence. Thank you, Joe Maggio

Janet Soto Published on Google 5 years ago

Fantastic experience: They're one of the Realtors I ever did business with.

Robert Jackey Published on Google 6 years ago

Fantastic experience: Joe and company provided excellent service during and after our purchase. We highly recommend Joe Maggio for your real estate needs. We have sold and purchased several homes in the past and Joe Maggio realty was number one.

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

Rob and Patty it was a pleasure to help with your move to Delaware. Thanks again and I look forward to seeing you and the family. Cheers.

Jeff Gelber Published on Google 6 years ago

Negative experience: We rented one of Joe's properties for a week. He gave us a negative review, stating that the house took longer to clean than usual, despite us leaving the home in very good condition. When we asked about the review, Joe said the cleaning service complained and he sent us a picture of a bathroom trashcan with used diapers coming out of it. We explained that we don't use that brand of diapers and sent a picture of the ones we use. He said he would look into it and get back to us. Several weeks later, after several requests for an update, he responded that the cleaning service said it was that date and that they also had to clean up a shredded gray dog bed. We sent Joe a picture of our very much intact red dog bed and explained we didn't bring a gray dog bed. Joe told us he wasn't spending any more time on this and refused to take down his review, which is clearly based on a different family's stay. His communication with us has been rude and unprofessional.

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

There is no record of you renting through this Company.

Jason Stauffer Published on Google 6 years ago

Negative experience: We rented a house at Bethany Beach through Air BandB. We picked up the key from Joe Maggio realty and found our house dirty and disgusting. Connie was absolutely unhelpful in getting the issue resolved and repeatedly hung up the phone on us. We cleaned the house ourselves but we will never again rent or buy anything with this name on it. Save yourself the hassle and bad experience and find a better company while planning your stay.

Tim Johnson Published on Google 6 years ago

Negative experience: Rudest most unprofessional place I’ve ever dealt with ever. Actually the sales rep that answered the phones threatened my wife when we called a couple times regarding issues with our rental (no air conditioning, dirty, missing pool pass). Go anywhere else!!!!!

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

Mr. Johnson this is the second year in the row you stayed with us. Please email me directly your concerns at [email protected] .
Thank you,
Joe Maggio

Erik Davis Published on Google 6 years ago

Fantastic experience: An amazingly helpful group of people. We enjoyed working with them over the years for out summer vacations, but they have been absolutely awesome during everything that was early 2020. We will only use them for as long as we vacation in DE.

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

Erik thank you so much for the support and endorsement. We have tried to keep our Lanlords and Guests aware of the Covid impact and the Governor's response on our rental booking page www.delaware.rentals

Thank you again,
Joe Maggio and our Rental team.

Mrs Wojciechowski Published on Google 6 years ago

Negative experience: Sent multiple emails requesting information. Never got response. Called-never get call backs. When I finally spoke to someone all they did was speak poorly of the other agents there. Unprofessional to say the least.

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

I find this difficult to believe. My Agents have the highest integrity and would never disparage another Realtor. You are welcome to call me directly to discuss, anytime 302-381-2268.

Coerte Voorhees Published on Google 6 years ago

Negative experience: Ron Golden represented a good friend of mine as listing agent of their home and then someone interested in their home as buyers agent. My friend who is quite savvy was poorly represented in a number of areas. Don't recommend listing your home with this guy.

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

I believe you are leaving another review for Karen, but you've never been a client of this Brokerage? I know people are disappointed when they relocate and realize they may have made a mistake. They relist and lose money, home sits, and their Realtor requests a reduction and sells the unit. It seems like my Agent did everything possible to accommodate the Seller and their schedule. Remember when a Seller and Buyer Agree to Dual Agency in Delaware some representation is limited. We wish the Seller the best in their move and I congratulate my Agent for helping her do it expeditiously. Not one offer save for my Agent. That's a job well done. Happy to discuss. 302-226-3770.

Christa Ferdig Published on Google 6 years ago

Fantastic experience: I’ve worked with Joe personally on many transactions! Always professional

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

Christa thank you so much for this review. Always here if you need me. Thanks, Joe Maggio

Karen R Published on Google 6 years ago

Negative experience: Avoid this realty! It doesn't even deserve one star, but I had to give it something. Even though the seller signed with the firm to sell a house and is paying the full commission, once a buyer was locked on, this realty only looked after the buyer's interests, including not even returning the seller's calls.

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

Hello Karen, I am sorry you've had this experience with one of my Agents. I had wished that you had given me an opportunity to intervene instead of posting these arbitrary comments? Was your house listed and sold by one of my Agents in a timely manner? Don't hesitate to contact me directly. 302-381-2268. Thank you and I wish you the best in your move. Joe Maggio, Broker/Owner.

James Ferraro Published on Google 7 years ago

Fantastic experience: I have worked with many realtors over the past 25 years. Joe Maggio is outstanding! He is very knowledgeable and honest as well as focused on providing great costumer service. I would refer any friend or family member to him!

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

James, thank you for our kind words and we appreciate working with you. We always strive to put the customer first and provide a first class customer experience.

Howard Gaul Published on Google 7 years ago

Fantastic experience: Joe Maggio Realty made buying a beach house easy. We had all the details covered and our experience was excellent! Thank you Joe!!!

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

Thank you very much Howard, it was a real pleasure to help you and Tammy, Enjoy your home. Don't forget we have a wonderful Bethany Rental department if you choose to lease your property. Contact us at 302-539-5500 or at www.delaware.rentals . Thanks again, Joe Maggio

dominic palermo Published on Google 7 years ago

Fantastic experience: Very professional and caring staff. Knowledgeable, kind, caring, and great at helping ease some of the stress involved during RE transactions. Joe, you are the best. Thanks, much appreciated. I live 90 miles from the area and it has been silky smooth thanks to Joe Maggio Realty. When Joe was busy, Robin stepped right in without missing a beat! Simply the best!

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

Dom it has been our pleasure to help you and Sonia and the kids find the perfect home in Southern Delaware. We create customers and friendships for life. Please us know if you need anything. Cheers, Joe Maggio

mickey riley Published on Google 7 years ago

Negative experience: Don’t use this company to rent out your property. They are only concerned with the renters and getting their money. We had renters from hell and they seemed to be on their side. When I reported that things came up broken and they didn’t charge anyone or fix the problem, the response I got was “Well, no one reported it!” It was their job to have the property inspected for issues like this, but they didn’t, because they don’t care. The money was already in the company’s hands, so that’s all that mattered to them. When they do decide to replace anything that’s been broken or ruined, they replace it with something that’s very cheap and no where near the value of the original item. So so disappointed in the service they provided. 1st review ———————————————————————————- EDIT; in response to the Owner. This is a real review, but the email address is different from the name used. My partner dealt with MaryLou regarding the bad tenants in our house in Lewes. It was supposed to be a 1 year lease, but they ended up having to kick them out after 3 months, because of multiple issues. We tried to get them to evict them sooner after finding out they were trying to move more people in, but they fought us on it and then other things happened We got out of our contract due to the negligence of the way she handled the situation. Regarding our property in Rehoboth, we went there a few weeks after they rented it out just to check on things. The microwave oven handle was broken off, there was a missing sliding door from the laundry area that was never reported. We live 2 1/2 hours away, so we couldn’t go right away to check things out. When we sent an email and called Marylou and Brittney about the broken and missing items, the response was “Well it was never reported to us.” The company was supposed to go and check these things out after every rental and they obviously did not. They did nothing to compensate us. We hired and paid their handy man Mike to fix the items. So $295 later...... Also the owner never entered the house and cannot speak to the fact that they replaced a thick expensive down comforter, with a cheap, thin polyester comforter, that has a Kmart label on it. They did inform us that the renters ruined the other comforter and they would replace it, but it’s no where near the value of the original set. We slept under it and it was so thin, it did not keep us warm last month. So Mr. Maggio, you can check with Brittney and Marylou or we can send you all the emails about these occurances. That’s why we ended our contract, because there were constant issues that were brought to their attention. They didn’t handle things in the most professional or caring way.

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

After a thorough investigation we can now prove this review is fraudulent and we have never rented this property to this person or rented on behalf of this person. Also, what they describe is not something we would ever do.

Nicole Fazio Published on Google 7 years ago

Negative experience: I used this company to book a trip for a destination wedding in Rehoboth Beach, DE. It was so disappointing. When we got there, the carpets were soaking wet from cleaning up after the previous guests. There were BLOODY handprints on the banister that led to the bedrooms, the apartment reeked of mildew, there was broken furniture, the locks were broken. I called the management company and when they came to the apartment they sprayed air freshener, wiped off the railing, and said they thought it was fine. I called back multiple times to complain that it smelled so bad of mildew that people could smell it on our clothes when we visited with others in town for the wedding. The staff at Joe Maggio said they’d call back, they were contacting the owner, they thought it was resolved, and a million other excuses without EVER getting back to me. When I returned the keys they said it was a holiday weekend and the owner of the property was enjoying it too so he wasn’t available! Needless to say, I am still fighting to get some kind of relief for the week from hell! They are so unprofessional and treat their customers so poorly. There were a ton of other issues with the apartment, but long story short......I’d stay far away from this place and it’s slumlords.

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

Hi Nicole, this sounds highly unusual and certainly does not reflect our company or services. All of our properties are inspected and meet meet strict standards of cleanliness and hygiene. Please call us to discuss this further.

Joe Grossnickel Published on Google 8 years ago

Negative experience: Cancelled our Bethany rental with 6 days notice. We had prepaid 60 days in advance. I would never use this realtor. Would give zero stars if it was possible.

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

Hello Mr. Grossnickel, I apologize for your experience at our Brokerage and with our Rental department. You are absolutely correct that your unit was double booked by another Brokerage, which was not reported to us. This does happen occasionally when a Landlord chooses to use multiple Brokers to rent their property. I understand we jumped through hoops finding you an alternate stay that was at a higher rate, which the Landlord was willing to absorb. As far as the unit's cleanliness and bare wires. We offered to have the cleaners go back and redo the unit and we also sent over an electrician. There are no bare wires that he could. There were several extension cords that you often find in beach homes. We know you are a repeat client and would like to earn your business again. We book over 1800 stays a season and these few disgruntled remarks are not reflective of our service. Happy to chat with you about this and find some resolution. Thank you, Joe Maggio, Broker/Owner 302-226-3770.

Irene Vrentzos Published on Google 8 years ago

Fantastic experience: Great place to work & use for real estate. Trust worthy & knowledgeable.

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

Thank you Irene, we enjoy working with you too

817847 Published on Google 8 years ago

Fantastic experience: Joe Maggio helped me locate and purchase a new property. I’m overall very satisfied with the experience, he is nice and very knowledgeable. He has a good connection with Appex Home, that provide you with custom made loans that fit your exact need at very competitive rate. Maggio Realty use an advanced IT system that allows you to do most of the paperwork required remotely from your smart phone or tablet, making it a quick and easy process. I highly recommend Maggio Realty.

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

Thanks you for lovely review. We appreciate your business and look forward to seeng you in the future.

Kate Published on Google 8 years ago

Fantastic experience: We rented a summer home in Delaware, USA and found it on their website. Joe was really helpful and took us through the ins-and-outs of rental procedures in the States. We are pleased with their services and would highly recommend Maggio Realty to others.

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

Hi Kate, many thanks for your review and we really appreciate you as a customer. We look forward to seeing you again.

MRN Klein Published on Google 9 years ago

Fantastic experience: Our agent, Lynda Massey was terrific during our recent house purchase. Lynda answered all our inquiries and requests promptly and professionally. She even took care of the listing agent's portion of the sale (he is the worst agent we have ever encountered). Lynda is a real asset for the Maggio Shields Realty office. Please contact her when you need a real estate agent. We definitely will do business with her again.

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

Thank you for your wonderful review, we appreciate your faith in our agents

Kevin Lieberman Published on Google 9 years ago

Fantastic experience: I honestly can't say enough about the service we were provided by Kim Hitchens and her team. Every little detail was taken care of and every question answered. Awesome job from top to bottom on two transactions (selling and buying) in the same week !! Also, every recommendation she gave us was excellent. We will definitely use them again and pass the word when asked.

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

Thank you so much for your kind words Kevin. We appreciate your business and look forward to serving you in the future.

Judy Setting Published on Google 10 years ago

Fantastic experience: Joe is so incredibly knowledgeable and such a pleasure to work with... I highly recommend him!

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates
Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates

Judy, thanks so much for this awesome review. Enjoy your that beautiful home in North Shores. Cheers and Happy New Year.

Jay York Published on Google 10 years ago

Fantastic experience: Joe was very helpful in finding me exactly what I wanted in a beach property. He listened and exceeded my wants and needs. I felt he gave me the same time and attention he would give someone shopping for a multi million dollar property!

Mike Moreland Published on Google 10 years ago

Fantastic experience: You will not find a more responsive real estate agent at the beach, and if you consider the fact that he is also a broker, his level of personalized attention is even more rare. To but it simply, Joe does what he says he is going to do when he says he is going to do it! You won't get that kind of service from most folks in Lower Delaware. The fact that he is a local and knows the market so well is an additional plus. This is not some part time fling for Joe, he is dedicated to his business and his customers and devotes his full time attention to your satisfaction!

Mike Davitt Published on Google 10 years ago

Fantastic experience: Maggio Shields is an excellent Real Estate agency. Maggio Shields found homes that met my unique requirements without wasting time looking at unsuitable properties. I purchased an absolute gem of a home through them. Maggio Shields went the extra mile for me being an out of state buyer to ensure the home was ready for me at settlement. I will use Maggio Shields for all my real estate needs.

Mark Slaughter Published on Google 11 years ago

Fantastic experience: How do you describe these guys who exceed your expectations every time you do a transaction with them? Refreshing, wonderful,professional,very knowledgeable,etc etc. They simply set the bar so high in their industry. I am not sure who or how it could be climbed over. You found the right company. I have done business with Joe Maggio and Bill Shields both for many years. Transparency,patience,personality,...........call em

Susan Lichtenstein Published on Google 11 years ago

Fantastic experience: I have worked with Joe Maggio on both the buying and selling end and could not have been more happy. This guy knows his stuff, the market trends and gives great advice. He makes it easy to get through the process and knows just who to send you to for anything you may need. He's your guy!

Leave your opinion about Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates:

1 = Poor
5 = Excellent

Reviews are checked before they are published. We do not publish reviews containing insults, accusations of criminal conduct or references to specific individuals. We also do not verify that the author was a customer.

Joe Maggio REALTOR - Dave McCarthy & Associates appears in the following listings:

Other real estate agencies you might be interested in

Add your real estate agency to our directory for free

If you manage a real estate agency and want to appear in our guide, send us your company information and you can appear completely free of charge.

Add your real estate agency for free

The largest real estate directory in United States

Find the best real estate agencies near you