Paul McArtor- Charlottesville Realtor

Fantastic experience: Above and beyond all expectations. Professional, proactive and very easy to work with. We trusted him to find a place when we couldn’t be there and we weren’t disappointed. Edit: Paul helped us just sell that same house that he helped us buy. When it came to sell, I wouldn’t consider anyone else. His help and guidance is priceless, we could not have done this without him. Thank you again, Paul!

Fantastic experience: I am a lender and needed Paul's help for a previous client of his. He was more than willing to get me the info requested and did so very quickly.

Fantastic experience: We can’t thank Paul McArtor enough for all his help! He made what we thought might be impossible possible. From the start, he was patient, knowledgeable, and always willing to go the extra mile to make things happen. He guided us through every step of the process and made sure we understood everything along the way. Thanks to him, we’re now in a home we truly love. We highly recommend Paul to anyone looking to buy or sell a home. He’s amazing to work with!

Fantastic experience: I couldn't recommend Paul enough. He consistently went above and beyond to help an out-of-state buyer (me). The search went considerably longer than anticipated, and he was patient and always dedicated.

Fantastic experience: I had the absolute pleasure of working with Paul McArtor to sell my home in Charlottesville, VA, and I cannot recommend him highly enough. From start to finish, Paul was exceptional—thorough, knowledgeable, and truly committed to guiding me through every step of the process. Despite a somewhat challenging market, Paul’s expertise and strategic approach made all the difference. He provided clear, honest advice, kept me informed at every stage, and went above and beyond to ensure everything went smoothly. I always felt like I had a trusted advocate in my corner. Thanks to Paul, my home sold efficiently and with minimal stress. If you’re looking for a realtor who knows the Charlottesville market inside and out and will genuinely look out for your best interests, Paul is the one to call.

Fantastic experience: Wonderful experience selling my Avinity Charlottesville home with Paul. He is exceptionally professional, knowledgeable, and experienced. He is always reachable for questions and guided me through every step of the way. Cannot recommend enough!!

Fantastic experience: Paul McArtor was referred to us by a previous client of his, as we were looking to buy a home with specific features and lived hours away from the area. He listened to our needs, paid careful attention to our checklist, and focused the search. Within a short time frame, he found the right house for us, negotiated our contract, kept our budget and interests in the forefront, and kept us informed and advised every step of the way! We are so happy with our experience with Paul as our real estate agent and property locator, he’s one we highly recommend to sellers and buyers alike!

Fantastic experience: We couldn’t have asked for a better realtor. From start to finish, Paul went above and beyond in every possible way. His professionalism, attention to detail, and tireless work ethic truly set him apart. He helped us stage and prepare our home for stunning listing photos that made a huge impact — and he made the entire process feel smooth, clear, and stress-free. More than that, he was kind, honest, and incredibly easy to work with. He treated our home like it was his own and always had our best interests at heart. It’s rare to find someone who brings both such warmth and such sharp professionalism to the table. As a veteran, Paul brings a sense of integrity and dedication that is both evident and inspiring. We are beyond grateful for everything he did for us, and we can’t recommend him highly enough. If you’re lucky enough to work with him, you’re in excellent hands.

Fantastic experience: Paul was an amazing resource in helping us locate a home and introducing us to the area. We Relocated from Connecticut and was given Paul's name as a good Real Estate Agent. We could not be happier with the recommend we got to contact Paul. We spoke with Paul regarding our needs and our target budget. Paul sent us a series of listings to review, and set up a time to walk thru our top choices. We place a deposit on one of the first homes Paul showed us. Paul help us all the way through the closing process, which we completed in a short 5 week timeframe. Paul acted very professionally the entire time, and was aggressive in helping us with negotiations of fixes turned up thru the home inspection, price reduction, and closing credits. I cannot say enough good things about Paul, and feel that anyone would be well served (as either a buyer or a seller) by Paul's knowledge.

Fantastic experience: Paul is great! We wanted someone who could stay on top of things and basically make our lives easier. We did talk to someone previously, but it felt like it was taking forever to get to the point of actually viewing homes. We reached out to Paul late on a weekday, and he immediately got the ball rolling. He’s super responsive. He doesn’t pressure you into anything, but is also a wealth of information - a great balance! Will definitely use him in the future.

Fantastic experience: Of all the good realtors in the area, notice how Paul McArtor is always helping someone in need. Just look him up on local Facebook community groups like Charlottesville Area Community Chatter. He has lots of experience, clearly very responsive and I know he works at the pace of his individual clients.

Fantastic experience: I have stated that Paul is the hardest working Realtor in the Charlottesville region because he will go anywhere in the area to find the perfect home for his clients. He is truly on your side and will save you from the knowns and unknowns of the buying or selling process. He is a true professional, responsive and incredibly knowledgeable. I recommend Paul with two enthusiastic thumbs up!

Fantastic experience: Paul is an outstanding realtor whose primary goal is to ensure that you get what you want when buying or selling a home. He will prioritize your interests and help simplify the decision-making process so that you do not feel overwhelmed. After meeting with Paul, I came away knowing that I could trust him to help me make the right long-term decision: acknowledging that buying a home is one of the most important decisions (or mistakes) you can make. The process often involves emotion and Paul will be honest with you about making a decision that may not be a good long-term decision. I am often weary of real estate agents because having bought and sold several houses in the last 20 years, I know that many agents are driven to earn the commission, not help us make the best decision. That was not the case with Paul - I had no doubt he would give me objective and unbiased advice. Paul is more of a guide, providing information based on his extensive experience and giving me options rather than pushing me towards a particular path. Being a local small business owner, I was also impressed with his knowledge of the commercial real estate market and he gave me great tips as I look for a new business location. If you want a realtor you can trust, go with Paul McArtur at Avenue Realty.

Fantastic experience: I've known Paul for some five years and have had an opportunity to interact with him personally and professionally. He is an individual of high moral standards and integrity who takes his profession seriously. A serious relationship builder who understands the value of going the extra mile. I recommend him without any hesitation.

Fantastic experience: Where do I even begin… Paul is the BEST! Being first time homebuyers, my husband and I didn’t know much about the real estate world. However, with Paul’s knowledge and expertise we were able to successfully make it through the process of not only buying, but building our first home. He helped educate us and guide us throughout a process we couldn’t have completed without him. We could always count on his honest advice, quick responses, flexible availability, and willingness to explain anything we asked… no matter what time it was or how long it took! He is so personable, kind, and extremely trustworthy. He managed to keep us calm and confident in the biggest purchase of our lives! He really went above and beyond in helping us. We are so grateful for Paul who has turned into not just our real estate agent, but a lifelong friend. We HIGHLY recommend you reach out to Paul as we have absolutely no doubt he will be the best real estate agent you could ask for. So do yourself a favor and choose Paul! Thank you Paul for making this process so fun and so easy!

Fantastic experience: Paul guided our cross-country move from Texas to Virginia with great professionalism. He has an incredible network of tools and people, and he put together an amazing team for us that made our purchase seamless. Thanks to Paul, we found our dream home in an ideal location. We couldn't recommend him more highly for anyone seeking a dedicated and knowledgeable Realtor.

Fantastic experience: My husband and I are so thankful that we had Paul as our realtor. He is so patient and really took our concerns seriously. Paul took the time to make sure that we found the perfect home and we will forever appreciate him. We will definitely work with him again in the future!

Fantastic experience: Paul was extremely helpful while my husband and I bought our first home with a VA loan. He was willing to work with us even when we were our of state. Paul is very knowledgeable about the Charlottesville area and buying/selling in general. He always informed us of best and worst case scenario and made sure we made the best decision for us. He always answered timely and made sure we had the answers we needed. I also appreciate how he made sure both of us were included in the process, not just my husband because he was "the man." I recommend Paul to anyone looking to buy a home, especially first time buyers and military/veterans.

Fantastic experience: We HIGHLY recommend working with Paul! As first time home buyers we found Paul to be extremely helpful, always very patient with us and explaining everything we would ever need to know (and more) about buying a house. He was very responsive to all of our needs and went above and beyond what we expected. He truly cared about finding us a home that we'll love. Working with him felt like having a friend find us a house, he was incredibly easy to talk to, and just a super nice guy.

Fantastic experience: Paul did an excellent job helping us sell our townhome in Charlottesville. His knowledge of the area helped us set the sell price to what the house is worth, and he made sure potential buyers would know the essentials of the house, neighborhood, and immediate area. Thanks again for all your help Paul!

Fantastic experience: We worked with paul and he help us buying our new home , he is really a good man have a lot of experience i do recommend him .

Fantastic experience: Paul helped my wife and I purchase our first home and we could not have asked for a better person to help guide us through the process. He was an incredible person to work with and we will be recommending him to all of our friends, and will 100% use him again in the future when we outgrow this home. Paul is very knowledgable, connected with so many other great resources (e.g., inspectors, HVAC repairmen, junk removal people, mold removal people, paint recommendations, etc.). You ask it, he likely has a person for it or will help you figure it out. He is very patient, makes sure you see every inch of the home and consider all things as your making your decision - and he does it in such a tasteful way that makes you feel supported and able to ask anything under the sun. We can't thank Paul enough. If you're looking for an all around great realtor, work with Paul!

Fantastic experience: Paul was excellent to work with. He knew the market well and was able to get us the best price for our house. He took care of all the details , which allowed us to focus on the move and our next destination. We highly recommend choosing Paul as your realtor.

Fantastic experience: Paul just helped us buy our first home and made what seemed an intimidating process at first go so smoothly - even with our limited budget. From explaining everything to us in detail, to answering questions we didn't even know we should ask, to stopping more than once to help my toddler get her shoes back on as we toured multiple homes... we couldn't ask for a more helpful and personable realtor. He was never pushy or impatient with us, truly seemed to care that we were happy with our purchase and has a whole team of people to recommend for every aspect of the home-buying process (all of which are just as helpful and personable as he is). Our family absolutely recommends hiring Paul McArtor as your next Charlottesville-area realtor!

Fantastic experience: Paul has been outstanding throughout the process of listing and selling our house. I highly recommend him; he is knowledgeable, kind and listens to the needs of the client. He will take care of you like family.

Fantastic experience: Paul was incredible for the whole process and helped us sell and buy a home seamlessly! Would highly recommend!!

Fantastic experience: Paul was outstanding! His knowledge of the process and the ins and outs of Charlottesville were incredibly helpful in finding and buying our house. Would recommend to anyone looking to buy or sell!

Fantastic experience: Paul is a fantastic realtor! He always went the extra mile and proactively worked in our best interests. He was always honest and kept us informed and educated regarding this ever changing market. He is so knowledgeable about the Charlottesville area, which really helped us narrow down an area that was absolutely perfect for us! We’ve had multiple realtors to date, and we can honestly say Paul is one of the best. But, most importantly, he is a great person. Not only was he our realtor, but he he now our neighbor and friend.

Fantastic experience: We’re so grateful we found Paul! First of all, we weren’t sure if we wanted to buy or build and he was very knowledgeable about the local builders and building regulations in the area. He was honest and forthright about the pros and cons of both options in the area and helped navigate us to the decision that was best for us. As we were from out of state, he was very flexible in working around our travel schedule in showing us many properties until we found just the right one. Paul had great recommendations for honest, reliable local resources for things like home inspections, handymen, and other businesses that we would need going forward. He was easy to communicate back and forth with throughout the process. We highly recommend Paul McArtor and Avenue Realty of Charlottesville, Virginia!

Fantastic experience: We were so fortunate to have found Paul when we began our home buying process. As our Realtor, he helped us find the right house in the right neighborhood for the right price. He was patient as we sifted through what we wanted or didn't want. In short, he was always on our side working to make our house purchase as simple and successful as possible. The best part about working with Paul was that he was always more focused on answering our questions, giving us good advice, answering questions before we thought of them, and kept us on our toes through the entire building process. He was not only our realtor but our therapist, project manager, home inspector, etc.. We would recommend him to anyone.

Fantastic experience: As a military family we are very familiar with the moving process and the woes and pitfalls that come along with that territory. However, this last move’s timing right at the peak of the Covid19 outbreak really put my family thru the ringer. I could go on about all we went thru to search seemingly endlessly for a new home, while staying for over two months in a hotel with 4 kids but, that would be for a different forum. The point is that during this move more than any other we needed to work with a realtor the was not only savvy and connected but one that was understanding and compassionate to our unique circumstances. Paul McArtor was that and more. He made finding my family a home one of his top priorities. We had a lot of specific criteria in a market that was very reduced and just plain unpredictable. At times the outlook on finding a house was not very hopeful. During those times he served as a sounding board and helped to uplift our spirits with personal stories of military life and moves and provided encouragement based on his knowledge of the market. Right when the outlook was very bleak for finding a home he was able to make a near impossible deal on a home, that was not even on the market, fall into place. As a realtor Paul has so many great qualities, but it was his unique combination of knowledge of the market, personal connections with the community and to past clients, and genuine concern/passion for finding a family a home that set him apart and made possible the home of our dreams.

Fantastic experience: Paul was very attentive and clear in his communication during the entire process of the sale of an undeveloped lot. He was transparent in all conversations during the process. He thoughtfully communicated what he thought was in MY best interest for the sale of the lot. He is excellent at working with clients who do not live locally and need to complete the process without ever meeting face to face.

Fantastic experience: I would highly recommend Paul as a real estate agent, without any hesitation. He is an extremely trustworthy, knowledgeable, and personable realtor. My husband and I are first time homebuyers, and Paul guided us through the process, making us feel comfortable and at ease. We truly enjoyed working with him and greatly appreciated all of his recommendations of people to work with (lenders, title companies, etc.), in the home buying process. He was super communicative; He always responded very quickly, and we felt like we could ask him anything.

Fantastic experience: I have had the pleasure to work with Paul several times as both a buyer and a seller. I highly recommend Paul to all my friends, family, and even new acquaintances that casually mention needing a realtor! He is professional, knowledgeable and trustworthy. I know that Paul always has his client's best interests at heart and does what it takes to make them happy (He's happily showed me various properties MANY times until I've made a final decision). In addition to real estate, Paul is a Veteran and a local Charlottesville business owner. Give him a call and I know you won't be disappointed.

Fantastic experience: Paul was an incredible agent, asset, and ally throughout the process of purchasing a home in the Charlottesville area. He was with us every step of the way, from when we first started considering a purchase until we found - and negotiated for - the perfect home for our family. He knew the area inside and out, and could tell us right away whether homes in specific neighborhoods tended to have the features we were looking for. It was clear that each time we had a property we were strongly considering, he had a negotiation strategy in mind, with multiple options depending on our priorities. He was very thorough, and helped us navigate a negotiation that with any other realtor could've been challenging. He was always responsive within minutes, and able to secure most showings same-day or next-day, either with him or a colleague. In an intense market like this one, that ability to get in the door and look at a house right away is a game-changer. I couldn't be happier with the support Paul provided, and strongly recommend him for real estate needs.

Fantastic experience: Paul is great at figuring out what you're really looking for, even when you struggle to articulate it yourself. He's a real professional, keeping his clients' best interests first always. Give him a call!

Fantastic experience: Paul is an excellent, knowledgeable realtor; but more importantly he is a really nice guy and will do all he can for you, and more. I highly recommend Paul as your realtor of choice.

Fantastic experience: Paul is an expert in his field. I could not be any happier with his handling of the sale of my house. Set him a task, and he achieves it! I would absolutely use him again, and recommend him to others.

Fantastic experience: Paul was an amazing realtor to work with. We gave him a pretty difficult task - helping us find a decent family home on a budget within 30 minutes of Charlottesville , (and within range of delivery pizza). Paul helped us avoid some miss-steps along the way, and he cared more about making sure we were getting a home we would be happy with in the long term rather than cashing in on a quick sale. Being new to the area we also didn't know anyone to fulfill other services, and Paul had great recommendations for everyone from the lender to the inspector. When a few surprises showed up in the inspection, Paul helped us traverse the negotiation process and ensured we got what we needed. We've got Paul to thank for helping us get a great home at a great price!

Fantastic experience: Paul McArtor is a phenomenal realtor and I will continue to recommend him for anyone buying or selling their home anywhere in the United States. Paul is very familiar with the military and government processes and can assist anyone reduce the stress involved in buying and selling their home. The selling of our home had some bumps in the road but Paul went above and beyond in notifying us of the buyers intentions and I feel like kept us very informed of all that was happening. Paul was very responsive and informative on the entire process and was able to address all of concerns in a timely manner.

Fantastic experience: Very professional and patient! Honest, personable, trustworthy! (Ignore the bad reviews, they’re not even for the correct person)

Fantastic experience: Paul was (and is) everything you could hope for in a realtor and more. He came highly recommended from a mutual friend. We were on a short time line to find a place. Paul paid careful attention to the qualities we were looking for in a house and helped us find the right one in just two days. He was outstanding in negotiations on our behalf down the homestretch as well.

Fantastic experience: Paul was fantastic to work with when my wife and I were looking to buy our first house. He walked us through each step of the process and never tired of helping to explain our options. Even more incredible was the way in which Paul made himself available to help. It seemed like he was always ready to answer questions or go and see a property and he even offered once to meet a contractor who was coming to look at our new house. His depth of knowledge and experience was evident at every turn and you can tell that his dedication to his clients is sincere. We simply cannot express enough how much we would recommend him when it comes to buying a home.

Fantastic experience: Paul was an outstanding realtor and friend to us. Thanks to his knowledge and expertise, we were able to get an outstanding deal on a new home in our desired location. We have a wonderful home that we can grow into for years to come—and we wouldn't have found it without Paul.

Fantastic experience: Paul has been a top notch realtor for myself and my family. He is patient and listens well. I appreciated his insights and felt he gave good advice. He is exceptionally available - always responsive and when he took a (much deserved) vacation, he made sure he put us in the hands of another realtor who was fabulous and I never once felt like we were forgotten or ignored. I have and would not hesitate to refer my friends and family to him.

Fantastic experience: I've known Paul for a few years and find that he truly cares about his clients. He is a top professional in my books and I can refer business to him knowing he will do his best.

Fantastic experience: I had the pleasure of working with Paul for two years. He is a dedicated realtor and puts his clients needs first. He goes above and beyond for his clients. If your looking for an honest realtor Paul McArtor is the man for the job!

Fantastic experience: Paul was there every step of the way with our new build experience. He kept the builders in line and made sure we understood what was goin on. Thanks Paul.

Fantastic experience: I thoroughly enjoy working with Paul. He knows his stuff! No nonsense. Cares about his clients.

Fantastic experience: We had a fantastic experience with Paul when he sold our home in Charlottesville. This was our first experience selling a home, and he was always patient in offering explanations and updates. With a new baby, a 3-year-old, a husband out of the country, and facing a move to a new state, I was a constant ball of stress, but Paul always managed to talk me down. We really appreciated his availability and willingness to go above and beyond to make the process as clean as possible. We'd use him again in a heartbeat if we still lived in Virginia!

Fantastic experience: I've called on Paul many times for his real estate expertise and each time, I've been blown away by his customer service.

Fantastic experience: Paul is an excellent realtor, his enthusiasm truly shined through when I interacted with him during a home purchase. He is always my first suggestion to anyone in the area looking.

Fantastic experience: Paul is the best realtor out there regardless of your situation. Before we moved to Charlottesville, we needed help finding a place to rent. We had no idea where to start looking, as neither of us were familiar with the area. Paul took the time to give us a tour of Charlottesville and we found a great place to rent and get settled into the city. When we knew we wanted to settle in Charlottesville, we Immediately called Paul and began the more than year long adventure of becoming first-time homeowners. Paul was thorough and patient with us as we navigated the crazy process, he let us ask stupid questions and gave us great answers. He helped us feel confident in the huge decision we were making, and was always quick to text or respond to a call or email when we had questions about the process. Paul is extremely familiar with the area and has a lot of really great connections for all your home-buying (or selling) needs. But I think the best thing about Paul is how easy he is to work with, approachable, trustworthy, and reliable. Never met someone with more integrity. We highly recommend working with Paul and will absolutely do so again in the future.

Fantastic experience: I have known Paul for a few years now. He is a solid and trustworthy guy. He is very knowledgeable about all things real estate. I have referred him many times and he has always delivered! He always puts his clients 1st. If you are in search of your dream home or a home for you and your family to enjoy many many years in with great school districts etc - Paul is your guy!

Fantastic experience: Best realtor we ever worked with. He helped us sell and buy a new house in 2017 - was the best. Knew exactly what we needed to do and our house sold in 3 days with his help. We found a new house quickly and he was very helpful throughout the whole process. Even after we moved he is still helping us. Will use again. Realtor for life. A++++.

Fantastic experience: Paul was great in helping us to sell our house 2 years ago- he had someone come in and stage the house and take professional photos at no charge. The house was sold before it ever went on the market because he knew of a buyer who might be interested. We were so pleased that we asked Paul to help us find our next home in Cville while we were living out of state. We would find a listing online, express an interest to Paul, and later that day he’d be sending videos from the site. He was fantastic. A great advocate for clients and makes himself available at all hours and at the drop of a hat.

Fantastic experience: Paul is trustworthy, responsive, and knowledgeable. I would work with him again and am happy to refer him to friends and family.

Fantastic experience: Paul McArtor is an outstanding realtor and now close friend. He walked through every step of the process with us, taking us to over a dozen homes and responding to countless text messages and phone calls at all hours of the day and night. We were selling a home and buying another and Paul was incredibly responsive and reassuring which we desperately needed, but was also unfailingly honest and never pretended to know something he didn’t. But he ALWAYS got us the answer. Paul ended up finding us our DREAM HOUSE that we had looked past countless times online, not seeing it’s true potential from the poor listing photos. He walked into this house and knew it was for us, and so did we. We are now settled in our family homestead and could not be happier. Paul has become a part of our family. I would recommend him to anyone, and everyone, and often do!

Fantastic experience: Paul is by far the best realtor I’ve ever worked with in both buying and selling a home. He goes above and beyond in every aspect imaginable. He just a stand-up, reliable, hard working gentleman who continues to help us with various aspects of new homeownership almost a year after we closed on our house. Would recommend him hands down to anyone!

Fantastic experience: Wonderful experience buying a new home with Paul McArtor at Montague Miller. I highly recommend working with Paul to buy or sell a home - he is a genuine, caring, and very honest realtor!

Fantastic experience: We had such a great experience with Montague Miller! They made the home buying experience seamless and quick. The best part is even after you buy the house they still help you with anything you need.