RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

144 4th Ave #3, 53913, Baraboo

With 29+ years of real estate experience, I specialize in single-family homes, condos, and land in South-Central Wisconsin. My expertise in recreational and vacation properties gives me a competitive edge.

Active in the community, I serve on local boards and volunteer at schools, sports, and events. With a 99% client satisfaction rate, many of my clients have become close friends.

Let my local knowledge, negotiation skills, and dedication work for you. Whether you’re buying or selling, I’m here to help make your real estate journey smooth and successful!

Opening hours

  • sunday: (closed)
  • monday: 9h-17h
  • tuesday: 9h-17h
  • wednesday: 9h-17h
  • thursday: 9h-17h
  • friday: 9h-17h
  • saturday: 9h-17h

Photos of RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Our comment from ImmoNetwork about RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel:

Decades of expertise in South-Central Wisconsin

With over 29 years of experience, Beth Goethel and the RE/MAX Preferred team have established themselves as a formidable force in the South-Central Wisconsin real estate market. Their specialization spans single-family homes, condominiums, land, and recreational properties, giving them a distinct competitive edge. Clients consistently praise the team's deep local knowledge, which allows them to navigate diverse neighborhoods—from Baraboo to the Lake Wisconsin area—with precision and insight. This extensive experience ensures that whether you are a first-time buyer or a seasoned investor, the agency provides the strategic guidance necessary for success.

A personalized and stress-free journey

Real estate transactions can be overwhelming, but the Goethel team is renowned for making the process smooth, transparent, and stress-free. Reviews highlight their exceptional patience, particularly with first-time homebuyers, as they educate clients on every step of the way. Agents like Amy Voigt, Breanne Trzesniak, and Cahrone are frequently commended for their ability to listen to client needs, offer honest feedback, and avoid pushy sales tactics. Their goal is not just to close a deal, but to ensure clients feel comfortable, informed, and confident in their decisions.

Unmatched responsiveness and dedication

One of the most recurring themes in client feedback is the team's incredible availability. Whether it is responding to urgent inquiries, coordinating showings, or handling complex negotiations, the agents are described as always being "on call." Many clients note that agents go above and beyond, sometimes handling paperwork or communication during evenings, weekends, or even personal time. This high level of dedication ensures that no question goes unanswered and that clients are supported from the initial search all the way to closing and beyond.

Strategic negotiation and community connections

Beyond personal service, the agency offers strong technical advantages. Beth Goethel is recognized for her sharp negotiation skills, often helping buyers secure homes in competitive markets by crafting winning offer strategies. The team also leverages an extensive network of local professionals, from contractors to lenders, providing a holistic resource for clients. Their ability to solve problems creatively and maintain strong relationships within the community adds significant value, turning a transactional process into a trusted, long-term partnership.

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel: Reviews

4.9/5 (92 Reviews)

Reviews are the opinions of their authors. We do not verify that the author was a customer.

Reviews on Google

4,9 out of 5 from 92 reviews

Jamie Bates Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Amy and her team are truly unmatched. She recently helped us purchase our first home, and we could not have asked for a better experience. We learned so much and in turn gained an immense amount of trust in her and her team. They were kind, flexible, patient, and available from beginning to end making the process as stress-free as possible. Choose Amy!!!!!

Allison Hanusa Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Our experience with Beth and Linda from the Goethel team was fantastic! They were very responsive to our questions and needs, and always willing to be available. Their experience and knowledge benefited us greatly. We highly recommend them for your house hunting needs!

BEN JARVIS Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Working with Amy Voigt on our real estate needs in Baraboo was an absolutely wonderful experience! Amy worked tirelessly on finding us the best property and assisting through all negotiations and contracts. She truly went above and beyond to help secure our location. Her communication, willingness to assist in showings, and overall knowledge of the market was extremely impressive. I'd fully recommend Amy to anyone in the area with real estate needs.

Jon Trzesniak Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Breanne does a fantastic job making the transaction simple and stress free!

Anthony Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Cahrone was the perfect fit as a first time home buyer. Patient while my tastes and criteria changed. Responsive when I had questions and as the closing date grew closer. She takes a lot of care in her work and her clients. 11/10, would recommend.

Nate Veith Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Amy V. Is the BEST! Always available to help with questions, extremely knowledgeable, very friendly and fast response. I couldn't have gotten my house if it wasn't for her timely responses and actions! THANK YOU AMY!

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Hi Nate! We agree! Thank you for sharing your experience. Wishing you all the best with your new house.

Victoria Zander Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Amy is amazing to work with. She worked hard to help us find a place and she was always ready to answer any questions we had. She walked properties, with us and helped us every step of the way. Her honesty, knowledge, positive attitude are only a few good things about her. She made sure we understood everything along the way. I would highly recommend her to anyone who is looking to buy or sell their home. She really let us look around the homes without being pushy. She is a great asset to RE/MAX. We really appreciated all she did and the effort she put into it. She is down to earth yet very professional. She always made us feel comfortable. She is great at her job! Thanks so much Amy!

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much for sharing your experience! We strive to give all our clients this and appreciate you putting your trust in us. Amy excels at what she does and goes above and beyond for her clients. Congratulations to you!

Klaren Alexander Published on Google

Fantastic experience: We were looking for a home in Baraboo, WI and contacted Beth. Beth clearly had extensive knowledge of the area, and it seemed she had been through many of the houses. We explored homes in Baraboo and the surrounding area. When we located a home that was "just perfect" we realized there would be competitive offers. Beth helped us with strategy to formulate the offer, and it turned out her advice enabled us to buy the home. Beth, and here team, communicated regularly throughout the entire process all the way through closing. I highly recommend working with Beth to secure your next home.

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Hi Klaren! Thank you so much! It was a pleasure helping you find this new home. I’m so glad we were able to put together the right strategy in a very competitive situation and agree this home is “just perfect.” Congratulations again!

nate Johnson Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Amy was a great realtor. Worked with us to find the house that worked for our needs. Would 10/10 recommend was vary responsive answered all questions and need.

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much for the great review! We’re so glad Amy was able to help you find a home that was the right fit for your needs. She takes great pride in being responsive and making sure her clients feel supported throughout the process. We truly appreciate the recommendation and wish you all the best in your new home!

Karen Trapino Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Amy made the entire process so much easier with her excellent communication, knowledge, and dedication. She was always on top of everything and did a wonderful job negotiating on our behalf. One of the biggest things we learned from working with Amy was how to better understand the process and make it as smooth and stress-free as possible. She was always willing to explain things and make sure we knew what was happening. There really isn’t much we would change. Amy worked diligently for us and truly had our best interests in mind every step of the way. We would absolutely use Amy again and would highly recommend her to our friends and family. In fact, we have already given out her card to others because we were so happy with the job she did for us. Thank you, Amy, for all your hard work and for making what can be a stressful process feel so much easier!

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you for the kind and detailed review! We are thrilled that you had an exceptional experience and Amy made the process easier. We appreciate you trusting us in the process and are so happy for you!Recommendations to family and friends is the highest compliment we can receive.

Robert Walsh Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Cahrone was great to shop homes with. She was readily available to house hunt. She followed up well during the home purchase.

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much! I’m glad you had such a great experience working with Cahrone. We really appreciate you trusting our team to help you find your new home!

Claudia Velásquez Published on Google

Fantastic experience: We had a great experience working with Breann! She was always there to answer our questions, explain things when we were confused, and help us through every step of the home-buying process. Even when things became stressful or complicated, she was patient, supportive, and always willing to help us find a solution. We truly appreciate everything she did for Victor and me to help us get to the finish line and purchase our home. We would absolutely work with Breann again and would recommend her to our friends and family. Thank you so much, Breann, for being part of such an important moment for our family! ❤️🏡

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much for sharing your experience
and congratulations again on your new home! Breann always goes the extra mile and we love being part of these special moments. Thank you again for trusting Breann and the Beth Goethel Group with such an important decision!

Kevin Drees Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Amy Voigt came to understand what I was looking for, was very communicative, helped find answers and was very flexible with her time...and we found the perfect building lot! She is a great professional!

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much! We know Amy strives to take the time to really understand what her clients are looking for and helped you find the perfect building lot. We appreciate you trusting our team!

Bailey Published on Google

Fantastic experience: We are so happy to have worked with Breann Trzesniak to purchase our first home. From the beginning we weren’t quite sure what we were looking for, but with Breann’s help, positive persistency and wide depth of knowledge we were able to find exactly what we wanted for for our family. Breann is one of the most welcoming, respectful, kind, and hard-working people that we know and anyone would be lucky to have them on their side while searching for a home. She was always available to answer our questions (no matter how big or small) via email, text or phone call. The whole process felt extremely relaxed and we will always highly recommend her services. Thank you again, Breann!

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much for the wonderful review! We're so glad Breann made your first home-buying experience such a positive one and helped you find the perfect home for your family. We’re lucky to have her on our team! ❤️

Alex Green Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Cahrone is an amazing realtor! She made the process very easy for us to follow and was able to answer all the questions we threw at her. As first time home buyers, we didn't know what to expect going in, and she made it a very stress-free experience for us.

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thanks Alex! We think Cahrone is really great too. So glad you had such a positive experience and congratulations to you again!

Sue DeRosia Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I highly recommend Beth Goethel as a realtor. I have had the privilege of working with Beth in purchasing and selling homes over the past 10 years. She is professional and dedicated to finding the home that fits your needs in each chapter of your life. Beth is extremely knowledgeable in all aspects in finding a home, finance options and the necessary steps needed in purchasing your home. Whenever there was a question or concern she immediately responded. Beth is very connected in the community and she can provide reputable companies for other services you need such as painters, cleaning service, moving companies just to name a few.

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much for your kind words and continued trust! It has been such a pleasure working with you over the years, and I’m so glad I could help you find the perfect home once again. Your confidence in me and my team truly means the world. I’m excited for you as you close on your new home, and I’ll always be here to assist you with any future real estate needs. Thank you again for allowing us to be a part of your journey! 😊🏡✨

Munzy 23 Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Amy really outdid herself finding us our perfect home for us! Can't believe the journey we've been on with her, its been a amazing ride. We definitely learned a lot along the way and she great at recent updates, things to stay away from and just the works. She's very good at communicating with you and responds very quick! I highly highly recommend working with Amy if you want to start your house journey. We couldn't ask for a better realtor than Amy Voigt. Thanks again for all of your hard work and dedication towards finding us our perfect home!!!

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much! Buying a home is quite the journey, and I’m so happy it ended with the perfect home! We truly appreciate you trusting Amy and our team along the way. ❤️

Wendy Tobias Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Amy really found us a perfect home. She found us one off market after looking for 8 months. We were wanting something right for us vs something quickly. She was very patient with us, showed us everything we wanted to look at and was very helpful in knowledge to help us through the whole process. We are very grateful she was our realtor!

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much! Eight months of searching was definitely worth the wait! I’m so glad Amy was able to find the right home for you and help you through the entire process. We’re grateful you trusted her and our team!

Sara Booth Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I first reached out to Amy as I was preparing to sell a relative's home that first needed to be updated and brought up to code. Amy met me for a walk-through of the home, did the research, and provided estimated current market value, discussed "as is" pricing, and potential market value after the improvements. That provided me some high-level guidance as I determined the budget for repairs and renovations which was greatly appreciated to avoid over-spending. Amy stayed in touch over the months while the work was being completed, and then we re-grouped in the spring looking at comparable sales and determined our asking price and date we would list the house. Amy also staged key rooms in the home since it was unoccupied and had professional pictures taken. We had multiple offers and closed on the sale within about 6 weeks of going in the market. The process was so smooth it made it as easy as possible for me.

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much for sharing your experience! I’m so glad Amy was able to be a resource from the early planning stages all the way through closing. It’s wonderful to hear that her guidance helped make the decisions - and ultimately the sale - as smooth as possible. We truly appreciate you trusting Amy and our team!

Ann Kulikowski Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Our agent Amy was very knowledgeable, proactive and an overall joy to deal with. No matter what type of home your looking for or wanting to sell, you won't go wrong having Amy from RE/MAX Preferred in your corner.

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much! Amy truly cares about her clients, and I’m so glad that came through in your experience with her. We appreciate your kind words and recommendation!

C. M Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Cahrone did fantastic! Definitely gonna buy through her again! Edit: I did buy from her again!

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much! I’m so happy to hear you had a great experience working together. It was a pleasure helping you, and I’d love to work with you again in the future! Wishing you all the best in your new home! 😊🏡

Jackie Bialek Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Breann made the whole search and purchase of my vacation home such a smooth process. She was very responsive through the whole search and purchase process and continues to be a great help as questions come up in the home.

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much! I love hearing that Breann made finding your vacation home such a great experience. And we know she’ll still there to help when questions come up - that’s exactly how it should be! Enjoy your new place!

Timothy Published on Google

Fantastic experience: My brother told me about breanne and I seen how fast breanne got him and his family into a new home so I started working with her and she did the exact same for me she has answered every question she could and if she didnt know she found out and got back to me everytime I hear someone is looking for a home I tell them I have a great realtor that can help find what they arw looking for and she can do it fast 10 out of 10 would go back to her if I am ever looking for a new home again 👍

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much! There’s no better compliment than having a client come to Breann through a family referral and then recommend her to others. I’m so glad she was able to help you find your home and make it such a great experience. We truly appreciate your trust in her! ❤️

Jordan Jones Published on Google

Negative experience: Rude

Cristhian Gutierrez Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Amy help us a lot trough the process, we have some issues with our pre approval and the process but she was patience with us and and the end we will find the correct home with the correct lender and of course the best Realtor, thanks a lot. super recommended :)

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much! I’m glad Amy was there to help you through the challenges along the way and that it all came together with the right lender and the right home! We truly appreciate your trust and recommendation. Enjoy your new home!

Betsy Lewis Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Amy Voigt with RE/MAX has been an incredible realtor and advocate through both sides of the real estate process. She first helped me purchase a home, and later supported me through selling a home. In both experiences, Amy was knowledgeable, responsive, patient, and genuinely committed to helping me make the best decisions. What stands out most is how much Amy cares. She went above and beyond to support me, answer questions, explain options, and guide me through stressful moments with professionalism and kindness. Buying and selling a home can feel overwhelming, but Amy brought steady guidance, clear communication, and reassurance every step of the way. I am so grateful for everything she has done to support me and would highly recommend Amy to anyone looking for a realtor who is experienced, dependable, and truly invested in her clients.

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much for such a thoughtful review! I love hearing how Amy was there for you through both buying and selling. She truly cares about her clients, and I’m so glad you felt that support every step of the way. We’re lucky to have her on our team and truly appreciate your trust in her!

Jessica Jacobson Published on Google

Fantastic experience: We find Amy just excellent at communications and strategies for finding us a special home and selling our property. She is well connected that helps immensely with problem solving. We would highly recommend Amy, Beth and ReMax.

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much! It was truly a pleasure helping you through both the buying and selling process. Amy and I really appreciate your trust in us, and we’re so happy we could help you find that special home! ❤️

Brian Jacobson Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Amy does a great job! She is easy to talk to and stays in touch. She has many helpful contacts and has a lot of local knowledge.

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much! She really does go the extra mile for her clients, and her local knowledge and connections are such an asset. We’re lucky to have her on our team!

Linda Balfanz Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Responsive, supportive , informative services. I definitely recommend Amy!

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you Linda!

Paige in a Book Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Amy voigt was and is such a wonderful person to work with! She felt like a guiding light and actually did not want to just get me into the first home- but rather make sure my first experience was something that I would be happy with and last! She put so much work into communication and even went above and beyond voicing things that I wouldn't have even thought of! If you want a true realtor with experience, but also can connect with you as a person she is your person!

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Hi Paige! Appreciate the nice review and so happy that you are pleased with your experience. Congratulations again on your new home!

Kayla Morey Published on Google

Fantastic experience: As first time homeowners, working with Cahrone was such a positive experience. She was very good about listening to what we were looking for, working with our schedules, and helping educate us along the way. She helped us weigh our options and was very transparent about potential issues or factors to consider with each properties. Once we did decide on a place, Cahrone went above and beyond to work with the sellers to help us address things at the property before closing. She was very easy to work with, kind and patient throughout the entire process. Her expertise was very helpful since she noted some things we hadn't thought to ask about. I found myself a much more informed homeowner by the time we decided on our new place!

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Hi Kayla! Congratulations on your new home! Thank you for your great review and glad to hear you had an excellent experience with Cahrone. This is exactly what we strive for with all our clients, to help them make informed decisions on one of their largest purchases! If we can be of any assistance in the future, please don't hesitate to reach out. Congratulations and thank you again!

Kelly Steiner Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Beth helped us through a complicated situation with the property we were selling. Her help was invaluable and our outcome was better than we expected. Highly recommend!

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thanks for the kind words Kelly. So happy to help and it couldn't have worked out better! Keep in touch!

Ryan Redline Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Amy is a wonderful lady and will do all the work for you, she took time out of her vacation to work with me through the process. Very trusting person and will give you all the details of a property and make sure it fills your needs!

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Hi Ryan! We couldn't agree more. Amy works hard for her clients and her professionalism and attention to detail shows!

Peggy Denten Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Amy Voigt is the best! We called her on a Saturday evening, with a property we were interested in purchasing. She called us back right away from her vacation in Mexico! Amy emailed us the necessary paperwork, and our offer was in by Saturday night, and we had a deal by Sunday morning! Amy always put her clients needs first! I highly recommend Amy for all your real estate needs.

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thanks Peggy! We agree that Amy always goes above and beyond for her clients! We appreciate you and your feedback.

Jim Langendorf Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Beth is a "go getter". She is prompt, ambitious, very knowledgable and easily accessible. She was quick to show us the properties we wanted to see in a competitive market. She went above and beyond to get our house listed on the market which made for a very quick and profitable sale. Highly recommend Beth Goethel as a realtor

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

This was one of my favorite stories, and how it unfolded was perfect! So happy to be a part of your journey and appreciate the kind words!

Susan Anderson Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Beth and Linda Goethel were great to work with on the sale of my house. They were calm and organized, very professional and patient with the balancing act of managing a sale.

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Long distance transactions can be tricky but we were
happy to get you on your way to your new home and handle the details here. Thanks for the kind words!

lori miller Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Beth was very helpful when we needed someone that knew the business to find our home! She is an avid volunteer in the community too so she really knows the area well.

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thanks Lori! Was so happy to help you with your move back and love having you here!

Betsy Rieke Published on Google

Fantastic experience: We’ve worked with Beth before and she has been very helpful always! She responds quickly and follows up with answers to any questions that arise. Couldn’t be happier with the selling and buying process. Her real estate experience and knowledge is very obvious and valuable to us.

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thanks so much Betsy! I know you’ll love your new home and I’m always happy to be a part of the process.

Helen Lurquin Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Excellent experience. Very professional staff. Would recommend to anyone selling or buying a home!

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you! We strive to provide the best possible service to our clients!

Al Schroeder Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Not sure what to say here. Working with Amy and her team was flawless and stress free. Sold fast without any issues. Thank you Beth Goethel Remax team.

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thanks Al for the kind words. We truly strive to make everyone's experience flawless and stress free. Honored that you chose us to help you!

Lorryn Yoss Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Amy is AMAZING!! I cannot recommend her enough. She was so kind, caring, and reassuring to us during the entire home buying and selling process. She made herself readily available to us and answered every question we had, even if we asked it more than once. She truly cares about her clients. She wants to see us succeed and find happiness in our forever home and not just settle for what is currently available. I am so grateful she was apart of our home buying & selling experience!! Choosing her to be our realtor is the best decision we could have made!!

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you Lorryn! Amy is amazing and goes above and beyond for her clients. So happy for you!

Austin Burkhalter Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Beth was awesome through the entire process of helping my fiance and I with the home buying process. She was always very responsive and so helpful with any questions. I highly recommended Beth Goethel if you’re looking to buy or sell. She’s very experienced and just a great human! Thanks Beth!

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you Austin! Super excited to help you and Ellie buy your first home! Congratulations again:-)

Jina Kramer Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Amy Voigt is very good at what she does. She's knowledgeable about the market and area. I rely on her for my real estate needs. This is my second time working with her; once to buy and this time to sell. She is my go-to person for everything real estate.

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

This makes us so happy! Amy is a great advocate and loves her clients. Hope all is well and we are always here to assist you!

Justin Corbett Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Beth is great to work with!

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you Justin!!!

Ryan Collett Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Amy is always a joy to work with!

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Hi Ryan! We agree. Thanks for the nice feedback. Wishing you all the best!

Ice Treu Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Well, I have to start with how AMAZING Amy is! Being a first time home owner was stressful looking at houses setting up viewings ect. UNTIL I met Amy, she made everything such a breeze and explained everything to me that I didn’t understand. She was open and honest about listings with me, So I knew exactly what I was getting into. I cannot think of a better Realtor to find you your for now home,fixer upper or even forever home!! I also loved how she walked me through my entire home buying process without making me feel like a paycheck or stupid. She’s super sweet! When* I’m ready to sell she is the one I’m calling!

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Wow! Your kind words truly made our day! 😊 It was such a joy helping you find your first home, and we're so glad Amy could make the process easier and less stressful for you. Buying a home—especially for the first time—can feel overwhelming, but we always want our clients to feel informed, confident, and cared for every step of the way.

It means so much to hear that you felt supported and never like "just a paycheck"—because to our Team, real estate is all about the people, not just the transaction. We can’t wait to work with you again when the time comes, whether it’s selling, upgrading, or finding that perfect forever home. Until then, enjoy making memories in your new place! 🏡

Joe Weis Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I've had the good fortune to work with Beth on several real estate transactions. She is a true professional. She is very organized, knows the market, takes time to understand your needs, and gives sound advice. She makes what can be a stressful event as pleasant as possible under the circumstances. Communication is key, and Beth and her staff did an excellent job of keeping me informed every step of the way. B.R.E.!! (Best Realtor Ever) Highly recommend!

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much for your kind words! It has truly been a pleasure working with you on multiple transactions. I’m grateful for your trust and so happy to have been part of your real estate journey. I always strive to make the process as smooth as possible, and I’m glad to hear that you felt informed and supported along the way. And wow—B.R.E.! That just made my day! 😊 Looking forward to staying in touch and am here to help with any future needs. Thanks again for the wonderful review!

Walter Hickey IV Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Beth and Cahrone were both phenomenal to work with. Their knowledge of the market and promptness in communication made the whole process smooth. Their guidance was always given with my best interest in mind. I couldn't imagine working with anyone else.

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much! It was truly a pleasure working with you. We’re so glad we could make the process smooth and stress-free. Your trust means the world to us, and we’re grateful to have been part of this journey with you. Wishing you all the best in your new home—don’t be a stranger! 😊🏡

Rebecca Olsen Published on Google

Fantastic experience: First of all Amy has the best energy and is incredibly knowledgeable. Buying my own home by myself has been a goal that I did not think I could achieve, but Amy gave me her word that she would work for me to help me find my forever home. She never let me settle for just any house. She knew the moment I had found my home and worked every day to do everything in her power to help with getting myself and my family into our home. Every time I was feeling overwhelmed or having doubts, Amy was always in my corner encouraging me. She always answered my messages right away and did not mind my "short" phone calls. This was an emotional journey and I'm not ashamed to say that Amy and myself shed many tears of joy once my offer was accepted. Amy truly cares for her clients and we may have started out as strangers but I will forever consider Amy a friend!

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much for sharing your experience! We’re truly honored to have been part of such an emotional and meaningful journey with you. Helping you find your forever home was such a rewarding process, and we’re so happy we were able to make it happen. Your trust, kind words, and friendship mean the world to us. We’re so glad we could be there for you every step of the way, and we’ll always be in your corner. Wishing you and your family many happy memories in your new home! 🏡❤️

Jody Platt Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Beth Goethel from Remax Grand is incredible to work with! I have sold 2 homes, purchased 2 homes as well as my rental property with her . I have worked with her for over 20 years from the sale of my first home to purchasing my dream lake house, in this time we have faced situations and challenges. I have seen this rock star agent make some very touchy and tricky situation seem like a piece of cake. She always has a solution. Beth has the knowledge, resources, and expertise to make your dreams come true. She goes above and beyond helping you get the best price for your new home and making suggestions on ways to maximize value of your property you have for sale. I would highly recommend Beth because she is ruthless when it comes to being your advocate and agent.

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Wow—this truly means so much to me! It has been an absolute honor to work with you over the years, from your first home to your dream lake house. We've certainly navigated some challenges together, and I’m so grateful for your trust through it all. Your kind words and support mean the world to me, and I can’t thank you enough for the recommendation. Wishing you all the best, always, and I look forward to helping with whatever comes next! 😊🏡✨

Matt Gilles Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Amy was with us for our entire home shopping journey. She took the time to understand what we were looking for and had patience with us as we sorted through our options. She was extremely responsive, often returning our texts or emails when we sent them at odd hours. We think Amy went above and beyond for us. We recommend her to anyone looking for a home.

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much for your kind words! We’re so glad we could be there with you throughout your home shopping journey. Amy truly cares about understanding her clients’ needs and making sure everything goes smoothly. We appreciate your trust and are thrilled that you had such a positive experience. Thank you for recommending Amy—we’re always here to help with anything you need! 😊🏡

Dell Gunn Published on Google

Fantastic experience: This group is down to earth honest, upfront, friendly, courteous, professional, and prompt in all aspects of their business. Never a disappointment from day one to closing and after!! Above and Beyond!!

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Hi Dell! Thank you so much for your kind words! It’s been an absolute pleasure working with you, and I’m so glad we could provide the level of service you deserve. Your trust and satisfaction mean the world to us. We’re here for you anytime, and we truly appreciate you taking the time to share your experience! 😊🏡✨

Rachel Sly Published on Google

Fantastic experience: We had a wonderful experience with Amy. We moved from out of country to buy our home in Wisconsin and Amy was there through every step, from browsing online, to (several) digital showings and when we made the trip up to view homes in-person she was always very flexible with her time, always had relevant information on hand and got us in to see so many homes so our time was well spent. She handled everything with negotiations well and continues to check up on us in the 2 months since we have owned our new home. She was always friendly courteous and professional, I cannot recommend her more. We love our new home and Amy is a big part of us getting here.

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much for sharing your experience! We’re so glad we could help make your move from out of the country as smooth as possible. Amy truly goes above and beyond for her clients, and we’re thrilled to hear how well everything went, from the digital showings to finding your perfect home. Your trust and kind words mean the world to us, and we’re so happy you love your new home. Amy will always be here for you, and we’re just a call away if you ever need anything! 😊🏡

Douglas Ableman Published on Google

Fantastic experience: After my mother passed away I was tasked with selling her home. I originally spoke with Beth a few months prior and she gave me advice on how to prepare the home prior to listing. When I was ready to list, the entire listing process took only about a half hour and then I turned over the keys. The "For Sale" sign was also in place that very same day prior to me leaving Beth's office. There were also several individuals inspecting the home the very next day. The home was sold within 2 weeks for exactly what I was asking. Beth's communication was impeccable and I couldn't ask for a better selling experience with Beth and her team.

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much for your heartfelt review. I’m truly honored that you entrusted me with such an important task during a difficult time. It means a lot that I could make the process as smooth and seamless as possible for you. I’m so happy to hear that everything went as planned, and that we were able to sell the home quickly and for the price you wanted. Your kind words about my communication and service are deeply appreciated. If you ever need anything in the future, please don’t hesitate to reach out. Wishing you all the best. 🏡❤️

Food From The USA Published on Google

Fantastic experience: We used Beth on two occasions. She helped us purchase our condo. She was very helpful and knowledgeable about the area in and around Lake Wisconsin. We also used Beth and her team to list our condo. On both occasions, Beth and her team we very helpful and accommodating.

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much for your kind words! It’s been a pleasure working with you both on the purchase and sale of your condo. We’re so glad we could provide you with the help and knowledge you needed, especially in the Lake Wisconsin area. Your trust in us means a lot, and we’re always here if you need anything in the future! 😊🏡

Roger Gonzagowski Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Beth is a friendly and kind person. she is willing to go that extra mile to help you out.

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much! That truly means a lot to me. Helping my clients is what I love most, and I’m always happy to go the extra mile. I appreciate your kind words and am so grateful to have been part of your journey. Wishing you all the best—keep in touch! 😊🏡

Myra Breest Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Beth has been the best to work with, She help me and supported me sense the start. I had a wonderful experience working with Beth. I give Beth 5 stars, and will recommend her to all my friends and family

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much! It was truly a pleasure working with you from start to finish. I’m so glad I could support you through the process, and hearing that you had a wonderful experience means the world to me. Your recommendation means everything—thank you for your trust! Wishing you all the best, and please keep in touch! 😊🏡✨

Theresa Butler Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Cahrone wonderful to work with and helpful! great job. thank you!

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much! Cahrone does a great job! It was a pleasure working with you. I’m so glad we could help, and I truly appreciate your kind words. Wishing you all the best—stay in touch! 😊

Austin Schroeder Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Cahrone was wonderful to work with and helped us find our first home. She worked with us for nearly 6 months in such a tough market and found the right home for us.

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much for your kind words! It was a pleasure working with you, and I’m so glad we were able to find the perfect home after navigating such a tough market. Your patience and trust made all the difference, and I’m thrilled we could make this dream a reality for you. Wishing you many happy memories in your new home! 😊🏡

Tina Lang Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Beth is thorough, timely, she works hard for her clients, she’s well connected with others in real estate and the building trades, and she’s a joy to work with. We have only good things to say about Beth and the people who work with and for her. Choose Beth if you want to work with the best.

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much for the kind words! It’s always a pleasure working with you, and I’m so grateful for your trust. I’m thrilled to hear you had such a positive experience, and I’m always here to help with anything you need in the future. Your recommendation means the world to me! 😊🏡✨

Ron Granberg Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Beth Goethel is consistently at the top of her game. On top of having a mastery for transaction-related tasks, she understands nuance among several southern-Wisconsin communities related to market trends and buyer behavior. What has really stood out, though, is her care for relationships within the community. She not only invests in her customers, but her vast network of contractors who respond quickly reflects on her care for her community. Outstanding work!

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much for this thoughtful review! I’m truly honored by your kind words. It’s always been my goal to provide top-notch service and be a resource not just for my clients, but for the entire community. I’m so grateful for the opportunity to work with you and for your trust in my work. I look forward to continuing to be a part of your real estate journey in the future! 😊🏡✨

Alan Anderson Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Thank you Beth for helping us buy our vacation home. Beth has also sold a house for us and helped us purchase our everyday home. I would recommend Beth and her staff in a heartbeat for any purchase or sale you are looking to do. Thanks again Beth!

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much for the wonderful review! It has been such a pleasure helping you with your vacation home, everyday home, and previous sale. I’m so glad we could make each experience smooth and successful for you. Your trust means the world to me, and I truly appreciate your recommendation. If you ever need anything in the future, I’m always here to help! 😊🏡✨

Patti Z Published on Google

Fantastic experience: We highly recommend Beth Goethel; she was a pleasure to work with, selling our property in just one day. Throughout the process, we were kept up-to-date concerning the contract, contingencies and the closing date, creating a flawless selling process. She was professional and committed from start to finish, and her advertising and photos of our property were phenomenal. We will be using Beth Goethel and her team in the future.

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much for your kind words! I’m so glad we could sell your property quickly and that the process was smooth from start to finish. It was a pleasure working with you, and I truly appreciate your trust in me and my team. I look forward to working with you again in the future! 😊🏡✨

Jerry Sprecher Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Beth was a professional through out the entire transaction. She guided me through the selling process and gave her recommendations along the way to make the closing go through with out a hitch. I would strongly recommend her and will use her in the future for all my real estate needs.

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much for your kind words! I’m so glad I could help guide you through the selling process and ensure everything went smoothly. Your trust and recommendation mean the world to me, and I look forward to working with you again in the future for all your real estate needs! 😊🏡✨

Kevin Flock Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Both Amy and Beth were each top notch from start to finish. The office staff was also so very helpfull. We never waited for paperwork or guidence on some of the details that were not typical for an everyday transaction. If there was a road block, they took the time to investigae ways to assist in getting the deal pushed through. Through all of the high end professionalism, there was simple sheer kidness as well. We have been through numerous real estate transactions in our life and would not hesitate to recommend this team to anyone. Thank you so much Amy, Beth and all of the others who made this happen.

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much for your kind and thoughtful review! It was a true pleasure working with you, and I’m so glad we could navigate everything smoothly, even through the more challenging aspects. We truly appreciate your trust and recommendation—it means the world to us. Amy, the team, and I are here for you anytime. Wishing you all the best and looking forward to working with you again in the future! 😊🏡✨

Lisa S Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Beth Goethel is Amazing! Her years of experience combined with her caring personality made our buying experience smooth and easy! We have lived in several states and she is buy far the best realtor we have ever worked with! She has lived in the Baraboo area her whole life too, so she has countless connections who admire and respect her work ethic!

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much for your amazing review! I’m truly honored by your kind words. It was such a pleasure working with you, and I’m so glad we could make your buying experience smooth and easy. Being part of this community and having the chance to help wonderful clients like you means the world to me. I truly appreciate your trust and recommendation—if you ever need anything in the future, I’m always here to help! 😊🏡✨

donald cone Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Beth has assisted us in several real estate transactions over the years. We would not go anywhere else. She and her team at Remax Grand are professional, and work to conclude the transactions in a timely fashion. We would recommend her to anyone that is looking for a realtor

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much for your continued trust and kind words! It’s been a pleasure helping you with your real estate transactions over the years, and I’m so glad we’ve been able to provide you with the professional service you deserve. Your recommendation means the world to me, and I look forward to working with you again in the future! 😊🏡✨

Bonnie Hudzinski Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I have worked with Beth over several months, attempting to find a perfect condo for me. She has had my back all the way and we finally had success! She is so easy to work with, is professional, honest, intelligent, knowledgeable in the real estate arena, helpful and readily available. I recommend her for any real estate matter!

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much for your thoughtful review! It was such a pleasure working with you, and although it took some patience, I’m so happy we were able to find the perfect condo. Your trust and kind words mean the world to me. I’m always here to help with any real estate needs in the future—thank you again for the recommendation! 😊🏡✨

Laura o'leary Published on Google

Negative experience: For selling our house she was either unethical or incompetent and I’m not sure which one is worse. Every document she completed she made errors so she would get paid more. When I called her on the errors she didn’t apologize. But I wouldn’t write a bad review for that alone. It’s because a month or so after closing she tried to shake us down for more money. When I explained how percentages work she acted like this was all new math to her. This wasn’t different math than what is used everyday in real estate. So again, either unethical or incompetent.

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you for sharing your feedback. I'm truly sorry that you felt frustrated by what happened. I want to clarify that my intention was to reduce my commission rather than pay a referral fee to your Mom, which was intended to have a greater benefit you. I regret that this misunderstanding—and an administrative error—led to confusion and dissatisfaction. Once the error was discovered, it was corrected promptly. I take full responsibility for ensuring all documents are accurate and transparent, and I’m committed to learning from this experience to improve my service. Your satisfaction is very important to me.

Travis Zick Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I've worked with Beth numerous times buying & selling properties over the years. She is knowledgeable, professional, responsive, and very helpful in navigating the real estate sales process. I highly recommend Beth to anyone looking to buy or sell.

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much for your continued trust and kind words! It’s always a pleasure working with you, and I’m so glad to hear you’ve had positive experiences buying and selling with me. Your recommendation means the world, and I’m always here if you need anything in the future! 😊🏡✨

M W D S Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Beth really knows the Baraboo and surrounding areas. She was always willing to show us a house even when it was all the way in Partyville. We hit some snags with our mortgage lender and Beth knew just how to work around it to get all of our documents signed so we could close and buy the house we wanted. She was professional and gave us honest, helpful advice. We will definitely use Beth if we need to move again.

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much for your kind words! I’m so glad I could help navigate through the challenges and ensure everything went smoothly for you. It was a pleasure showing you homes and working with you to find the perfect one. I truly appreciate your trust, and I’m always here if you need assistance with anything in the future. Wishing you many happy memories in your new home! 😊🏡✨

Sherry Henseler Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Beth and her team did a wonderful job from listing through closing on our lot.

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much for your kind words! It was a pleasure working with you from listing to closing. I’m so glad we could make the process smooth and successful. If you ever need anything in the future, don’t hesitate to reach out. Wishing you all the best in your new home too! 😊🏡✨

Lisa Johnson Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Beth Goethel helped to make our home owning dreams come true. The process was as painless as possible due to her availability to us day and night. In the end, we not only had a Real Estate agent, but we have a friend! I absolutely would not hesitate to call her for future home buying ventures, nor would I hesitate to give her number out to ANYONE looking to purchase a home. Thankyou Beth FOR EVERYTHING

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much for your incredibly kind words! It was an absolute pleasure helping make your homeownership dreams come true. I’m so happy we could make the process as smooth as possible, and I’m honored to have earned not just your trust but your friendship. I’m always here for you, and I truly appreciate your recommendation to others. Thank you for allowing me to be part of such an important journey in your life! 😊🏡✨

Heather Esker Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Beth was quick to get me in to see a house in this crazy market! We wrote up an offer the same day. She was able to explain everything very direct and clearly! Highly recommend

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much for the awesome review! I'm so glad I could help you navigate a crazy market and get you into that house quickly. It was a pleasure working with you, and I’m thrilled to hear you had a positive experience. If you ever need anything in the future, don't hesitate to reach out—I’m always here to help! 😊🏡✨

Frank Minniti Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Aside from having a pleasant personality, Beth is the epitome of professionalism. I would highly recommend her service's.

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much for the sweet words! It really means a lot to me. I’m so happy I could make your experience a positive one, and it was truly a pleasure working with you and Marion. If you ever need anything in the future, don’t hesitate to reach out—I’m always here to help! 😊🏡✨

Rebecca Paulsen Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Beth helped us sell a small lot that no one else would bother with. She was patient and persistent and found us a buyer as well as taking care of all the details remotely. Much appreciated and highly recommend!

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much for your kind words! I’m so glad I could help you sell your lot and make the process as smooth as possible. It was a pleasure working with you, and I’m thrilled we were able to find the right buyer. I truly appreciate your recommendation, and I’m always here if you need anything in the future! 😊🏡✨

Ashley Sternhagen Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Beth and her team were amazing to work with! My husband and I were buying a house for the first time and were nervous about the process, but Beth and her team at Re/MAX were so kind, patient, and genuinely helpful from starting our house search through the closing date and beyond. They were all so knowledgeable on all aspects of purchasing a home and very prompt in answering phone calls, emails, etc. If and when we decide to sell/buy another house, we will give Beth and her team a call!

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much for the wonderful review! It was an absolute pleasure working with you both, and I’m so glad we could help make your first home-buying experience a smooth and enjoyable one. I truly appreciate your trust in me and my team, and we’re always here for you whenever you're ready to buy or sell again. Wishing you many happy memories in your home and congratulations on your newest addition! 😊🏡✨

Lauren Schomer Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Hands-down, the most committed and thorough realtor you will find. Her knowledge of the market and home buying process is second to none. Beth is simply the best.

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much for the incredible review! I truly appreciate your trust and kind words. It’s an honor to work with such wonderful people like you, and I’m always here to help with any of your real estate needs. Thanks again for allowing me to be a part of your journey! 😊🏡✨

Matt K Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Beth and her team worked very hard together to give me, and buyers every opportunity to get together, negotiate and finalize the sale of my house always having my best interest in mind.

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much for your kind words! It was a pleasure working with you, and I’m so glad my team and I could help make the process as smooth as possible while keeping your best interests in mind. If you ever need anything in the future, I’m always here to help! 😊🏡✨

Diana Allaby Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Beth was geeat to work with. She was efficient, responsive, professional and thoughtful during the sale of our home. I would definitely refer her to friends and family.

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Here's an updated response based on your recent transactions:

Thank you so much for the kind words! It has been a pleasure working with you through multiple transactions, and I’m so grateful for your continued trust. I'm always here to help with any future real estate needs, and I truly appreciate the opportunity to assist you along the way. If you ever need anything, don’t hesitate to reach out! 😊🏡✨

kitty bitty Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Dedicated to her buyers and sellers to ensure that they are happy and satisfied 100%. Provides honest feedback with questions and concerns to a maintain a respectful relationship. Thanks Beth!

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much for the kind words! It truly means a lot to me that you felt supported and valued throughout the process. I’m so happy I could be there for you, and I always strive to make sure everything goes smoothly for my clients. If you ever need anything in the future, don’t hesitate to reach out! 😊🏡✨

Mark Bostwick Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Beth is the ultimate real estate professional. She is a available and has looked out for our interests in the type and location of property for us. She also sold our house and even helped us to change out some of our hardware on our kitchen cabinets! She had great ideas to help sell our house and helped us to get it done!

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel

Thank you so much for your kind words! It's been such a pleasure working with you on multiple transactions. I'm glad I could help with everything from finding the right property to offering suggestions to help get your house ready for sale, and ultimately building your dream home. Your trust and continued support mean so much to me, and I'm always here for anything you need in the future! 😊🏡✨

Leave your opinion about RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel:

1 = Poor
5 = Excellent

Reviews are checked before they are published. We do not publish reviews containing insults, accusations of criminal conduct or references to specific individuals. We also do not verify that the author was a customer.

RE/MAX Preferred: Beth Goethel appears in the following listings:

Other real estate agencies you might be interested in

4.9 (59)
Bill Hays - Selling 608 Real Estate, powered by RE/MAX Preferred
Bill Hays - Selling 608 Real Estate, powered by RE/MAX Preferred

Bill Hays - Selling 608 Real Estate, powered by RE/MAX Preferred

View address and contact details
144 4th Ave #3 - 53913, Baraboo
+1608-434-1470
5 (66)
Alina Gorsuch Real Estate
Alina Gorsuch Real Estate

Alina Gorsuch Real Estate

View address and contact details
133 Wisconsin Dells Pkwy S - 53965, Wisconsin Dells
+1608-617-6642
4.4 (73)
Sand County Service Company
Sand County Service Company

Sand County Service Company

View address and contact details
116 W Munroe Ave - 53940, Baraboo
+1608-254-6551

Add your real estate agency to our directory for free

If you manage a real estate agency and want to appear in our guide, send us your company information and you can appear completely free of charge.

Add your real estate agency for free

The largest real estate directory in United States

Find the best real estate agencies near you