BethanySells716

5462 Sheridan Dr, 14221, Depew

Bethany Botzenhart is a dedicated and highly rated real estate professional based in Depew and serving the greater Western New York area. With a background in leadership and 25 years of experience coaching for excellence in service, Bethany brings a unique level of professionalism, patience, and dedication to every transaction. Whether you are a first-time homebuyer or a seasoned investor, she ensures a seamless and confident experience.

Bethany specializes in both buying and selling properties across key neighborhoods including Amherst, Lancaster, Clarence, Williamsville, and Buffalo. Her deep local expertise allows her to provide accurate home valuations, strategic pricing advice, and effective marketing strategies that help clients achieve the best possible outcomes. Past clients consistently praise her for her exceptional communication, problem-solving skills, and ability to navigate complex challenges with ease.

Beyond traditional real estate services, Bethany offers comprehensive support through her portfolio of sold and active listings, neighborhood guides, and educational resources for buyers and sellers. She is committed to fair housing practices and stands by her clients from the first consultation to the closing table and beyond. Contact Bethany Botzenhart today to experience a personalized approach to your real estate needs.

Opening hours

  • sunday: 7h-21h
  • monday: 7h-21h
  • tuesday: 7h-21h
  • wednesday: 7h-21h
  • thursday: 7h-21h
  • friday: 7h-21h
  • saturday: 7h-21h

BethanySells716: Reviews

5/5 (63 Reviews)

Reviews are the opinions of their authors. We do not verify that the author was a customer.

Reviews on Google

5,0 out of 5 from 63 reviews

Megan Saunders Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I can't recommend my real estate agent highly enough! She made both the sale of my condo and the purchase of my new home a smooth and successful experience. She helped me sell my condo for over the asking price, and we were under contract in about a week. Her pricing strategy, marketing, and guidance throughout the process were outstanding. She was also incredibly patient while helping me search for my next home. We looked at several properties, and although my offers on a few homes weren't accepted, she kept me focused and optimistic. One of the best pieces of advice she gave me was to sell my condo before purchasing a home. Finding a buyer for my condo first made my offers much stronger and ultimately helped me secure the right home. Throughout the entire process, she was knowledgeable, responsive, honest, and always had my best interests in mind. If you're looking for an agent who truly cares about her clients and knows how to get results, I highly recommend her!

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Megan, I am thrilled for you. Thank you so much for finding me! I love working with a fellow dog lover. It was such a pleasure to partner with you and I hope you are happy for many years in your new home. Glad I could help make it a seamless process for you.
xo Bethany

Daniel Manta Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Bethany was incredible in both the sale and purchase of our properties and we could not be more thankful for her! I HIGHLY recommend her as she does so much behind the scenes to keep things running smoothly and managing the multiple parties to ensure everything is on track. Best decision for our housing endeavor!

Melissa Moran Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Bethany was an absolute pleasure to work with. She guided me through EVERYTHING and responded to any of my messages immediately. She was there for me every step of the way and genuinely cares about her clients and wants them to get all they deserve on the sale of their home. She also helped my daughter find her own apartment and made sure she wasn’t being taken advantage of. I would absolutely recommend her to anyone buying or selling a home. She’s truly the best and you won’t be disappointed!

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Thank you for the kind words Melissa and trusting me to sell the beautiful home that was custom built for your family. What a bonus to help your daughter as well. Wishing you the very best as you both settle in and start to explore your new neighborhoods. It was an absolute pleasure to work with you as well, look forward to seeing you soon!

Rocco Lucente Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I highly recommend Bethany to anyone looking for a real estate agent they can trust. Her dedication and expertise helped me find the perfect tenants for my commercial properties.

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Thank you for the compliment and trust! The tenants have enjoyed the success they have had with their businesses in your plazas. Looking forward to having you support more small businesses and partnering again.

Ariel Russell Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Bethany was amazing! She’s great with communication, very knowledgeable and was always available when needed!

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Ariel, thank you so much for trusting me to help you with the sale of your home and finding the perfect new place to start the next chapter. I know you'll be happy for years to come. Enjoy the process of making the house a home with your finishing touches. Can't wait to see what you've done!

Kimberly Sargent Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Bethany was our agent when we bought our house in 2019 and was our first call when we decided to put it on the market due to our first time working with her. Very personable and helpful. We told Weichert that we were not interested in any other agents representing us on the sale."

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

WNY said goodbye to a wonderful family when you moved! Wishing you the very best on the next adventure and I hope you'll visit Buffalo again and say hello. We were able to sell your home for top dollar because you took such great care of it over the years.Thank you for trusting me (twice), I appreciate the opportunity.

Kimberly Yao Published on Google

Fantastic experience: She was very helpful in assisting me with all my needs and with any of the questions I had!!

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Thank you so much Kim. It was a pleasure to help sell the condo. I appreciate you trusting me all the way from California with the sale. Best wishes with the next chapter!

Irene Clark Published on Google

Fantastic experience: It was a delight to work with Bethany in the sale of my sister-in-law’s house. She provided information about the prices of houses in the area, gave us advice about the house and recommendations about companies we could contact to help us with the clean out. She answered any questions we had, contacted us when we returned to our out of state home if there were any problems, called us when an offer was made. We felt that she only had the best in mind when dealing with us. I would recommend her to others.

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

I appreciate the kind words so much. I appreciate the referral from our mutual friend and really enjoyed guiding you through the process. Thank you for trusting me with her estate while you enjoyed the sunshine! It was a pleasure.

Kate Q Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Bethany is extremely kind and helpful. Excellent communication and responsiveness and delivered above what I was expecting. Thank you, Bethany!

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

I was thrilled that you received multiple offers for your home. All the work you put into getting your home ready to sell really paid off! So excited for your next adventure, thanks for taking me along.

Jackie Wright Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Bethany is a five star real estate agent. She was very professional assisting me in the purchase of my house. She went above & beyond to help me to ensure I had everything I needed to close on the house. She remained positive throughout the entire process & assured me everything would work out. I was confident in her ability & it was evident that she is an experienced & talented agent. It was a real pleasure working with her.

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Jackie, what a fun time we had finding the perfect home for you! I was thrilled to guide you on the adventure and I know you'll be happy for many years to come. Thank you for your trust and kind words.

Ivy Carey Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Bethany was the best realtor to work with. Her personalized assistance was relaxed and super helpful throughout my home searching process. She provided helpful advice and made this journey very enjoyable and stress-free. I would recommend Bethany to anyone and everyone looking for a place to call home. Thank you Bethany!!

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

What a pleasure to be a part of finding your first home Ivy! Thank you so much for trusting me to help you. I can't wait to see how you make this fabulous condo your own.

Jaime Salcedo Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I highly recommend Bethany if looking to sell, buy, or rent a property! Bethany was the rental agent for a condo that my girlfriend and I ultimately rented. She was extremely responsive, transparent, friendly, and insightful throughout the entire process and truly made the rental and moving process easy/stress free. Highly recommend and thank you again Bethany!

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Thank you Jamie! What a perfect condo for you to rent, so close to everything with gorgeous windows. So happy to be a part of it, thank you so much for your trust! ️❤️

Jessica Young Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Bethany was great, super easy to work with, answered any questions to make the process smoother.

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

What a pleasure to help you rent your gorgeous condo! I know they'll be very happy and take great care of it. Enjoy settling in to your new home! Thank you again for trusting me to help guide you.

James Pioli Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Bethany was incredibly helpful through the entire process. We were first time home sellers and she explained everything in such an understanding way that it made the whole process very easy. She stood up for us when the buyer was making unreasonable demands, and she handled several difficult conversations on our behalf. You definitely will not be disappointed in the service that you receive! Very knowledgeable very understanding very kind very helpful. We really could not have asked for anything more. Go Bills

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

So much fun to get to know your beautiful family while helping you find the new perfect home and guide you through the sale of your current residence. You're in the perfect spot to make memories, celebrate holidays and read all the bedtime stories! Thanks for your trust and your patience.
And Go Bills!

Beth B Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I made the decision to relocate to the greater Buffalo area from Massachusetts. Moving is stressful, relocating to a new state heightens that. I had met Bethany at the grand opening of a dear friend's store, and Bethany had helped her find a gorgeous space in a perfect location. When it was getting nearer to my time to move, I visited the area, and Bethany showed me three great houses. The second was perfect for me. As I returned home to secure last details for the move, Bethany attended the inspection for me, negotiated terms, and kept me abreast of the plans. Her team at Howard Hannah helped me set up utilities and find a local moving team to unload the truck. Every step along the way, Bethany was communicative and on top of things, which so greatly lightened my emotional load. So, yes, although moving can be stressful, Bethany worked to make sure I got the home of my dreams, and I knew I was being well taken care of. I wholeheartedly recommend working with her if you're thinking of moving within (or to) the Buffalo area.

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Western New York is lucky to have you in the community Beth! Thank you for the very kind words and allowing me to share in the journey and being a part of your story. I can't wait for your store to open and maybe learn a new hobby! I'll see you around town. B

Sam S Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Bethany was kind, patient, and really focused upon helping us find our dream home!

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

What an honor to help guide you and your lovely wife through the home buying process. It's a perfect home you'll enjoy for years to come. We found a great house, exactly where you wanted to be so quickly and didn't overpay. The stars were aligned for you. Wishing you all the happiness and thank you again for the trust in helping you with this very big decision. Bethany

Alexandra Brian Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Bethany was absolutely vital to our success in buying and selling our property. She was informative and kind. Bethany always advocated strongly in our best interest and led us through the buying and selling process with confidence. We would recommend Bethany to anyone! We are so grateful for all her hard work

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Alex, it was an honor to help you and your family start the next chapter in your novel! Thank you for trusting me and being such a fabulous partner to work with. I’m glad we were able to get top dollar for your sale and find a new home that checked so many boxes on the list. Congratulations

Cyndi Horrigan Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Bethany Botzenhart was an outstanding Howard Hanna agent to work with. She is a skilled listener with an in-depth knowledge of the real estate market. She was professional, patient, efficient and effective in selling my brother-in-law’s estate. She used multiple marketing methods to promote and sell the home. I would highly recommend, Bethany Botzenhart of Howard Hanna to sell your home.

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Thank you so much Cyndi! It was an honor to partner with you and Michael. It took some time to find the perfect buyer, thank you for your trust and your patience!

Tara Bazilian Chang Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I want to give a special shoutout to Bethany Botzenhart Lic. Real Estate Salesperson Bethany helped us find a house to buy AND she sold our house for us. She was always responsive and answered all of our questions with a smile. Bethany spent 2 months looking at houses with us. She was always excited about it and kept our spirits high. She has the eye of an inspector, so she gave us honest feedback. She wasn’t pushing us, in fact she would point out red flags (even if we loved a house) and had an idea about repair costs so we could make an educated decision. And when we were ready to put our house on the market, she gave us detailed instructions to get it ready. She told us what needed to be fixed and what needed to go. She sold our house in 8 days It was emotional roller coaster, to say the least - but Bethany was there every step of the way with a calming and soothing approach. Oh, and another amazing about Bethany - she knows all the best people to help you with your move. We’ve hired the movers, electricians, wood flooring guy, and painters she recommended and they were all excellent!

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Tara, I couldn’t be happier for you! I love your new home and know you will have fun making it your own. It’s the perfect location, you’ll love being able to walk everywhere, and never have to cook being surrounded by such yummy places to eat!
“Rightsizing” is tough, but sold your home at a perfect time to receive top dollar.
Onto the next adventure! Thanks so much for trusting me. ♥️

Don Manta Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Bethany is always on top of what is going on and what needs to be done.

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Thank you so much Don! I definitely try my best to stay on top of dates and communicate throughout the transaction so everyone stays informed.
I appreciate your trust, this is our 7th deal together! You're filling up a punchcard. :)

Ruth Manta Published on Google

Fantastic experience: We love Bethany as our realestate agent. She's knowledgable but not pushy, giving great advice, but still lets us make our own decision. Thank you Bethany!

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

I love you as a client Ruth! Your homes are always meticulously updated and maintained to receive top dollar for every sale. Thank you for your continued trust and partnership. Onto the next adventure!

Logan Gsellman Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Bethany is an incredibly competent, professional and enjoyable realtor to work with. She helped us with our very difficult out-of-state sale of our duplex and was our front front line resource through a preceding eviction. I will be recommending her to all of my friends and family.

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Logan, thank you so much for the kind words. It’s been a privilege to partner with you and your family over the years. Tenants can be tricky, I’m so glad I could be here to help you get to closing. Thank you for your trust.

Cassie C Published on Google

Fantastic experience: My father passed away and it was time to sell the house. I didn't know where to start. I didn't know who to ask. I don't live up there. So I was very unsure. My cousin over at miller's thumb bakery, suggested Miss Bethany. So I gave Bethany a call. She was super caring and friendly and very sweet. She assured me that she would be able to take care of everything. So I trusted her. She did she took care of everything! She helped me being so far away with the house. She stayed in constant communication with me. She did what was best for me in my situation. And if I didn't understand something she would take her time out to explain it to me. I am honestly gonna miss her as she is such a fantastic person. I highly recommend her to sell your house.

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Cassie, it was an honor to be your realtor and loved helping you from a distance. I was flattered for the referral and am so happy you were so pleased with the way you were represented. I am glad we were able to connect when you were in town and don't worry, I'll keep in touch! Thank you for the kind words.

K Gilbert Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I’ve been involved in two real estate transactions with Bethany in the last three years. Each transaction had significant challenges. Bethany handled these challenges skillfully, while maintaining her professionalism and easy-going style. In the most recent real estate transaction, Bethany went far beyond what would be expected from a real estate agent. Bethany’s Hardwork and intelligence played a major role in satisfying both parties in the transaction. There are not enough adjectives in the English language to describe how amazing Bethany Botzenhart is. I wholeheartedly. Recommend Bethany for any real estate transaction, simple, or complex that you may have..

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Very generous words Kurt. Thank you so much for your trust and your referrals. I am up for the challenge and really appreciate you sharing your experience. It's always a pleasure.

Elizabeth Freund Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Bethany is a go getter. She is professional and handles everything in such a wonderful manner. She is hard working and was diligent from start to finish with getting our home sold. She is reliable and always available for any questions or concerns. We appreciate all of her hard work throughout this entire process.

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Liz, what an honor to partner with you for the sale and build of your new home. It’s stunning and I know you’ll make so many beautiful memories there. Thank you for your trust! xo B

Marcie Brown Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Bethany is amazing! She is knowledgeable, professional, and has excellent communication skills. We had a seamless selling process thanks to her!

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Thank you so much for the kind sentiments Marcie! WNY is going to miss your family. It was such a pleasure getting to know all of you.

Brittany Ricchiazzi Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Bethany is not only a great agent, but a great person. She consistently went above and beyond during our home buying process, always communicating kindly and transparently. She does an amazing job at helping you understand everything that goes into the home buying process. With Bethany, our experience buying a home was anything but stressful. You won’t find a more down-to-earth agent focused on YOUR needs out there.

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

You and John were so much fun to look at houses with! I am so happy we found the very perfect place to call home and it has such an amazing pool to enjoy. Thanks for your trust and your kind words, I can't wait to visit.

Karina Krantz Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I had the pleasure of working with Bethany for both of my property purchases, and the experience was beyond fantastic each time! Her professionalism, knowledge, and dedication, made the process smooth and stress-free. She truly understood my needs and went above and beyond to ensure I found the perfect properties. I couldn’t recommend Bethany enough for anyone looking to buy or sell a home or business property. A five star experience all around!

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

It's been a long journey. I am so glad you've finally opened the store you always wanted to! Congratulations and cheers to Filled With Love Buffalo.
Thanks for hanging in there with me.

Marybeth Mantharam Published on Google

Fantastic experience: We could not be more happy with Bethany! She sold a condo for us in Williamsville, and was fantastic through the entire process! We highly recommend Bethany for your real estate needs!

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Thank you so much for the kind words Marybeth. I really appreciate the referral from a mutal friend. What a pleasure to get to know your family and assist with the sale! See you around the ballpark.

gregory rittling Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I can't recommend Bethany enough: she was outstanding in communication, direction and advice, professionalism and completely competent. After ~2yrs of searching and many trials, I am now in a home due mostly to her. Also as important to me when working with someone: she is honest, has personal and professional integrity, values and great sense of humor

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

What an honor that you were referred to me. I was able to see a lot of corners of WNY I don't always travel too. Thank you for your patience and trust, we did it!! And side note, I keep telling my kids I'm funny...they never believe me :)

Dawn Copperthite Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I can't say enough about Bethany! She helped me find the perfect place for my new office location. She was kind, patient, calm and always smiling. Bethany was there from the first time that I looked at the space, to the countless times that I wanted to "look at it again" and then for the closing day. She made the entire process so easy and stress free. She answered all of my questions immediately. It was an honor to work with Bethany and I will always recommend her.

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Dawn, thank you so much for choosing me to help you find an ideal commercial space to expand your business. So many amenities in this building, I know you're going to love it. Appreciate the kind words and can't wait to see the new office when it's done.
~Bethany

LJ Waterhouse Published on Google

Fantastic experience: "Selling our family home was difficult, as many beautiful memories were created here. Bethany was so encouraging and professional as she walked us through the entire sale process! She has such a beautiful personality and she’s so uplifting with her words and descriptions, making us always feel like we were her #1 seller! Thanks Bethany for being our #1 cheerleader! "

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Thank you so much for the kind words. Selling a family home filled with such love is an emotional time. Appreciate you for trusting me and letting me guide you through the process! xoxo Bethany

cayley behringer Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Bethany is fantastic! She is knowledgeable and professional. My property was unusual and she did an amazing job helping me to sell it. We had a great experience house hunting with her as well. She is very helpful and has a personal touch that we really appreciated.

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Cayley, an honor to help you sell such a special piece of property. I can't wait to partner with you and your family again! Thank you for allowing me to help you.

Winsome White Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Bethany Botzenhart is Amazing!!!! She exceeded our expectations in finding the perfect space and landlord to relocate Bella Que Dresses. She is passionate and committed to the success of her customers beyond the sale. I will absolutely recommend Bethany to everyone I know that is looking for a great realtor.

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

You are so kind Winsome! I know your store will be very successful in its new location. Congratulations!

Regina Walker Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Bethany was wonderful to work with and she was able to find exactly what I needed to relocate my law office. Bethany was readily available to answer any questions and provide knowledgeable guidance every step of the way. I would highly recommend Bethany as an agent to anyone looking for commercial space or residential real property.

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Regina, what an honor to be your friend for so long and help you find the perfect spot for your law office. Here's to many more years of winning cases on behalf of your clients. They have the very best representation.

Cathy Yergeau Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I met with Bethany shortly after deciding to make my dream of owning my own business a reality. From that first meeting to the ribbon cutting ceremony she was there with me every step of the way. She was not only my realtor but also a supporter, cheer leader and friend. I would highly recommend her!

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Cathy, you are a gift to the community! I admire you for following your dreams! I wish you many years of success with your new business venture.

Marty Sorrentino Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Bethany was awesome. Hands on, totally involved in every aspect of listing and selling my nephews home. I’ve been a Realtor for over 30 years and I can tell you Bethany is a real pro. It takes a lot to impress me and Bethany knocked it out of the park. Looking to buy or sell? Look no further. Thanks Bethany. Marty Sorrentino Signature Premier Properties Merrick-Long Island NY

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Marty, thank you for the very generous words. It was an honor to partner with you and your nephew on the sale of the home and I look forward to working together again!

MaryLou Julian Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Bethany is the best! She is so personable and easy to talk with. Really knows the business, and responds immediately to any questions. It's her personality that makes you want to work with her. She is a ray of sunshine!! So glad to know her, and I will always recommend her.

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

MaryLou, you and Nick were so wonderful to trust me twice!! I can't wait to stop by when I'm at the ballpark and say hi! Let's meet at the concession stand for an ice cream!

Sarah K Published on Google

Fantastic experience: It was intimidating to begin the search for a house as first time home buyers, but Bethany turned the entire journey into a wonderful and exciting experience. From the beginning, Bethany was always available to answer any questions, whether it was early morning or late at night. Our search for a home was a lengthy one, which at times felt discouraging, but Bethany offered an incredible amount of knowledge, encouragement, and support throughout the entire process. She even checked in after we closed to make sure everything went smoothly. I truly cannot recommend Bethany enough to anyone looking to buy or sell real estate. She is the best!

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Sarah how exciting to have you and Alex invite me to be a part of your story! I loved helping you find the perfect home and I know you'll make so many memories in your new home. I appreciate you trusting me.

Lucas Horigan Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Bethany has gone above and beyond for me throughout the entire home buying process. When a complex requirement from New York State was given to install electric base boards to get my mortgage, Bethany immediately booked an electrician for me. I am happily settled into my home now. I couldn’t have asked for a better advocate and would highly recommend you get her as an agent!

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Lucas, I was so happy to celebrate on closing day with you. Thank you for including me on this journey to purchase your first home. I can't wait to help you with the next!

Jorge Vera Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Bethany provided exceptional assistance in our search for a home in Western NY. Her professionalism, patience, and caring attitude truly set her apart. She not only understood our needs but also made the process seamless. Thanks to her, we were able to find our dream home that perfectly matched our budget. My wife and I wholeheartedly recommend Bethany on a personal level, and we enthusiastically encourage anyone seeking a home to collaborate with her.

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Jorge, it was an honor to welcome you and your beautiful family to WNY. Thank you for trusting me to help you find the perfect home. You're going to be an asset to the community, in your new role.

Jill Bernstein Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Bethany is always calm, cool, and collected. She has gone above and beyond in helping me with my recent home purchase, even after I closed. We are now working on selling my existing home and I know I’m in great hands. It is such a different and better experience than my last home purchase. I would highly recommend Bethany.

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Jill I am so glad it's been a great experience! It was an honor to have you referred to me. Thank you for trusting me to find you the perfect place and to help you sell your lovely home. Dog people are my kind of people!

Monica Romero Viñas Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Bethany is the best real estate agent. She took a lot of time to listen to our needs and ideas. She suggested what was best for our family, and because she spent so much time talking to us and getting to know us as a family, she found the perfect house for us. She not only helps you find a house but also, for me, she was so much more than that, she helped me find a school for my daughter and helped me get familiar with this new city. Anytime I had a question for her, she was approachable. She made this moving process a very beautiful and unique experience. Thank you very much, Bethany, for your amazing work and passion for what you do!"

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Thank you for such kind words Monica! I was an honor to help your family relocate to WNY. I'm so glad you love your home. I can't wait to help you explore this great city!

Megan Wolfe Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Bethany was an absolute godsend helping us find a house during our move from out of state! My husband & I found her knowledgeable, professional, and dedicated to helping us find a wonderful home for our family. She was always available to answer any questions we had throughout the process, and went above & beyond to help us find exactly what we needed. She was extremely accommodating regarding scheduling viewings (via FaceTime) and making herself available on short notice when necessary. We are truly grateful to have had Bethany as our realtor and highly recommend her to anyone looking for a new home!

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Megan, thank you so much for the kind words. I loved being able to welcome your family home from Mississippi! WNY is lucky to have all of you back. Thanks for your trust and patience to find the perfect home!

Kate Sherry Published on Google

Fantastic experience: We had a wonderful experience working with Bethany as our real estate agent. She was professional, knowledgeable and attentive to our needs. Bethany helped us find our dream home and never made us feel pressured. She was always available to answer our questions and kept us updated throughout the whole process of buying a smaller home and selling our family’s large home which we had built 31 years ago. Bethany is always smiling and has a positive attitude which made us feel confident and comfortable working with her. We highly recommend Bethany to anyone looking for knowledgeable and friendly real estate agent. We consider her our friend now. She is the best!

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Thank you so much Katy. Thrilled that you and Tim found the perfect spot. I'm sure the buyers of your home will have as many happy memories there as you did. I appreciate your trust and flexibility going through the process of buying and selling at the same time! So happy to continue the friendship!

Clara Bennett Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Bethany helped us to buy our first house, and she really put us at ease through the whole process. We were coming from out of town, and we were so grateful to be able to rely on her local expertise and network of professionals to help us during the purchase process and afterwards. I highly recommend Bethany and will definitely be calling upon her again the next time we’re looking for a house in Buffalo.

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Clara, thank you for the kind words! It was an absolutely honor to help you find your first home. Thank you for your trust and welcome you to Buffalo! ❤️

Lisa P Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Thank you so much Bethany! You did a great job and we are so grateful for making this process so easy and seamless. With having to move out of state, you took the stress of showing and selling the house off of us so that we could focus on other aspects of the relocation. We are very happy with how quickly the house sold. We would recommend your services to anyone who would need to sell their home!

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Thank you for choosing me to partner with. I know you had a choice and was honored to help sell your beautiful home. You made it just as easy for me. WNY is going to be missing a fabulous family!

Mary Alice Ubal Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Bethany helped me with my first business office location and has now gone above and beyond once again in the purchase of the property for my second office- from the charcuterie board during the home inspection to cookies at closing and more! Bethany puts her heart and soul into her relationships, and I'm blessed to have a dear friend in her! In addition, she knows everyone and has referrals for everything you need well after you've closed. She's always there for you no matter what time of day to let you know she's got you covered, and makes the experience exciting and fun even when it should be stressful. I'll continue to refer all of my family and friends to Bethany as I know they'll be extremely pleased with all she does.

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

MaryAlice, thank you so much for your generous words. It was an honor to help find a second office space for you. I love celebrating your success and am happy to observe first hand the reason for your growth...the amazing service you offer as well.
Only good things in store for you!

Steven Tokarczyk Published on Google

Fantastic experience: It has been a privilege to work with Bethany on multiple transactions.  Bethany’s secret sauce is her highly personalized customer service.  She is a student of the real estate market and her client’s needs.  As a real estate investor, her market knowledge, creativity and resourcefulness have helped me successfully navigate a highly competitive market, resulting in the acquisition and sale of first class properties.   Bethany’s tireless energy and constant communication make every transaction seem frictionless.    If you need someone to help you buy or sell a house or just need someone to put a smile on your face, call Bethany!

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

These words are so incredibly generous Steve. It’s been an absolute honor to help you on the buy and sell side of transactions. Our partnership means the world to me. Many thanks.

Marcia Taylor Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Bethany sold my house recently and I couldn’t be more happy with her experience & knowing how to help me every step of the way! Grateful to know her and highly recommend her!

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Marcia, I am so grateful you were referred to me. It was such a pleasure to partner on the sale of your home and get you moving to the next adventure! xo Bethany

Belle Sargent Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Bethany just sold a second property for me. If you want a no hassle experience, Bethany is your person. She is not only a expert in what she does, she is a genuinely nice person. She will not disappoint.

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Belle, thank you so much for the kind words. What an honor it’s been to help you and continue the journey as friends!

Sarah Anders Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Bethany was an incredible partner not only in the sale of our home but also finding us our new home. Her ability to connect and truly understand what we needed was amazing. Attentive to every detail she made the process seamless. Quick to answer texts - she ensured we had everything we needed and more! Thank you Bethany!!

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

What an honor to work with you and your family. Thrilled WNY is keeping you local for a bit longer. Thank you for your trust and friendship.

Tim Gaudioso Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Bethany was amazing in our first home buying experience. She truly took the time to find us what we were looking for and answered any and all of our questions (there were a lot it was our first time!). I would recommend anyone looking for a new home to go with Beth. Thank you for everything!!

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Thank you so much Tim! It was a pleasure to partner with you and Sadie. You picked the perfect home to start your journey together in. Thank you for trusting me to help! ❤️

Racquel Kurzweg Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Bethany is WONDERFUL! She was always in contact with me and took care of so many details I didn't even know needed to be worried about. Would highly recommend for residential or commercial needs.

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Racquel, thank you so much! It’s always a pleasure to work with someone who has a clear vision for what they want. Congratulations on your new space and wishing much success with your business!

Meghan Hill Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Bethany is a wealth of knowledge and made the stressful side of finding a home manageable with her care and expertise. Bethany was available to show homes immediately which was a blessing after other realtors never returned my calls or emails. I am so thankful for Bethany with her help of finding our perfect home. My son and I are looking forward to many wonderful memories and we could not have done this without Bethany. Thank you Bethany - please come see the Titanic bedroom soon! Love, Meghan and Desmond Benimoff

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Meghan, thank you very much. I was so fortunate to meet you and Desmond. Thrilled for you both and can’t wait to stop by and see how you’ve made this new home your own! ❤️

christian milioto Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Sometimes you feel as though things are meant to happen for a reason and when I met Beth I soon learned after that it was true. We had struggled for sometime to find our forever home. We had begun to worry with rising interest rates and over bidding of home we all have been experiencing. Within 4 viewings Beth not only found the perfect home for us but went above and beyond to seal the deal. Then the next worry came, to sell our home now being constrained to a very short time period. This was due to the sellers of our home moving so we purchased from the company not the sellers. She was then able to get this done for us as well, for exactly what we needed to satisfy all our goals. Beth is kind, courteous, honest and caring. Not only did I find a fantastic realtor but we found friends in her and her family. I am very thankful.

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Christian, what an honor to work with your family on the sale of your home and purchase of your new home. You have such a beautiful life and I was thrilled to be a small part of it. So glad to now call you a friend as well.

Ryan Mateyk Published on Google

Fantastic experience: My husband and I had an awesome time working with Bethany! Super responsive any day of the week, willing to take you to any and every property you ask for and very fun to be around. We found our house super quickly so didn't spend too much time working with her but would absolutely recommend! Thanks again for making our first house hunt super painless!

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

It’s always bittersweet for me when buyers find something so quickly! I am thrilled and flattered you were referred to me and can’t wait to see how you make your house a home! ❤️ Thank you for your trust.

Donna Mazurowski Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Bethany is beautiful on the inside and out, she was a very calming presence like when I lost my mind having a garage sale. Here's an example---excuse me, how much is this brand new camping stove--$10, a yeah can you throw in the the John Deere tractor with that?" Yeah, is this a 16th century table that John Hancock signed the Declaration of Independencece on, um I'll give you $4 in small change for that and can you throw in that snowblower? My colon is about to explode, do you mind if me and Jethro and the 5 kids use your bathroom, we all must of got food poisoning, its about to come out of both ends. Now I am not prone to using f-bombs...but what the... Bethany calmly explained that garage sales can be challenging. The time I was watching a realtor show some people the house from my ring camera that they were standing in front of. I turned on the sound and from the television came "I am going to kill you, get outta here", I was watching Outlander (which I highly recommend), there went Bethany's commission running out of the yard. I planned on coming up from Florida, selling the house in 2 weeks and being done with it as it was/is very emotional. 5 months later, not due to Bethany, but God who had to teach me about patience, I had to be talked off the ceiling several times. When it was time to do a price reduction, of course we all think our property is worth millions, she calmly and I mean calmly with the voice of Bob Ross painting a masterpiece in 4 minutes, suggested we do that. It worked! Always dressed to perfection. Not easily freaked out even when the snake crossed over in front of her, he was big----ooooh I was freaked!!! She prepared a beautiful picture book of the property for potential buyers to have, of which I will save and cherish. She was always available every time I texted her and walked me through all my questions. I highly recommend Bethany especially if you're a type A person who wants everything yesterday, she'll talk you down from the edge every time and get the job done.

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Donna, selling a home certainly can throw you some curve balls! Thanks so much for trusting me to guide you through the process. I’m glad you remember me being calm when that snake slithered past me…. I think I blacked out!

Gary Schaffer Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Bethany made the process of selling our home easy and stress free. She really cares about her clients and the work she does. She was easy to get a hold of, prompt, efficient and extremely friendly. When we return to Buffalo, my wife and I will certainly be using Bethany to help us find our new home!

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Gary, you and Anna were absolutely wonderful to work with. I can’t wait until you’re back in town and we can find the perfect home for again! Thank you for your trust.

Danielle turner Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Bethany stuck by my side during this crazy market! She took me to see all the homes I asked about and made sure I was only looking at homes in my budget. She’s flexible, available whenever you need her and always has a positive attitude. Gives her suggestions when needed or when you feel in doubt but let’s you take the lead. I look forward to working with her again in the future. Thank you

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

How lucky was I we got to hang together for so long! So much fun finding you “the one”. Can’t wait to see how you make it yours! Thank you for such kind words.

Michael Fiandalo Published on Google

Fantastic experience: An excellent rating does not do Bethany justice because she was extraordinary in all facets for purchasing our first home. To elaborate, Bethany was extremely flexible (and patient) with meeting our crazy work schedules for house showings, the depth of her knowledge of the house market, intricacies of each house we visited as well as the nuances throughout the home searching/purchase process were abundantly clear. Bethany's display of professionalism was impeccable, her interactions with us and other groups involved with the purchase of the home were positive. At no point during our venture did we ever feel like we were left dangling or alone, we had the utmost confidence in Bethany each step of the way and that confidence never waivered. We also appreciate her honesty when a potential purchase was not ideal because of factors that would lead to unnecessary post-purchase challenges. Moreover, even after we closed on our home, Bethany continued to provide guidance and help us find resources for updating our home. We recommend Bethany as a realtor for anyone interested in buying a house. She is an amazing realtor and an awesome person, who is genuine and actually cares about her clients.

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

These words are so very generous. Thank you and I hope you enjoy your home as much as I enjoyed working with you.

Jim Barron Published on Google

Fantastic experience: I have been a home inspector here in Western New York for the last five years. I’ve worked with Bethany many times it can’t say enough about how terrific she is to work with. Buying or selling a home is an exciting venture but but can be stressful as well. Bethany consistently goes above and beyond to make sure that her client’s needs are met and fears put to rest. I cannot recommend her highly enough to someone looking to buy or sell a home.

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Jim, thank you so much for the kind words. It’s great to have an honest home inspector to work with. Knowing my buyers have an eye like yours on the home gives everyone comfort when making such a big decision! Thanks for all you do.

Allison Meindl Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Bethany is a class act. She was so patient with our multiple requests and hectic schedule and always made us feel like we were her only clients. From the buying to selling process, Bethany made it easy and was always there for support. As happy as we are to have found our new home, we will miss our weekly showing “dates” with our friend

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

It was so much fun working with your family, thank you for the kind words. I know you’ll have many happy years in your new home! Count me in for the bbqs ❤️

The Care Connection Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Bethany was so wonderful to work with! She took time to listen to our needs, as well as wants, in a new location for our business. She provided us a number of options and also offered to scout places early so we wouldn't waste our time if it wasn't a good fit. She made the process of finding a new location enjoyable and exciting. Thank you Bethany for supporting us through the process and helping us find the perfect new location for our business!

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Thank you for the kind words. I am so excited to watch your business grow in your new location! Skies the limit for you. Congratulations

Jane Olvera Published on Google

Fantastic experience: Working with Bethany Botzenhart was such a pleasure. We could not have invented a better realtor if we’d tried! Professional, personable, smart, responsive, conscientious are just some of the words that come to mind. We were relocating from another state, and greatly appreciate Bethany’s capabilities. From long discussions to FaceTime walk-throughs to touring houses in person, Bethany was exceptional in every way. Thank you, Bethany!

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Thank you so much! I appreciate your very generous words. It was such a pleasure working with you and Gil to find the perfect home

Natalie Pieri Published on Google

Fantastic experience: We used Bethany for the sale of our home and the purchase of our new home. For the past two years we have called on Bethany to show us several homes before we finally found the perfect place, she was always available for us at any time! Bethany worked extremely hard on the selling of our house she went above what was expected of her. My husband and I definitely recommend Bethany for anyone looking for a hard working realtor, you will not be disappointed.

BethanySells716
BethanySells716

Thank you so much for your kind words. It was so much fun working with you both on your sale and your purchase.

Leave your opinion about BethanySells716:

1 = Poor
5 = Excellent

Reviews are checked before they are published. We do not publish reviews containing insults, accusations of criminal conduct or references to specific individuals. We also do not verify that the author was a customer.

Other real estate agencies you might be interested in

3.7 (64)
Keller Williams Realty WNY
Keller Williams Realty WNY

Keller Williams Realty WNY

View address and contact details
5500 Main St #108 - 14221, Depew
+1716-832-3300
5 (144)
Real Estate People, The Giambra Team
Real Estate People, The Giambra Team

Real Estate People, The Giambra Team

View address and contact details
5500 Main St #108 - 14221, Buffalo
+1716-239-6432
5 (66)
John Majewski Lic. Associate Real Estate Broker
John Majewski Lic. Associate Real Estate Broker

John Majewski Lic. Associate Real Estate Broker

View address and contact details
5500 Main St #108 - 14221, Depew
+1716-430-9916
5 (63)
Thejan Kodituwakku (TJ) : Real Estate Salesperson
Thejan Kodituwakku (TJ) : Real Estate Salesperson

Thejan Kodituwakku (TJ) : Real Estate Salesperson

View address and contact details
5500 Main St #108 - 14221, Depew
+1716-292-8756
4.8 (93)
Own NY Real Estate
Own NY Real Estate

Own NY Real Estate

View address and contact details
2562 Walden Ave - 14225, Buffalo
+1716-650-4915
4.7 (66)
WNY Metro Premier Realty
WNY Metro Premier Realty

WNY Metro Premier Realty

View address and contact details
1876 Niagara Falls Blvd - 14150, Tonawanda
+1716-446-1560
3.5 (73)
Buffalo City Living, LLC
Buffalo City Living, LLC

Buffalo City Living, LLC

View address and contact details
2626 Main St - 14214, Buffalo
+1716-222-2489
3 (119)
Irish Jones
Irish Jones

Irish Jones

View address and contact details
1305 Bailey Ave Unit 2 - 14206, Buffalo
+1716-768-4915
4.6 (64)
The Bishop Team at Exp Realty
The Bishop Team at Exp Realty

The Bishop Team at Exp Realty

View address and contact details
4830 Transit Rd - 14043, Depew
+1716-791-7253
3.3 (159)
Greenleaf & Co

Greenleaf & Co

View address and contact details
1131 Delaware Ave - 14209, Buffalo
+1716-885-8538
5 (74)
Scott Perkins with Realty ONE Group Empower
Scott Perkins with Realty ONE Group Empower

Scott Perkins with Realty ONE Group Empower

View address and contact details
451 Elmwood Ave - 14222, Buffalo
+1716-796-1404
4 (485)
Sinatra & Co.
Sinatra & Co.

Sinatra & Co.

View address and contact details
617 Main St #200 - 14203, Buffalo
+1716-220-8468

Add your real estate agency to our directory for free

If you manage a real estate agency and want to appear in our guide, send us your company information and you can appear completely free of charge.

Add your real estate agency for free

The largest real estate directory in United States

Find the best real estate agencies near you