Michelle McArdle, Realtor at Douglas Elliman in Garden City Long Island
Micahelle McArdle is the top-performing realtor at the Douglas Elliman Garden City office, recognized for her exceptional dedication, ethical standards, and proven results. Ranked among the top 1.5% of real estate agents nationwide by the Wall Street Journal's Real Trends (2021-2023), Michelle has achieved a sales volume exceeding $210 million, establishing herself as a leader in the Long Island real estate market.
With a diverse portfolio of certifications including Senior Real Estate Specialist (SRES), Accredited Staging Professional (ASP), and Sellers Representative Specialist (SRS), Michelle offers comprehensive expertise for every stage of the property journey. Whether you are a first-time homebuyer navigating your first purchase, a seller looking to maximize your property's value through professional staging, or a client requiring relocation services, Michelle provides personalized, hard-working representation. Her holistic approach ensures that every client receives the highest level of service and support to achieve their real estate goals.
Opening hours
- sunday: 9h-20h
- monday: 9h-20h
- tuesday: 9h-20h
- wednesday: 9h-20h
- thursday: 9h-20h
- friday: 9h-20h
- saturday: 9h-20h
Photos of Michelle McArdle, Realtor at Douglas Elliman in Garden City Long Island
Michelle McArdle, Realtor at Douglas Elliman in Garden City Long Island: Reviews
Reviews are the opinions of their authors. We do not verify that the author was a customer.
Reviews on Google
5,0 out of 5 from 53 reviews
Fantastic experience: We recently sold our home with Michelle, and we couldn't be more pleased with the experience. From the very beginning, she was professional, knowledgeable, and incredibly responsive. From day one, she made the whole process easy and stress-free. She really knew the market and helped us price our home just right. She was easy to work with and we highly recommend her.
Fantastic experience: Working with Michelle was seamless and stress free. We met with her once and then left for our home in Fl. She handled everything Our home sold within a week for our asking price. We couldn’t have been happier!
Fantastic experience: Michelle was a pleasure to work with. She is very knowledgeable and helped ease my mind during a very stressful situation.
Fantastic experience: Michelle was thorough, knowledgeable, and extremely helpful. She went above and beyond! So grateful we decided to go with her!
Fantastic experience: A good friend recommended I contact Michelle to assist in the sale of my Garden City home. I am so glad he did. I was in a pinch having submitted a bid to buy another house and needed to get the sale of my home done quickly. I knew from our first meeting that Michelle would do an excellent job and that she would give her full attention to the sale of my house. She came totally prepared with ample market information enabling me to determine an appropriate offering price. She advised me on staging, she brought in a terrific photographer to take pictures for the website, she arranged for a full-page ad in the local newspaper, and she scheduled and managed the open house. She gave me ample feedback on buyers’ interest and evaluated the strength of their offers. It wasn’t long before I had a signed contract of sale. Her experience in the market and good relationships with other real estate agents and attorneys facilitated the closing process. I am very happy to recommend her to anyone thinking about selling their home
Fantastic experience: I highly recommend Michelle McArdle. I had the opportunity to see Michelle's skills when she represented me in the sale of my home and just recently on the purchase of our new home. She is a true professional who has exceptional knowledge of the marketplace, respect amongst her peers, and a keen negotiator.
Fantastic experience: Michelle did an excellent job assisting my husband and I with selling our coop. Her expertise and experience with the Birchwood community and the local real estate market was instrumental in securing many viewings, offers, and ultimately a very competitive selling price. Michelle is professional, friendly, responsive, and a pleasure to work with.
Fantastic experience: “ Miracle Worker” Is the best way to describe Michelle – she listed my house in August and I signed a contract of sale in September at the price I needed to get. As a senior citizen with a handicap, with no family and no real estate experience, I was in a difficult position. Michelle took over everything that had to be done and kept me updated every step; answered my questions; and always kept me informed. When I hired Michelle I knew that I was entrusting my future to her. It was one of the best decisions I ever made.
Fantastic experience: We really appreciated Michelle's professionalism in working with us on a house closing. Michelle acts fast, provides prompt responses, and most importantly, is honest and fair. She is a pleasure to work with and we would work with her again.
Fantastic experience: We recently worked with Michelle McArdle to sell our Mineola home, and we couldn't be more pleased with the experience. From start to finish, she was professional, knowledgeable, and dedicated to making the process as smooth and stress-free as possible. Michelle provided excellent advice on how to prepare our home for sale, ensuring it looked its best for potential buyers. She created a fantastic marketing strategy that included professional photos and listings that really showcased our home. Thanks to her efforts, our home sold quickly and for a great price. Communication was always prompt, clear, and helpful. Michelle kept us updated and answered all of our questions we had. If you're looking for a knowledgeable and hardworking, agent to sell your home, we highly recommend Michelle McArdle. It was a pleasure working with her, and wouldn't hesitate to work with her again!
Fantastic experience: Michelle recently assisted in selling my coop. She was extremely knowledgeable and professional. She made the process easy for me and always made herself available to help with any questions along the way. I highly recommend her!
Fantastic experience: Agent Michelle McArdle was communicative and knowledgeable! We were selling one property while trying to buy another. This involved a lot of deadlines, restrictions, and time constraints - - and Michelle handled them all efficiently and skillfully. Michelle is thorough!! She also has a bank of resources and connections to help you. So happy with the way everything worked out. Thank you again, Michelle!!
Fantastic experience: Working with a great realtor can make all the difference. Michelle McArdle is that person! We had an absolutely fantastic experience working with her to sell our co-op. Michelle is knowledgable, patient and kind. She was also a great negotiator! The entire process working with her was exceptional...from beginning to end. We highly recommend Michelle to anyone looking for the perfect realtor!
Fantastic experience: Michelle's in-depth expertise and industry knowledge enabled her to price, market, and sell our co-op within days of listing, at above-asking. She was a pleasure to work with, and delivered a seamless selling experience. We recommend her highly!
Fantastic experience: We highly recommend Michelle for your real estate needs. Michelle was friendly and very knowledgeable of Birchwood Court. She was informative and communicated with us throughout the whole process.
Fantastic experience: I highly recommend Michelle McArdle for all your property buying and selling needs. She is professional and sees the sale from beginning to end. I needed an agent to handle an estate sale for me and Michelle sold the property at the first open house. It was a complicated sale due to a land lease expiration in 27 years and therefore, lenders would not issue a 30 year mortgage. Michelle literally "held my hand" throughout the process and negotiated with the buyers a 20 year mortgage on the property after they were denied for a 30 year mortgage. The entire sale could have fallen apart and due to Michelle's due diligence, there was a successful closing. In addition Michelle met with the painter, junk removal people, and floor installer providing me with the gift of time and there's no money value that can be placed on the gift of time. She also selected a couple, who according to my dad's upstairs neighbor, is a great find. They are courteous, thoughtful and make good neighbors. Michelle was able to accomplish what at times appeared impossible. I am pleased with the sale, the buyers are very pleased with their purchase and it warms my heart that my dad's upstairs neighbor is delighted as well. I can't say enough about Michelle and highly recommend her as your agent. Ruth Cosentino
Fantastic experience: I highly recommend Michelle McArdle. She is very professional and very sensitive to all the emotions involved with selling your home. Above all she helped with every step. From setting up the home, to clearing out the house ,donating furniture, and most of all, making sure I was doing well though it all. Her experience and compassion helped me get over my asking price. Michelle is a go getter and will do her best to make things run as smooth as possible.
Fantastic experience: Michelle and Erin were very helpful as my realtors in the sale of my home. They effectively communicated with me during every step of the process. When the buyers hit a road bump in securing the mortgage for the purchase, Michelle and Erin kept me informed and assured me that the deal would be finalized, and it did! Thank you Michelle and Erin for your expertise and fine attention to detail. Steve Carey
Fantastic experience: I can't say more positive things about Michelle. She is reliable, upfront, and most importantly she sold my coop within days at the above asking price. The entire process was seamless from our first meeting until the closing.
Fantastic experience: Michelle was great! She made our search really easy and found the perfect place for us. She knows her stuff! She was always available to answer any questions and helped with our co-op paperwork which wasn’t easy. She was there every step of the way. I would definitely recommend Michelle to all my friends and family.
Fantastic experience: Michelle an is an absolute pleasure to work with. We've worked with her for many years, and her professionalism, attention to detail, tenacity, and experience have made every one of our purchases and sells painless and a great overall experience. Thank you Michelle!
Fantastic experience: Michelle McArdle is a stellar professional. She does what she says, and go beyond the call of duty. She made the selling of my home process seamless. She answered all my questions while allowing me space to make my own decisions. She has an outstanding record for selling homes in a short period of time. I had an interested buyer with a down payment in less than 3 weeks on market placement. I would highly recommend Ms. McArdle to anyone seeking quality, professionally, and fast results.
Fantastic experience: Michelle is a consummate professional and she shepherded us through this process with great skill and deep knowledge of our market and how to make our home stand out for potential buyers.
Fantastic experience: Michelle McArdle was a pleasure to work with. She handled both our buy and sell. She was attentive and answered our every question and addressed our concerns as they arose. She made what could have been a very stressful situation run smoothly.
Fantastic experience: Michelle was amazing!! She sold my place in three days for a record price!!
Fantastic experience: Michelle has been more than helpful in assisting with the sale of many units through the years. She has gone above and beyond to advise on contractors and finishes. And of course, the proof is in the pudding, and she always achieves the most competitive pricing. Most of all she is genuinely nice, well informed, professional, understanding, willing to work with complicated situations and a pleasure to work with.
Fantastic experience: Michelle did an outstanding job of listing and selling my co-op. She was professional, courteous and extremely knowledgeable of the entire process. She communicated frequently and was always available to answer questions. I felt very comfortable working with her and would highly recommend her to others.
Fantastic experience: Michelle was outstanding to work with. If we were to sell another property, we'd definitely work with her again. Her communication, responsiveness, and knowledge of the entire selling process from staging to closing was very impressive. As first time sellers we had tons of questions and she did her best to answer everything and anything and put our concerns to rest. Every detail was taken care of and she made the process go exceedingly smooth from start to finish. 10/10!!
Fantastic experience: Michelle is excellent. She is trustworthy, dedicated and easy to work with. She makes the process seamless.
Fantastic experience: Michelle did a great job finding tenants for my rental in Mineola! She is honest and trustworthy. I highly recommend her for any of your real estate needs.
Fantastic experience: We recently sold our condominium last year, and Michelle and Helen were our agents. The market had begun to slow down at the time, and we followed their advice regarding the original offering price. Despite the week sales market, we were able to quickly sell our condo at a higher price than we had thought. I found that they were easy to work with, and quite responsive to our suggestions. They also “staged” the apartment, and it showed beautifully in person and in photos. We continue to work with them through our Wish was straight forward. I would highly recommend both Michelle and Helen as brokers if you are considering either buying or selling real estate in the current market.
Fantastic experience: We contacted Michelle to sell our Mother’s co-op. Michelle had another unit listed in the building. Michelle met with us very quickly, explained the selling process and made suggestions for minor improvements to the unit which would assist in the sale. Michelle recommended the contractor, cleaning service and lawyer that we worked with. Michelle provided virtual staging and the apartment was in contract shortly after the Open House. Michelle was transparent, responsive and communicated frequently throughout the process. The closing was repeatedly delayed by the incompetence of the co-op management company, but Michelle remained positive and truly assisted us in crossing the finish line.
Fantastic experience: Michelle was friendly and full of knowledge about the whole process. She walked me through the coop selling step by step. She made great suggestions to get my apt ready for sale. The virtual staging was perfect. Wonderful experience with Michelle!
Fantastic experience: This was my second time using Michelle!! As always, she was reliable, knowledgeable and really tried her best to get me the best price possible on selling my co-op. I would not use anyone else but her. She is always willing to answer your questions and responds very quickly. Over all a great experience!
Fantastic experience: Michelle and Helen are a great team and made the process of selling our property relatively easy. They were realistic in their pricing, wonderful in their staging and always available to assist us. Most importantly sold our place in a difficult market.
Fantastic experience: Michelle was professional and successful with selling my home. Everything was done correctly and she assisted in every needed aspect.
Fantastic experience: Michelle did an amazing job at helping my wife and I sell our cooperative apartment. When we were first looking to sell, we recently had a child and were anxious about juggling selling the apartment and taking care of a newborn, but Michelle was flexible, worked with our schedule and provided detailed guidance on timelines and milestones to achieve to have a competitive listing. Once the listing went on the market, we got offers within a week at above listing price. I would highly recommend Michelle for all your real estate needs.
Fantastic experience: If you’re looking to sell your home, Michelle is the realtor you want. Michelle has extensive knowledge with real estate, which was very helpful in todays market. She priced my home accurately and it sold in a matter of days and over asking price. She found great buyers, who worked quickly to close on the property. I couldn’t have asked for a better transaction. I will definitely refer Michelle, knowing that my friends and family are in good hands.
Fantastic experience: Michelle McArdle from Douglas Elliman Realty did a great job in selling my cooperative apartment in Mineola. She was knowledgeable about the market and professional in her dealings with me and potential buyers. In the end , I was very satisfied and sold my home for above the listing price.
Fantastic experience: Thanks for Michelle. She is a nice agent.Very professional. I want everybody to know how much I am appreciated the excellent service she provides on the case of selling my property(832 Pepperidge Rd, Westbury, NY 11590
Fantastic experience: I can’t possibly recommend Michelle McArdle enough. My sister was contemplating selling her co-op when I came across Michelle’s name as someone who was very well respected at Birchwood Ct. (Mineola). I contacted Michelle and she immediately made the time to meet with my sister and me. We loved, trusted, and connected with her instantaneously. Aside from being extremely knowledgeable about anything and everything to do with real estate - she is an awesome person who we now consider a friend. We also utilized her as our “real estate therapist”. Selling and moving can be an overwhelming and anxiety ridden process - and Michelle held my sister’s hand every step of the way with incredible advice on how to create a manageable plan to get the apartment ready for sale. Her guidance on maximizing the visual appeal of the apartment was spot on, and within weeks of putting the place on the market - it sold for more than we expected. The process couldn’t have gone smoother. TRUST ME - Michelle is a real estate goddess and you will be in amazing hands with her if you’re looking to buy or sell.
Fantastic experience: Michelle is a true industry professional. My wife and I had bad experiences in the past buying our first home, so we were hesitant going through the process again. Michelle spent quality time with us learning current market trends, providing examples and gave us the hard Q&A every home buyer needs to answer. From start to finish on the sale of our property to moving into a new dream home, Michelle handled everything with calm and grace as a professional should. Highly recommend her when it comes any real estate needs.
Fantastic experience: Michelle is the Queen of Birchwood Real Estate. She is very good at what she does and a pleasure to work with. I would definitely use her again and recommend her to friends and family!
Fantastic experience: Michelle McArdle is a wonderful resource for all of your real estate needs. Michelle is professional, attentive, responsive, and knowledgeable. Taking Michelle’s advice and suggestions, my home sold quickly and easily. I would highly recommend Michelle!
Fantastic experience: Michelle McArdle is an outstanding realtor. She sold my home in Hempstead within two weeks of listing it at above the asking price. I buy and sell homes frequently and it is rare to meet a realtor with her professionalism. From our introduction to the closing she did everything right!
Fantastic experience: I moved to another state and Michelle was recommended to me to help me sell my coop. She was very professional and informative upon our first meeting and made me feel comfortable and confident about the whole process. While I was on the other side of the country, I received an offer very quickly. Michelle provided her expert advisement on negotiating, which proven to be successful. I would highly recommend Michelle to anyone looking for a professional and experienced agent!
Fantastic experience: Michelle went above and beyond what I ever expected a realtor to do. I could not have possibly had a better person to go through the process of selling my parents house than her, she is absolutely top notch!!
Fantastic experience: Highly recommend!!!
Fantastic experience: I’ve worked with Michelle in both the purchase and sale of our property. Her experience and proficiency are unmatched. After staging our apartment and pricing appropriately, we sold in only 1 day on the market. Beyond grateful for being able to work with such a wonderful person and professional.
Fantastic experience: We had to move my dad into assisted living and Michelle made what we thought would be a difficult process of selling his place easy. She was wonderful and patient with my father and us. Very knowledgeable of the real estate market and made excellent recommendations on how best to move his place. Professional and kind, a terrific combination.
Fantastic experience: We took Michelle's help for finding a new home for us as we were getting married. She has been amazing through the entire process, finally we got it and moved. It was very kind and sweet of her to send us a house warming gift too. Surely made us feel connected. We would highly recommend working with her.
Fantastic experience: Working with Michelle was a great experience! Buying your first home can be scary and Michelle made the process so easy and enjoyable! She took the time out to sit with me and go over all paper work and anything I needed. She was always available to answer any questions and always explained every step along the way. I could not have asked for a better realestate agent.
Fantastic experience: Michelle was very knowledgeable in staging and then advertising my house. She sold the house on the Open House weekend, negotiating the best deal for me among multiple offers. Michelle was very professional and made the whole process enjoyable.
Leave your opinion about Michelle McArdle, Realtor at Douglas Elliman in Garden City Long Island:
Michelle McArdle, Realtor at Douglas Elliman in Garden City Long Island appears in the following listings:
Other real estate agencies you might be interested in
Nina Jean Harris | Realtor @Signature Premier Properties
David Lau | Realtor
Caroline Kohen, Licensed Real Estate Salesperson, CBR, CIREC, SFR, at Douglas Elliman
Taleen & Richie Krug Jr- The RTK Realty Group @ CB American Homes (Formerly of The Krug Team)
All Area Realty Services
The Right Bob Realty, LLC
Armas Group NYC Real Estate | Queens Village | Bellerose | Floral Park NY
Add your real estate agency to our directory for free
If you manage a real estate agency and want to appear in our guide, send us your company information and you can appear completely free of charge.