The Columbus Team REALTORS

Fantastic experience: Sue Lusk-Gleich at The Columbus Team did an amazing job helping to sell our house. The whole process was so easy and low stress, they had a person for everything that needed to happen along the way. The house was in Clintonville, and Sue is an expert on the area. She helped us to get the best price for our house and took the time to guide us through each step along the way. I would recommend them to my friends.

Fantastic experience: Words cannot express how full my cup is after working with Sue Lusk-Gleich from The Columbus Team on the purchase of my new home. I came to her with a unique proposal, to buy the home my family fell in love with, after renting it for 2 years. She was kind, supportive, and tenacious to get the best outcome for us. Her years of experience in the Worthington market and dependable network of resources lead us through every turn in the process. Since closing, she has followed up and checked in, going well above and beyond any obligations. I just feel so grateful for having shared this experience with her in my corner. Thank you Sue, truly, thank you <3

Fantastic experience: Attentive and professional. Great communication. Completely satisfied with the experience.

Fantastic experience: My wife and I heartily recommend Sue Lusk-Gleich and The Columbus Team of Keller-Williams realty. Sue has been our Realtor twice now, and the fact we used her the second time -- 28 years later -- should attest to our satisfaction. Our latest transaction was buying a condo in Westerville in March 2026 and then selling our house in Worthington in May 2026. Sue was with us every step of the way, from the first day we indicated we were interested in moving right up through the purchase of the condo and the closing on our house. There was never a drop-off in support, and that includes from Sue's team. House coach Lisa Viertel advised us early in the process on what we needed to do before showing our home, and others in the office played helpful roles in giving us constant support. It all produced a well-above-listing-price sale on the first day on market. We also really appreciated Sue's communication in the days and weeks leading up to closing on both the condo and the house. Just as a question was emerging in my mind, Sue would contact me and answer my question before I'd even asked it. You really can leave it to her and her team to take care of a lot of things for you! She also carefully explained all of the financial details on the closing documents. By the time we put our signatures on documents, we knew exactly what we were doing. Sue and her team are the best.

Fantastic experience: My wife and I recently purchased our home in the Reynoldsburg area, and we are incredibly grateful for the outstanding service we received from Sue Lusk-Gleich, REALTOR with KW Capital Partners, and The Columbus Team. From the moment we began our home search, Sue demonstrated exceptional professionalism, knowledge, and dedication. We viewed several homes throughout the Columbus area, and she was always patient, responsive, and willing to go the extra mile to help us find the perfect fit for our family. What truly set Sue apart was her genuine commitment to our needs. She never made us feel pressured and always took the time to answer our questions, explain the process, and provide honest guidance. Her expertise and attention to detail gave us confidence every step of the way and made what could have been a stressful experience feel smooth and enjoyable. Sue Lusk-Gleich and the Columbus Team exceeded our expectations in every way. Their commitment to client service, communication, and professionalism is second to none. We felt supported throughout the entire home-buying process and knew we were in great hands. We are proud homeowners today because of Sue’s hard work, dedication, and care. “We highly recommend” Sue Lusk-Gleich, KW Capital Partners, and The Columbus Team to anyone looking to buy or sell a home in the Columbus area. Thank you, Sue Lusk-Gleich, for helping us find not just a house, but a place we are proud to call home. Your kindness, expertise, and support.

Fantastic experience: AMAZING! Pat was our realtor when my husband and I bought our first home. After more than 20 years, we decided to move. Our first call was to Pat. He was with us through every step of the process with unbelievable patience as we didn’t quite know what we wanted or where we wanted to live. When we decided on a custom-built home Pat spent so much time with us watching as the house was built. He made selling our former home almost effortless. I absolutely recommend Pat and his team to anyone buying or selling.

Fantastic experience: The Columbus Team sold my home fast for above asking price. Great communication and home photos. The closing process was smooth and easy. Thanks Sue and your team !

Fantastic experience: I have sold and bought with this fine team and I can’t say enough. Above and beyond work, trustworthy, reliable and professional. Doesn’t hurt that they are good, honest folks too.

Fantastic experience: I have had great experiences with the Columbus team, both buying and selling. Recently I worked with Jeanne O’Keefe and Erin Oxender to purchase a home. They took care of all the heavy lifting. Erin made many recommendations that saved us money and helped us get what we were after. They really know the business and the Columbus market, and are a pleasure to work with. I plan to use them for any future moves!

Fantastic experience: As first-time homebuyers, we honestly couldn’t have asked for a better realtor than Terry. From our very first meeting, she made us feel comfortable, informed, and confident every step of the way. Buying your first home can feel overwhelming, but Terry patiently answered all our questions, explained the process in detail, and gave us honest advice about every property we looked at. Terry was incredibly responsive and always just a call or text away when we needed guidance. She truly cares about her clients and wants the best for them. We felt like more than just another transaction and were treated like family. We wholeheartedly recommend Terry to anyone looking to buy or sell a home — especially first-timers like us! Thank you for making this experience so smooth and memorable!

Fantastic experience: Sue was very helpful not hesitate to giver her opinion on the house as to what was good for us and what wasn’t. She got to know us very well as we got to know her. Had us explore things we didn’t realize was available. Couldn’t have asked for a better realtor. She was a blessing. Thanks again Sue Gleich

Fantastic experience: We had a fantastic experience with Patrick. He was incredibly responsive, always getting back to us quickly and keeping us informed every step of the way. We truly appreciate his strong knowledge of the market, which gave us confidence throughout the process. Patrick was also easy to work with and genuinely caring. We felt very comfortable and supported during what can be a stressful time. We highly recommend Patrick to anyone looking for a knowledgeable and personable agent!

Fantastic experience: The house we just purchased with Terry and the Columbus Team represents the 3rd home I've purchased. In the past, I've had great experiences with my realtors, but this one stands head and shoulders above. Terry and her team were so flexible and accommodating and were supremely flexible in helping us deal with getting a house in the midst of a time crunch and tons of work travel. Terry quickly keyed into what we were looking for and steered us right to the house we ended up purchasing which we've been super happy with. The whole experience was as painless as possible, and she and her team made all the difference in getting us into our home. We couldn't be happier.

Fantastic experience: We have worked with Pat on several projects of selling and buying properties. We Were able to buy and sell quickly and he helped us locate the perfect house that fit our family! He has always been available responsive helpful and knowledgable throughout the process. He is also friendly and really cares about our needs. We would Highly recommend him and his Team .

Fantastic experience: I have bought and sold with the Columbus Team over many years. Jeanne, Erin and the team have become trusted partners in my home ownership. I wouldn’t do it without them.

Fantastic experience: For real estate transactions, I only work with Jeanne O'Keefe and Erin Ogden Oxender. They are genuinely committed to meeting the long-term needs of their clients and work to make a positive impact on the greater Columbus community. Buying or selling a home can be so stressful, but I promise you will have an incredible experience with this crew. They are consummate professionals - ethical and kind with a proven track record of returning clients like me.

Fantastic experience: I highly recommend Jeanne O'Keefe a dedicated realtor and trusted friend from the Columbus Team Realtors. She helped me understand recent tax changes by finding comparable properties, and provided valuable insights, which helped us navigate our options.

Fantastic experience: We highly recommend the expertise of Jeanne O’Keefe and the Columbus Team. We are so happy with our investment property and would not have been able to navigate this market without Jeanne. She is a wealth of knowledge about the current Central Ohio real estate climate. Her ability to communicate and negotiate is beyond just dollar signs. We have used their services for over 20 years and will continue to for many more.

Fantastic experience: The Columbus Team is an expertly curated group of extremely talented professionals- I’ve worked with them a number of times and am always impressed with their professionalism and focus. Special shout-out to team member Jeanne O’Keefe, who has provided priceless real estate services to my family for over a decade- thanks for being so good at what you do!

Fantastic experience: Sue and her team were friendly and comforting throughout the incredibly emotionally challenging process of selling a long-term and beloved home, a process made even more challenging by the recent loss of my spouse. Sue and her team shoulder much of the burden, including having a stable of skilled and vetted craftspersons that can tackle many of the tasks required to get a house on the market. Sue and her team also have an impressive understanding of the real estate market in Clintonville and Central Ohio, and provided invaluable guidance as we worked to achieve maximum value on the sale of our house. In my experience with Sue and her team, first in buying this house 20 years ago and in selling it now, I had a great confidence that I had true professionals in my corner, guiding me to the best possible outcome. When we sell our home, we are putting our future in our agent’s hands, and with Sue, I did so confident in a quality outcome. Sue and her team care, and it shows.

Fantastic experience: Sue is a peerless real estate professional.She patiently and expertly talked me through each step of my home buying journey. She deftly managed and made me aware of details so that I overlooked nothing. She was quickly responsive to all of my calls and questions. I recommend her service and that of her team without reservation.

Fantastic experience: Stefanie was beyond helpful and she is amazing at what she does! We needed a realtor and team to come in and take our house sale off our shoulders. That is exactly what Stefanie & her team did. They came in, staged the property, took professional photos, she communicated clearly & well, told us exactly what needed done to sell. Our house was in contract in less than a month! Our experience was incredible & I highly recommend Stefanie and the Columbus team!!

Fantastic experience: We purchased our home in Marion with help from Sue Lusk-Gleich and her team. She quickly steered us to a home we wanted and then helped us to negotiate for the right price. The process was smooth and we very much appreciated the expert help from Sue and the Columbus Team Realtors. When we decided to sell we went directly to Sue and her team. The entire experience was amazing. She enlisted the help of a videographer that made an outstanding video of our home and surrounding neighborhood. Her expert knowledge of the market and our needs for a fair price as well as timing resulted in our home selling after the very first open house. She is a straight shooter whose experience is invaluable. We cannot more strongly recommend Sue and her Columbus Team, whether you are buying or selling. You simply cannot go wrong!

Fantastic experience: Stefanie was amazing for us in the process of buying our first house! So professional, prompt and a great communicator. I recommend her to any individual/ couple/ family buying a house as this was a great experience for both me and my husband!

Fantastic experience: It was the most amazing experience from meeting Sue for the first time and having her know what our family needed and wanted to the day she brought a home to us that would be a perfect fit to the day we closed on our dream home , it’s truly been the most exciting experience I’ve ever had

Fantastic experience: This is the second time I have worked with Stefanie and she is an absolute dream! She intimately knows the housing market, has a strong team that seamlessly guides you through the sales process and gives great and honest advice. Quick and easy communication. Questions answered. Needs met and no stone left unturned. There is no one else I’d rather work with on a real estate deal!

Fantastic experience: Sue and her team were absolutely fantastic in selling our Clintonville home! Sue was always available for questions and was extremely prompt in her communication with us. Lisa was great with staging suggestions. Sue’s selling strategy and Lisa’s staging really paid off, as we had over 30 showings in the first weekend and multiple offers. We ended up selling significantly over asking. The entire team was great throughout the close process, keeping us informed of each step. I would absolutely recommend Sue and The Columbus Team for anyone’s real estate needs!

Fantastic experience: We have had the pleasure of working with Sue and Patrick on a number of home sales and buys with multiple family members. In this strange market the two things that stood out were their diligence and sound advice. We are so happy with the outcomes of working with Sue and Patrick we will never look anywhere else for our realtor needs. What a great team!

Fantastic experience: We met Stefanie when she was having an open house on our street. She came over that day and we were so comfortable with her that we asked her to list our home. She and her team were very communicative and easy to deal with. We were able to sell our home and go through the process with minimal stress because they assisted us every step of the way.

Fantastic experience: Erin helped my fiance and I get an awesome deal on our first house! Big thanks to her and the whole Columbus Team!

Fantastic experience: I am delighted to recommend Terry for all your real estate needs. Her dedication, professionalism and industry knowledge are second to none. Terry's expertise in the local real estate market was invaluable in pricing my property accurately. Her marketing strategies coupled with professional photography and compelling property descriptions, led to a swift sale at the desired price point. Throughout the process, Terry was committed to buy best interests, staying responsive to my queries and handling negotiations with utmost professionalism. Her personable approach helped immensely in reducing stress often associated with selling property. In essence, Terry's exceptional service, extensive industry knowledge and genuine care made for a seamless and successful experience. I highly recommend Terry Zellar to anyone seeking a reliable and experienced realtor.

Fantastic experience: My husband, John and I would like to Thank Stefanie Halbert for helping us sell our condo! We live in Cincinnati and she was referred by a friend who told us that Stefanie would work hard for us! She went above and beyond in helping us due to some glitches, as her expertise and knowledge base got use through with little difficulty and the fact that we couldn't drive up there often as we needed. We HIGHLY recommend Stefanie and her team as they are outstanding and will make every effort to prep, stage and price your place to sell. Thank you !!!

Fantastic experience: This was the second time we used these Realtors, the first to sell our home and the second to sell our Mother's Condo. Both times they were very professional and helped us maximize our return. Both properties were sold in a couple days after listing. We would use them again!

Fantastic experience: Stefanie did an amazing job helping me get my house ready to sell!! The process was so streamlined and professional. I definitely could have never sold my house so fast without her expertise. I would highly recommend her and her team !!

Fantastic experience: I highly recommend Patrick Florence and the Columbus Team. He was knowledgeable, always prepared and provided just the right amount of communication. As a result, the selling process went very smoothly. I've relocated multiple times and Patrick is the best realtor I've ever worked with!

Fantastic experience: Mary Allen was great to work with, and the results speak for themselves! Ask Mary personally what we sold my house for beyond data fed market value at the time we started the process. :)

Fantastic experience: Mary Allen is wonderful to work with, she listens and clarifies with you as to the type of home you are looking for. She is very knowledgeable, professional and enjoyable actively searching for what you want. I have recommended Mary Allen to all my family and friends, and when anyone asks me to suggest a realtor I always recommend her.

Fantastic experience: Mary was the best! She was kind, caring, informative, extremely knowledgeable and precise at every level. Since this was my first time going through something like this Mary explained everything in ways so there was no doubt that I understood what was going on and what to do and what needed to be done. Mary's the best and I would recommend her to anyone. I love my condo it's the best and has pretty much everything already in it that I need. Thank you so very much and take care!

Fantastic experience: We wouldn't choose anyone else. Jeanne, Erin and Lisa have done an outstanding job of guiding us through two moves. They always have our best interests in mind, and their specific knowledge and insight helped us to achieve excellent results. Thanks to their help we sold our last house for significantly more than anyone was predicting or even hoping for, and used the proceeds to purchase a home that we never dreamed we could own. Also the entire team are wonderful people, lovely and easy to work with and good listeners.

Fantastic experience: We had an outstanding experience working with Sue and The Columbus Team. Sue is incredibly experienced in real estate, and she was able to point out pros and cons of every property we looked at that we would have otherwise missed. Her knowledge of the area helped us find properties in places we never would have thought to look, and she was always open to check out some places we found along the way. When we found our eventual home in Mount Vernon (our first choice of where to live), she went to bat for us from making the offer all the way through signing. We never once felt we were doing this alone. We truly felt like we had a coach, a mentor, and a friend.

Fantastic experience: We recently moved from Idaho to Columbus and had no real idea of where to settle in Columbus. Sue Lusk-Gleich was recommended by a colleague and we couldn't be more thankful for working with Sue. Even before we flew to Columbus to look at houses, she asked us to let her know what type of houses spoke to us on the MLS and why. She developed a fast sense of what we are looking for and after a few showings we were able to be really specific in what houses we toured and which neighborhood. We ended up buying a place in Merion Village which we adore. In this competitive market, Sue was the big difference who ensured that our offer was accepted and the sale went through without a hitch. I cannot recommend her and her team enough. She will be in your corner every step of the way, especially if you are an out of town buyer.

Fantastic experience: Sue Lusk-Gleich and her group at KW Capital Partners/The Columbus Team made the recent sale of our condo in the Reed Rd/Henderson Rd area easy! She provided advice on preparing the unit for sale which resulted in multiple offers over asking price in a matter of days. Closing was a breeze even from out-of-town. We have used Sue Lusk-Gleich for real estate purchases and sales since 1978 and it has always been an outstanding experience beyond our expectations.

Fantastic experience: Working with Sue is always a joy. She is friendly, professional and very knowledgeable. Our family always go to Sue when it comes to selling or buying our homes. Our last adventure was the fall 2022 on our mothers home in Clintonville/Beechwold area, Sue made this sale so smooth, THANK YOU Sue for always being there for our family

Fantastic experience: Columbus Team took selling my home in Clintonville seriously from day one. The detailed attention given to researching the history of my unique home (and going above and beyond to share info including links, QR codes and colorful flyers for buyers to answer any potential questions), staging, photographing, listing, showing and closing we’re a dream come true. Sue knows the market and how to price fairly to ensure buyer interest. I was overwhelmed by the friendliness and professionalism of the entire team and ultimately a successful closing in just two weeks after accepting an offer well over asking price. Don’t look anywhere else if you’re ready to buy or sell in Columbus.

Fantastic experience: We love The Columbus Team and have recommended them to several friends. They helped us purchase our starter home, our retirement home, and a couple homes in between. Sue and Erin have a talent for helping you find the home that is a perfect fit at the perfect time. We have used them for homes in Linden, Pataskala, Delaware County, and Clintonville. They listen closely during showings and narrow the search to homes that meet your current needs. Sue and Lisa gave us great guidance in the sale of our homes. Helping with house prep, staging, and pricing. Each home buy or sell was handled smoothly by the entire team. You can’t go wrong choosing The Columbus Team.

Fantastic experience: Terry is the best kind of realtor. She knows her stuff but she lets you decide what works for you. She doesn't bend things in her favor or push you in directions that make her job easier. She gives you the needed information. Does the reaching out and negotiation and keeps you in the loop. If you aren't ready she is patient and waits till the timing works for you. If you are looking for a realtor who treats you like a friend with experience and knowledge....Terry is your agent.

Fantastic experience: Terry was the very best and we are super happy with the way the experience went. I would definitely recommend her to others..Love our new home!!!

Fantastic experience: Stefanie Halbert was an excellent realtor who really cares about her clients, is very professional, and did a great job of promoting my house. The whole team had all parts handled well, from start to finish. I highly recommend Stefanie and the whole team.

Fantastic experience: Stefanie was so professional and had an excellent offer for us in less than a week. She staged our house without any additional cost to us. It looked soooo good. And again at no additional cost she had a superior photographer take pictures. This resulted in an awesome flyer and an online video with music. To top it off drone shots of the house were included. She was in constant communication with us every step of the way. Could not have asked for a better experience. SOLD.

Fantastic experience: We couldn't be happier with The Columbus Team! Sue was incredibly responsive, knowledgeable, honest, and super enjoyable to work with. We live in MA and were not sure how house-hunting would go given that distance, but The Columbus Team made it easy. Sue listened to our needs/wishes and within just a few (remote/in-person) viewings realized what we were looking for. Thus, we didn't spend a lot of time looking at houses that weren't a match. Sometimes when looking on the web, we would think a house might be a match and Sue would first check it out without us and note any disqualifying attributes. Everyone in the office was very attentive to our needs, and they really seem to thrive on finding the perfect house for their customers. If we could give 10 stars, we would!

Fantastic experience: Sue Lusk-Gleich was able to help us find the perfect home for us! In late 2021 she helped us with our search, and was great at finding homes that were within our budget and preferences. We found our home in December and finally closed mid-January 2022, finding a home in the Devonshire neighborhood. She was able to assist us through every step of the process and always made sure we understood everything, which is priceless to a first-time home buyer. Sue treated us like a member of her family, and I felt well taken care of from the beginning of our search to when our keys entered the locks! We couldn't thank her enough for helping us find our perfect home ❤️

Fantastic experience: Best team on the planet. Sue and the team put all their resources and effort into you finding your home and will be there as a level head when you aren't sure or need a valuable second opinion. They put YOU first and never pressure you into a bad choice. Our experience made us unable to look anywhere else. This is the best team out there and going anywhere else is a waste of your time, money and most importantly sanity.

Fantastic experience: The Columbus Team helped me throughout the entire buying process! 10/10 would recommend!

Fantastic experience: Sue Gleich made selling my home super easy. I was in a rough situation and Sue just made my experience easy and low stress. She was extremely responsive and kept me updated every step of the way. I would highly recommend her and her company again.

Fantastic experience: Patrick and the Columbus Team exceeded our expectations from the start. They were genuine, thoughtful and hardworking on top of great communicators.

Fantastic experience: Great team, they make the process simple and communicate clearly.

Fantastic experience: This WHOLE team was kind, knowledgeable, fast acting and a very easy to work with when it came to helping my family and I purchase our new home ! I (will) definitely recommend this team to anyone I know or meet along the way. Thanks again Columbus Team for making these positives all happen !!

Fantastic experience: We recently purchased a house with the help of Pat Florence. He is very knowledgeable, kind, and professional. He was available to answer any questions we had, and he made the process enjoyable. We will use him again in the future! Highly recommend.

Fantastic experience: Thanks so much for your help Mary Allen

Fantastic experience: When I needed a savvy realtor to help me sell my condo in Victorian Village, where I've lived for 25 years, I obviously wanted someone who came highly recommended. My partner had worked with Erin Oxender with The Columbus Team for over ten years and had only positive things (exemplary, actually) to say. I contacted Erin a year before I wanted to put my home on the market, to be sure and plan ahead for any remodeling that she might suggest would earn me the greatest return on my investment. She was blunt (but tactful) about removing all the wallpaper throughout my home (which I had personally picked out years earlier!), repainting, and about putting the place on the market in move-in-condition, that is, with nothing inside except the appliances that were staying. I was impressed that she telephoned me six months later unsolicited. It lit the fire under me to get things moving along. She and an expert from the Team in getting homes ready for sale visited soon after, and we went over what needed to be done. Since I was consolidating households with my partner, I needed to get rid of a lot of "stuff" (furniture, books, knickknacks, wall art, area rugs) before moving. Erin had a list of available contractors for painting, wallpaper removal, moving, junk removal, among other things, that her firm has worked over the years and that she recommended. After contacting several contractors on her list and because I was planning well in advance of my projected listing date (thanks to Erin's guidance), I had everything scheduled that I needed to with contractors that I trusted. Moving is stressful (understatement); no doubt about it. But throughout the three month process, Erin kept in touch, helped me fill out the paperwork, and carefully explained what her estimate was for selling price--and why. The moving--and all the contract work involved--was completed--and to my specifications--in time for the target listing date . I was really impressed with the on-line listing and marketing of my home that Erin had arranged soon afterwards. A photographer came out, and in addition to beautifully taken photographs, he used a drone to film an aerial view, which was part of the on-line listing. To make a long story short, the first people who looked at my home made an offer--at a price that gave me the return on investment I sought. Several homes in the area have taken longer to sell recently, so I was ecstatic. Unquestionably, it was her list of suggestions about that expedited the sale. Throughout the final paperwork and closing process, Erin guided me every step of the way, along with her thoroughly knowledgeable professional staff. The closing took place on time, and with complete efficiency. In summary, Erin and her staff went above and beyond what I had experienced from other realtors I've used. Her kind, cheerful manner helped along the way as well! She--and the Columbus Team at Keller Williams--have my strong recommendation.

Fantastic experience: I have worked with Patrick Florence a couple times before and have always been extremely satisfied. He is professional and kind. I will refer him to anyone I know moving in or out of the Columbus area. He was always available to answer my questions & always kept me updated as the process moved along. I cannot say enough good about him. He was great & I appreciated all of his hard work!!

Fantastic experience: The Columbus Team was amazing! Every member of the team was professional and always ready answer any questions or concerns. A new chapter when moving from our home of 30 years was made easier. Sue was a blast to work with and so helpful in taking the emotion out of the sale in order to make a wise business choice. Loved Lisa and her staging suggestions, what a great perk when selling your home. Thank you to the entire team! If you are thinking of selling your home they are your source!

Fantastic experience: Mary Allen and the Columbus Team were great to work with! Mary is very knowledgeable, professional and experienced as a Realtor and I always felt like I was in good hands working with her. She responded promptly to texts and calls and although I know she is very busy I never felt like she was too busy for me and my needs or questions. Mary is great at explaining things about the house buying process in a patient and thorough way which was very helpful and much appreciated. I felt like Mary was on top of everything and I never felt anxious about any details that Mary was taking care of for me. I knew she would get it done! The other thing that I loved about working with Mary is that she has a great sense of humor and very personable. I had a lot of fun working with her and going through houses with her. I learned a lot about houses because she has a keen eye and knows what details to look for in a house. I also enjoyed working with the Columbus Team members who were always available to answer questions and help me navigate the house buying process. I was impressed with everyone that helped me throughout the house buying process. Thanks to you all!

Fantastic experience: We had an excellent experience with the Columbus Team. Mary Allen was our agent. She was helpful, friendly, available, supportive during the good and not-so-good times of scouting for a house to buy in this difficult seller's market. We highly recommend her to others looking to buy a house.